Another vote for Subaru. I bought a 2011 Forester (non-turbo) about 8 years ago mostly because it had a 5 speed stick, and I love it. It's not fast but if you're willing to rev it the torque really punches in over 3000 RPM. So you can merge when you have to. It had 48000 miles on it, and it burned the same amount of oil as gas. I mentioned that to the local sub dealer, he said he'd do an oil consumption test which he did, he said mine was the worst he'd ever seen. Then he got me a new engine, no charge, even tho I didn't buy it from him. It was apparently a hidden warranty, he said they replaced an engine every week. It runs fine now and burns a quart of oil about every 6 months.
I have slept in it, I'm 6 feet tall, but certainly it's tight. My dog fit with me but no way 2 guys could sleep in it unless you're really friendly. (I won't say anything about les*****). For one guy tho it's fine, and it holds all the gear you'd need. A rod longer than 9 feet would require some bending or a take-down however.
Outbacks are a little bigger but to me the roofline seems lower or the windows are smaller, or something, not as good visibility. Sorry if you Outback guys are offended. I'm currently thinking about an Ascent which gives you about 10 more cubic feet than an Outback, but mileage isn't good. And a problem for me is the ubiquitous Subaru CVT transmission. CVTs just seem creepy to me. I wish they still offered sticks.
Speaking about Defenders, Hyundai just redesigned and enlarged the Santa Fe (to look like a Land Rover) and it looks almost perfect. Plus a great warranty. Mileage again not great but this summer the hybrid arrives which gives you 30 mpg. It offers AWD but only 7 inches of ground clearance, but they have a raised model that's 8.4 inches.
I'm cheap and never owned a pickup truck. Except for an FJ Cruiser once which looked totally cool. But any back seat passenger complained about the coffin-like poor visibility back there. And it was one of the 2 lemons ever built by Toyota. I owned the other one too. No more Toyotas for me.
Minivans have enticied me but they are not cooler than Subarus. I've rented minivans for long family trips and once for a week long fishing/camping excursion. They certainly have a lot of room, but with the low load floor I felt like I was sleeping on the ground. I guess I could get used to it.