Unbalanced Rod-How to Make It Better

Dear redietz,

Name one type of fishing done with a fly rod that doesn't require controlling the level of the rod tip. I'll wait.

I'm not trying to be a jerk, but a tip heavy rod serves no purpose that I can imagine.

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
Streamer fishing, where the rod tip may pushed under the water to get the rod down. Or any type of fishing where keeping the rod parallel to surface is desirable. Poppers might be another exaple

i'm not at all arguing for tip heavy rods; only that balance isn't necessary for casting purposes. I personally can't stand an unbalanced set up.
 
I agree that tip heavy rods are a pain. Fish all day tip heavy and your wrist will feel it. I have quite a few 10’ rods. I like Allen reels because they tend to be heavier than other manufacturers. Your setup will feel lighter, even if the overall weight is heavier (with a larger reel) and it’s balanced.
 
For our OP: Rod balance is either something someone takes seriously or thinks is completely stupid, I'll go with the former.

I like to have it "balance" with about 10' of line out of the tip and having it sit on a finger about an inch or so from the tip of the handle, if I'm going to have it off that point, I'd rather have the short, butt, be heavier than the tip: Simply enough, holding something that wants to pull itself down all teh time is more taxing than the other way around. To me, it's not really about the casting stroke as much as the holding up.

Everything else is simply picking a reel that meets that point. I don't pay attention to the sizes as much, if it holds the line it holds the line. Sometimes it needs more backing, sometimes less. For better or worse, I'm not catching fisht hat are going into my backing anytime soon.

Bamboozle's advice is good, if.. a little intense. I don't have a spreadsheet, I just have a general idea.
 
Balancing a rod with a heavier reel is mechanically inefficient. If a rod is tip heavy it requires less additional mass to balance it by adding weight to the butt.

An easy way to do this is by adding a foam rubber end cap with a few coins or lead weights inside. The Fuji EWBC 21 butt cap includes three lead washers that can be placed into any foam endcap that fits your rod.


Cheap, effective, and reversible.

After you dial in a balance that you like, you can make the modification permanent if you want.
 
Last edited:
ledhead1944:

A couple of things I know...

The Orvis Hydros (if that's what you mean by "Hydrostatic") 5WF Trout line is a true-to weight 5wt line with the identical tip length and front taper length as the Mastery Trout WF5.

If I understand you correctly, you have these two lines on different reels as options. If so, if the amount of aerialized line, leader length, taper & tippet, line speed, fly size and rod are the same, the two lines SHOULD behave the same on any rod.

Combo balance as in static weight balance has nothing to do with anything except comfort and fatigue reduction.

Listen to what Tim Murphy said...

If you want to change the static balance point of your Midwest custom rod 9' 5wt combo, you want to use a heavier reel than the TFO NXT LA1 which has a stated weight of 4.7 oz. If you rod has an uplocking reel seat, that further exacerbates the balance problem.

FWIW - I like my combos to be static balanced with about 4-5 feet of line out in front of me on the ground or water and I like that balance point to be as close to the winding check as possible. I'll also add that all of my trout rods have downlocking reel seats.

To achieve that winding check balance point on a 9'0" 5wt graphite rod, I am using a reel with a stated empty weight of 5.5 ounces or about an ounce heavier than your reel empty.

Of course there is a chance both of our reels loaded with line & backing weigh the same, but I don't choose a reel for a rod that way. I made a chart with of all of my rod combos that includes just the rod length & material it is made from and the stated empty weight of the reel that balances it at or near the winding check.

The chart has never failed me when choosing a reel for new rod....

In regards to your question about using a 6wt line on the Midwest custom rod 9' 5wt. I don't know the rod, but a heavier line will always load a rod deeper into the blank, in effect slowing it down.

Depending on the blank, that isn't always a bad thing, but SOMETIMES a whole line size heavier is more than you need to get it to feel the way YOU want.

Experiment to your hearts content, but just focus on the factors that WILL make a difference.

Good luck!!
The rod is an uplocking seat. I didn't know what the meant and how that effects the rod. I didn't know what increasing a line size would do to the action and how the rod would feel either so thank you for that comments. 👍

This is all good information that I can add to my knowledgebase. Thanks!!
 
Just go fishing and don’t think about the tip. You be any worse for wear unless you think your way into being tired from a heavy tip. Balance is nothing but a sugar pill.
 
The rod is an uplocking seat. I didn't know what the meant and how that effects the rod. I didn't know what increasing a line size would do to the action and how the rod would feel either so thank you for that comments. 👍

This is all good information that I can add to my knowledgebase. Thanks!!

If you are old enough to have played on a "seesaw" or "teeter-totter," you would remember how sliding your butt to the very end would get your partner way up in the air.

The position of the reel in relation to the grip and the desired fulcrum or balance point does the same thing. That's why tip heavy longer rods are more easily balanced when the rod has a downlocking reel seat.
 
Dear ledhead,

You can solve the rod balance problem with a larger reel. You have already proven that to yourself.

The NXT 1 is a 3/4 weight reel and probably better suited for a rod of 8 ft or less. The 9 ft 5 weight will always be tip heavy with an undersized reel. The NXT 1 weighs 4.3 ounces and the Battenkill Disc lightest model weighs 4.9 ounces. That is the same weight as the NXT 3 which is a 7/8 weight reel. A little over 1/2 oz doesn't seem like much, but trust me, it makes a difference when trying to counterbalance a longer rod.

If it were me, I'd just use the Orvis Battenkill Disc and call it a day.

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
What he said. I will also add that rod/reel balance and line weight should mainly be considered separately.

You almost always want your rod tip up at an angle, rather than parallel to the ground or pointing down. Every increment you need to spend bringing the tip up to level reduces your chance of hooking a fish because the hook setting doesn't kick in until the rod tip is past even with the ground / water surface. As such, a too-heavy reel that throws the balance upwards is a good thing, especially if you're new to the sport.

Line weight is a more nuanced thing. Strictly speaking, a 5wt rod is made to cast a 5wt level line. If you want the delicate presentation you get with a double taper, in most cases you're going to want a 6wt line, especially on a fast action rod. If you're going with a weight forward, on that 5wt rod, a 5wt line is probably still what you want, but you may get away with a 4 if it's a medium to slow action rod.

And there's a substantial difference between casting a wet line compared to a dry one (backyard casting).

The faster (stiffer) the rod, the more these differences will affect your cast. That's why I prefer to fish with a slow to moderate (soft) action rod in almost all situations. Plus slow/soft rods are more forgiving. You can't cast quite as far, but accuracy improves with a slow rod, and you're less likely to make a sloppy fish-spooking cast.

That IM6 blank is fairly fast action, so if I were you and looking for delicate presentations of small flies, with my preference for slower rods, I'd put a 6 or even 7 wt double taper on. It'll slow the action down a bit (or a lot if you go with the 7wt) but it should give you the ability to easily throw 30 feet of line, plus leader, and have a delicate landing. Thing about throwing streamers, heavy flies and extra weight is the lure and lead essentially add to the line weight by a fraction. If you are throwing a 5wt well with a heavy streamer but not with a #12 Adams, you need that extra line weight to make the magic happen.
 
Streamer fishing, where the rod tip may pushed under the water to get the rod down. Or any type of fishing where keeping the rod parallel to surface is desirable. Poppers might be another exaple

i'm not at all arguing for tip heavy rods; only that balance isn't necessary for casting purposes. I personally can't stand an unbalanced set up.
The popper example makes sense.
 
Back
Top