Vest or sling pack

Dear RH1

It depends on what fish I am chasing at the moment. I ditched the vest 30 years ago when I realized my vest and my 4-tray chest box combined weighed more than a set of 3XL rubber chest waders filled with water! I desperately needed and wanted to lighten the load.

I have an Umpqua Chest pack that I bought 20 years ago that covers my trout fishing. It carries 4 or 5 boxes including a multi-leaf Wheatley nymph box in the front pouch with room in the back for streamers and junk flies. It's easy enough to undo one side strap and roll it around my head to switch tactics or dig something out of the larger rear section that I need.

For bass or warmwater I have a sling and a hip pack. I have tippet spools on a tender and tools like nippers and hemostats on a carabiner that I can swap around.

Regardless of what the quarry is, I have a larger gear bag that holds multiple boxes of various flies that I will switch out in any of my packs depending on how I want to fish that day.

I used to want to cover every conceivable scenario at all times. I've long since outgrown that mentality and now I pick things I think should work and commence!

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Last edited:
I'm a sling pack guy, but have friends who love the vest. I say try it and see, if you don't like it sell it and move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RH1
I use an Orvis sling pack, and I've used the same one for a long time. I have used a chest pack, a vest, and a sling pack. I think the chest pack actually might have been my favorite, but mine was very small. I tried a vest for a while. I didn't like it. I went back to the sling pack. I might purchase another chest pack this year and give that a go again, though.
 
After years of various vest digging into my neck. I found a Fishpond vest that I love. It is very comfortable.
 
I'm a vest guy. I like a vest because I can carry more fly boxes in it than a chest pack. I am also an aggressive wader that finds myself up to my waist in water too often, so that rules out hip packs and most slings. Another strike against slings is I am not into a strap around my neck. A smaller size sling would probably be comfortable but it won't hold my stuff.

View attachment 1641250009
Dude, I love my fly banjo.
 
I've used a vest, a fishpond waterdance guide, and just acquired a sling. Like the pack but it will not hold a net well. Picked up a sling but haven't tried it out yet next week I'll find out which is better sling or pack.
Good luck in your pick .
 
  • Like
Reactions: RH1
My cheap vest ripped on my last trip out so i now need to buy a replacement.
What is your favorite vest or sling pack and why?

If you are new to the game, your head will explode with options and reasons...

It's not what I do, but if I was using a vest and it worked for me but it ripped...

I just buy a new (and maybe better) vest with the same number of pockets and go fishing...
 
  • Like
Reactions: RH1
When I was a kid, I had an eagle claw creel, with two or three pockets on the front. I kept most of my fly boxes and stuff in the big fish pocket since I rarely any trout.

IMG_4681.webp

Then when I needed to be cool, I got a vest and spent the next few decades always being confused about which boxes were in which pockets.

About 10 years ago, I started using a version of the old kid’s creel, though much bigger and sturdier.


IMG_4682.jpeg
Say what you will about my purse, but I’ve got leader material and tippet in one front pocket, sinkers, dry fly float, and indicators (bobbers) in the other.

All my fly boxes for the day are in the main pouch.

In many ways, it makes me feel like a kid again.

I like the purse, but, as Sheryl crow says, “if it makes you happy, it can’t be that bad.”
 
Last edited:
I used to use a vest ,but witnessed people just having an easier time with a murse.

A murse makes changing jackets or lowering waders easier for me.

Like Jim Kennedy, I keep tippet and leaders in a front pocket,floatant etc in another and fly boxes in the main pocket
 
A couple of years ago I retired my vest. I had 4-5 beginning in the mid seventies. I have an issue with over packing. I have a very serious case of TMS Syndrome. My last vest had so many pockets that I would take my vest off at the end of the day and find that box of flies that I could not find stream-side. I bought an Orvis chest pack. It required more discipline as it reduced carrying capacity and everything was right under my nose. I also have a bad neck and the chest pack reduced the strain on the back of my neck and shoulders. I considered a side sling pack but could not stand the thought of having to move it from back to front to access. IMHO for what it’s worth.
 
Say what you will about my purse, but I’ve got leader material and tippet in one front pocket, sinkers, dry fly float, and indicators (bobbers) in the other.
I like the purse, but, as Sheryl crow says, “if it makes you happy, it can’t be that bad.”
I used to use a vest ,but witnessed people just having an easier time with a murse.

A murse makes changing jackets or lowering waders easier for me.

It's a satchel, not a purse!
 
I have a roughly 25 year old Filson strap vest that I love, mostly because when I was learning 45+ year ago, I wanted to look like the old pipe smoking geezers and that image just stuck. Perfect for my mostly blue line fishing, and it has the clearance in the front to add a Richardson chest box (also a geezer accoutrement from my youth) that my fishing buddy refers to as “the accordion”
 
I use a Fishpond Cross CurrentI can attach a Gear keeper retractor to the bottom of the test pack for my wading staff, and another gear keeper to the top of the back pack for my net. Works great for me. Also Fishpond makes a larger backpack called Ridgeline which you can switch out the smaller pack if you need more storage space for longer trips or whatever. Dave Kyle mentioned the same setup in a previous post , so I tried it and it works great. Only downside is the whole setup will set you back about $300 .
 
  • Like
Reactions: RH1
I use a Fishpond Cross CurrentI can attach a Gear keeper retractor to the bottom of the test pack for my wading staff, and another gear keeper to the top of the back pack for my net. Works great for me. Also Fishpond makes a larger backpack called Ridgeline which you can switch out the smaller pack if you need more storage space for longer trips or whatever. Dave Kyle mentioned the same setup in a previous post , so I tried it and it works great. Only downside is the whole setup will set you back about $300 .
I was just looking at the canyon creek chest pack. Looks about perfect for the couple of creeks that I fish locally. Wonder if I could rig a water bottle holder on that pack
 
Back
Top