I flew with Southwest with a fly rod in a case that was 4 ft, 6 inches long, and they let me carry it on and put it in the overhead bin.
Whether that fit their stated rules, or whether they just gave me a break, I'm not sure. But there was no problem.
This was a case with the reel the attached. If they make you check it, take the reel off and carry that. Stuff some newspaper to fill the space in the reel pouch, so the rod doesn't slide in there, as that is less protected than the tube, then check it.
The PVC tube in the case is tough and should protect the rod in the storage bin. The chances of it breaking are very slim.