pcray1231 wrote:
I can honestly say I've never had Vibram soled wading boots returned due to the sole wearing out.
My Simms G3's are nearly flat after 2 years of very light fishing, probably 20ish outings (I don't fish anywhere near as much as I used to due to life).
I went internet searching and discovered that there are lots and lots of reports of the same, 20-30 outings is the expected lifetime if walking on rock. Simms even acknowledges as such, though defends their choice of materials by saying that other rubbers are too dangerous. From another site, here is a Simms response copied and pasted.
Good Morning,
Thank you for contacting Simms in regards to your Freestone boot and your question on the wear of Streamtread.
While I realize that Streamtread does wear down, I do need to point out a number of points that will hopefully explain to you the hows and whys, as well as providing you a link to a listing of authorized Vibram cobbler shops that we work with in regards to getting Simms wading boots re-soled.
First, the wear issue. . . in order for the rubber compound to actually work in the slick and nasty environment that it lives in, it needs to be of a “hardness” that will grip the rock and provide traction in those challenging conditions. What he have seen is that in order to actually perform, it needs to be soft enough to mold and grab that which it travels over. If Streamtread was built and molded like a hiking boot outsole, it would not work, the hardness of the rubber would not grip the rock and you would slip and slide all over the place. Now, the outsole tread and lugs would certainly last longer, but you may not care that much as you would more than likely be picking yourself up out of the river with some frequency.
Then there is the comparison to felt. A new felt sole is 12mm thick. A brand new Streamtread is 3mm thick. Comparatively, it will outlast felt 2 to 1, but as felt is 4 times as thick to begin with. . . well, it doesn’t take too much math to figure that one out. While there is no perfect solution to any of this, I feel that we offer a great product that works well and is something that can be re-soled. Speaking of which, here is a link to the shops that we recommend our customers to. We do not do this work here. . . but they can certainly help you and I have heard nothing but good reports.
http://www.simmsfishing.com/site/streamtread.html
I actually consider that a very informative and fair response from Simms. i.e., they acknowledge a trade-off between grip and longevity. They acknowledge that they leaned in the direction of grip and performance. They even give a comparison to felt (which, if you do the math, says the typical felt sole will last twice as long). And knowing the shortcoming, they put together a network of cobblers authorized to resole your Simms boots as needed.
The only problem for me is that the nearest cobbler is in Philly, a pretty good drive, and would cost close to as much as a new pair of boots anyway. But that's life today. What else is new. I do agree that, when new, the performance of their rubber is superior to other rubber soles I have tried.
Aside from wading boots, I have been wearing a model of hiking boot almost daily for years now. My most used footwear overall. It just fits me perfect and is comfortable. I'm on my 4th pair, and need to buy a 5th. The prior 3 all failed in the same manner. Soles wore flat, till they wore through and started letting water come up from the bottom. Yep, vibram soles, and fairly soft.... This happens well before the uppers wear out, although it helps that the uppers are leather, and I'm a crazy man about keeping my leather properly cared for (I highly recommend Obenhauf's Heavy Duty LP, if it's of any use to you).
I'll buy a 5th anyway.
Everything has trade-offs. Everything wears out. In this case the biggest negative comes from optimizing the most important positive attribute of any boot. Grip.