Valley Creek, Chester/Montgomery County - 22/Dec/23

wgmiller

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
3,213
City
Lancaster County
I had some business to tend to in New Jersey Friday afternoon, so I decided to make a stop at Valley during my travels east along the PA Turnpike. I had never fished Valley before, bur have read much about it. I knew it was a highly pressured stream, due to its proximity to population centers. Given the heavy rain we had last weekend, I had been following the USGS gauge and saw it dropping like a rock. It was in prime shape by the time I got on the water on Friday. I didn't have high expectations with Valley, given the pressure it sees, but more than anything was curious to fish in a national park. Admittedly, I had never been to Valley Forge NP before, so it was neat to take in a few sights and envision what it must have been like a few hundred years ago when troops holed up in the region.

As far as fishing goes, I started around 8:30 and fished from just below the Knox covered bridge up to Bradford Road. I didn't see another angler until I reached the area around Lafayette's quarters. There I ran into two other fly anglers, so I moved past them and continued fishing upstream. The ambient temperature never really warmed up and it remained in the low to mid-30s the entire time. The sun never came out and I didn't see any airborne bug activity. I ended with a dozen fish or so of varying sizes, with a 9"(ish) fish being the biggest. I fished a point/dropper rig with a #14 metallic pink bead heat Walt's Worm as the point and a #20 red jig midge as the dropper. Almost all fish were taken on the Walt's Worm.

I did explore the area below Valley Forge Road and found some interesting water, but no fish. Access was a bit trickier in this area and you can really see how floods have ravaged the lower portion of the stream. I wrapped up my fishing around 1:30 with some sightseeing around Washington's headquarters, etc. I think Valley is a stream every angler should fish at least once, for no other reason than its location. I can easily see why it sees the pressure it does and can only envision what it looks like on a nice spring or summer day. While I was able to fish it at 43 CFS, I know it goes a lot lower than that and can only image how skinny it gets.

IMG_2035.JPEG

Knox Covered Bridge

IMG_2041.JPEG

Stream conditions via the USGS gauge just south of the turnpike.

IMG_2048.JPEG

Dressed for the weather - overall not a bad day to be out, as temps were at least above freezing.

IMG_2038.JPEG

Valley Creek brown

IMG_2052.JPG



IMG_2046.jpeg

The nicest fish of the day.

IMG_2058.JPEG

Life in these huts must have been brutal
 
Geo nice write up and thanks for sharing. Glad to see you getting into a few fish there on VC. I was driving past the cabins with my wife last week and thinking how brutal it must have been living there in Valley Forge during the winter almost 250 years ago.
 
That's a nice report..I have also never wet a line in Valley. Some day I will give it a try.
 
Well done. A dozen fish on Valley is a great day.

I'm not gonna lie, since switching over to tightlining tactics a few years back, my success rate on the water has completely changed - for the better. It's not for everyone, I get it. But being in contact with my flies and managing my drifts has really made me a better angler.

Merry Christmas to all!
 
I'm not gonna lie, since switching over to tightlining tactics a few years back, my success rate on the water has completely changed - for the better. It's not for everyone, I get it. But being in contact with my flies and managing my drifts has really made me a better angler.

Merry Christmas to all!
From small streams to huge tailwaters, there ain’t nothin better. Fly line is more of a detriment to fly fishing than perhaps anything else.
 
Nice report. Interesting creek. I have caught a few there in early spring on midges and blue wings. There are definitely a few bigger fish around but all the ones I got were about like yours. go back after a rain with a streamer for a bigger one. The day I was there I had the section I fished all to my self.
 
Nice report. Interesting creek. I have caught a few there in early spring on midges and blue wings. There are definitely a few bigger fish around but all the ones I got were about like yours. go back after a rain with a streamer for a bigger one. The day I was there I had the section I fished all to my self.

Yes, plenty of fish in the 4-8" range, with a few smaller here and there. I've seen videos of larger fish being caught and can see why a little bit of rain and a streamer would work wonders. The bigger boys and girls know when to come out and play!
 
Yes, plenty of fish in the 4-8" range, with a few smaller here and there. I've seen videos of larger fish being caught and can see why a little bit of rain and a streamer would work wonders.
There have been a few pics posted here of some really nice (16"-18") browns from Valley. They are in there!
 
Great report, I fish VC often since I used to live 10 mins away in Wayne and now just a little bit further in Downingtown. The stream sees a ton of pressure, but for better or worse those are some resilient fish between the random water main breaks, stream erosion, and angler pressure. I enjoy the national park section the most lately, over the years I've changed up where my go to spot is. The stream changes with basically each rain event.

The lower section can be fruitful, but I've found it to be hit or miss. Sometimes you'll get visitors from other streams like this brook trout I caught:

1703776399968.png



There have been a few pics posted here of some really nice (16"-18") browns from Valley. They are in there!

That they are, I have caught a few myself. I don't feel too bad posting this trout, as its been a year since I caught it, but I try to be mindful where I take pictures since the stream is so recognizable. They are hard to get, but honestly catching those big fish on smaller water is some of the most rewarding fishing I've had:

1703776577488.png
 
Great report, I fish VC often since I used to live 10 mins away in Wayne and now just a little bit further in Downingtown. The stream sees a ton of pressure, but for better or worse those are some resilient fish between the random water main breaks, stream erosion, and angler pressure. I enjoy the national park section the most lately, over the years I've changed up where my go to spot is. The stream changes with basically each rain event.

The lower section can be fruitful, but I've found it to be hit or miss. Sometimes you'll get visitors from other streams like this brook trout I caught:

View attachment 1641233632




That they are, I have caught a few myself. I don't feel too bad posting this trout, as its been a year since I caught it, but I try to be mindful where I take pictures since the stream is so recognizable. They are hard to get, but honestly catching those big fish on smaller water is some of the most rewarding fishing I've had:

View attachment 1641233633

There is a club in downingtown that stocks west valley with brookies or at least they used to. I grew up in downingtown and learned to fly fish on west valley. fun lil creek in it's day. I haven't fished it in ages
 
West Chester Fish and Game club stocks West Valley Creek, but it is not in the same watershed as Valley Creek. West Valley dumps into the East Branch of the Brandywine. Valley Creek dumps into the Schuykill.
 
Back
Top