Yeah. Since it's a 5 wt, I assume you're not chasing huge fish here.
So frankly, for 99% of my fishing, I view a reel as little more than a place to hold my line. It's primary concerns are:
1. Look good
2. Balance the rod well.
3. Don't break.
I'll only discuss #2. Test it. Put reel on rod, string line through (that part's important), find balance point. Should be near the front of cork. A little beyond or back isn't a big deal, but within a few inches of the end of the cork. If it's way out the rod, the reel is too light. If its near the base of the handle, it's too heavy.
Since you don't have the reel to test with, test it with some reels you already have. If none are just right, then note which are too heavy, too light, etc. Then tear off all the line and backing, and weigh them empty. Wife's kitchen scale works 🙂. You'll get an idea of the weight you need. Now look for new reel with that weight.
Most modern reels work pretty good on 9 ft graphite sticks. I only run into problems with boo and/or exceptionally long or short rods.