moon1284 wrote:
Why is a 10' 4 weight considered an upgrade from a 8'6" 4 weight?
It sounds more like a more specialized rod that will be better than the 8'6" in a couple situations, but worse in others. I'm sure the longer rod is better for tight line or indicator nymphing but I don't use those tactics.
For dry flies or dry/dropper, I strongly prefer a shorter rod. The problem I have with longer light line rods is that they don't balance very well unless you hang a fairly heavy reel on it. To me, a setup like this isn't very comfortable for overhead casting.