Dear kc,
I'm a diabetic with poor circulation so I know a bit about keeping my feet warm and comfortable in the Winter.
You need a thin silk or poly liner sock on your foot first. Without these thin socks to pass moisture from sweat away from your skin to the outer socks you're dead in the water before you start.
For an outer sock I'm partial to 100% wool but there are many different socks that will do the job. Just make sure you don't wear socks that are too thick, they can be too confining in your waders and actually make you colder by not allowing movement of your toes or allowing moisture to be quickly wicked away.
Bootfoot waders are much warmer than stockingfoot waders and wading shoes but you may not have that choice and all bootfoot waders are definitely not equal. Uninsulated or poorly insulated bootfoot waders aren't worth much.
If you are in the market for new waders or wading shoes make sure you try them on with the sock setup you plan on wearing in the Winter. It's important to know everything fits properly and you have the ability to wiggle your toes and feet inside the waders. Stuffing your feet in with an inch of socks can create more trouble than it solves.
Regards,
Tim Murphy 🙂