Vest or sling pack

Vest or waist pack for me.
Never could get the hang of a sling thing.
 
When I first started FFing as a kid, I used a creel like the one pictured below to hold my fly stuff. It seemed that every fly-fisherman I ran into dissed me. While unfortunately some FFers ARE a-holes, but I later realized many thought I was out there to catch a limit and put trout in my "creel" rather than practising C&R and just using the bag to hold my flies and tippet. LOL.

1774794335535.png
 
When I first started FFing as a kid, I used a creel like the one pictured below to hold my fly stuff. It seemed that every fly-fisherman I ran into dissed me. While unfortunately some FFers ARE a-holes, but I later realized many thought I was out there to catch a limit and put trout in my "creel" rather than practising C&R and just using the bag to hold my flies and tippet. LOL.

View attachment 1641250056
I used that same creel for a lot of years, but I used it as a substitute for a vest to hold my fishing stuff, not to hold trout. It had a measure on it that I'd occasionally use, like for this 12" native.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5801.JPEG
    IMG_5801.JPEG
    204 KB · Views: 47
I use a Fishpond Cross CurrentI can attach a Gear keeper retractor to the bottom of the test pack for my wading staff, and another gear keeper to the top of the back pack for my net. Works great for me...

I use Gear Keepers for my wading staff and a net when I carry one, but for more flexibility and positioning, I don't use the included snap hook or the threaded stud to attach them.

I use either the correct size Rotating Belt Clip and attach it to my belt or depending on the rig, I bought the corresponding Rotating MOLLE Mount and attach it to my gear pouch.

Both accessories can be purchased direct from Gear Keeper and installed on the RT2 or RT4 retractor body in a few minutes.
 
I used that same creel for a lot of years, but I used it as a substitute for a vest to hold my fishing stuff, not to hold trout. It had a measure on it that I'd occasionally use, like for this 12" native.

I can't tell if yours is the same one and I know there are a lot of those soft sided creels out there, but the one I remember is the "Arctic Creel" made of Flax/Linen from Belgium.

Take a gander at what these go for new and even used on eBay:


If you have an Arctic Creel, you may want to show it some respect. 😉
 
Last edited:
Whatever your preference, I think its pretty nice to have so many choices to carry your "stuff" on the stream.

When I started out, everybody wore vests.
Pretty much all you had at the time
And I just got used to wearing one

Some of my friends also used the Richardson chest boxes to carry their flies in.
I did try out their boxes a few times, just to see how I would like them.
And I didn't care for them.
To me, it just didn't make much sense to have 4-5 trays of flies crammed onto the front of your chest at all times. Right where I'm busy tying new flies and tippets on, along with landing and releasing fish.
Allways liked the way a vest has many pockets to spread my fly boxes and accesseries out.

I like to wade deep too, and really appreciate the "shorty" option you have with them too
Keeping my stuff pretty much above the water surface.

Being able to hang my net on a magnet/cord on back of the vest is a plus for me too.
Still a little more out of the way than just stuffing it down my waders.

And a big back pocket to carry a packable rain jacket if rain threatens
 
I can't tell if yours is the same one and I know there are a lot of those soft sided creels out there, but the one I remember is the "Arctic Creel" made of Flax/Linen from Belgium.

Take a gander at what these go for new and even used on eBay:


If you have an Arctic Creel, you may want to show it some respect. 😉
I can’t tell you how old this thing is, I’m 67 and had from a teenager. It’s held up well don’t really use it anymore.
IMG_0755.jpeg
 
My cheap vest ripped on my last trip out so i now need to buy a replacement.
What is your favorite vest or sling pack and why?
My problem with a sling pack, which I had GREAT HOPE for when they 1st came out, was that, when I needed something, I always had to dig into my "purse" and try to find where it was packed in the darkness of the pack. Fly boxes aren't an issue. They are easy to find and dig out. Maybe it's because I'm so used to a vest that it's easy to store and then later, find what I need. Plus the vest makes carrying something like water or a rain jacket easier. Maybe if someone who uses a sling pack showed me their methodology, I'd switch, but in leu of that, I stick with the vest. Mine is an LL Bean jobbie that replaced an Orvis that was really nice that was dropped and stolen . They keep updating and "improving" vests so that now, there are hardly any around and few I like. Fishpond is about it. Simms is good, but way, way too expensive.
 
My problem with a sling pack, which I had GREAT HOPE for when they 1st came out, was that, when I needed something, I always had to dig into my "purse" and try to find where it was packed in the darkness of the pack. Fly boxes aren't an issue. They are easy to find and dig out. Maybe it's because I'm so used to a vest that it's easy to store and then later, find what I need. Plus the vest makes carrying something like water or a rain jacket easier. Maybe if someone who uses a sling pack showed me their methodology, I'd switch, but in leu of that, I stick with the vest. Mine is an LL Bean jobbie that replaced an Orvis that was really nice that was dropped and stolen . They keep updating and "improving" vests so that now, there are hardly any around and few I like. Fishpond is about it. Simms is good, but way, way too expensive.
If your vest works for you just continue with it. But I switched to a sling pack (Orvis Guide Sling)15 years ago.

I have it set up in a way where I rarely have to "sling" it around to get at my stuff. I have all my essentials up front attached to the strap (sort of like a lanyard) > tippet spools, hemos, nippers, floatant, fly box (loaded with flies I expect to use that day).

In the sling itself I have my larger (unabridged) fly boxes, extra leaders, headlamp, thermometer as well as other misc. FFing stuff along with water, a snack and usually a light rain jacket.

Seldom do I have to access the sling yet I can carry everything I need (and probably don't need) with the bulk stuff sitting behind me out of my way.

Oh, and I carry my net attached to the D ring behind me attached with a heavy-duty zinger that I can easily reach back to use the net and have it retract when the monster trout is back in the water. HTH.
 
The best pack for me is the William Joseph surge. It's a lumbar with the magnetic closures (No zippers). They went out of business. I own two of them and hope to keep the them functioning for the rest of my life. I expect they might wear out before that.
 
Used to use a vest when I first started fly fishing.

I've been using an Orvis sling pack now for probably 7 years, still going strong. It's the standard size.

Also have the guide size, which is bigger. I use that if I am in a little bit more remote of an area and want to carry more gear like a rain coat or more water.

I've set mine up so each pocket serves a different function whether it be for fly boxes, leaders, spare tippet spools, streamside tools, license, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RH1
Advice if you decide on a sling pack: throw a second pair of nippers in your pack. I have one pair on the strap and always seem to need them after I pulled the bag around to change flies. The second pair saves a lot of back and forth

Steve
This is the most real advice I have ever read.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scs
Advice if you decide on a sling pack: throw a second pair of nippers in your pack. I have one pair on the strap and always seem to need them after I pulled the bag around to change flies. The second pair saves a lot of back and forth

Steve
This is why I have a lanyard that hangs across my wader straps. It carries my nippers, forceps, flotant, a cork and sometimes tippet. Keeps it right in front where it’s easy to get yet not in the way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scs
Pack that I use; small enough to stay out of the way, large enough for three fly boxes and some miscellaneous.
 
70 years of fly fishing & I prefer the vest. I know exactly where each fly box is located. There is much better organization with a vest than a sling. There are some chest packs that can provide good storage but if it rains it's hard to zipper up a rain jacket wearing a chest pack. On my annual Montana trip I am a minimalist. A small chest pack with enough room for two fly boxes, nippers, forceps, tippet, & a bottle of dessicant.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20260331_192542_Samsung Internet.jpg
    Screenshot_20260331_192542_Samsung Internet.jpg
    52.3 KB · Views: 27
Back
Top