ledhead1944:
A couple of things I know...
The Orvis Hydros (if that's what you mean by "Hydrostatic") 5WF Trout line is a true-to weight 5wt line with the identical tip length and front taper length as the Mastery Trout WF5.
If I understand you correctly, you have these two lines on different reels as options. If so, if the amount of aerialized line, leader length, taper & tippet, line speed, fly size and rod are the same, the two lines SHOULD behave the same on any rod.
Combo balance as in static weight balance has nothing to do with anything except comfort and fatigue reduction.
Listen to what Tim Murphy said...
If you want to change the static balance point of your Midwest custom rod 9' 5wt combo, you want to use a heavier reel than the TFO NXT LA1 which has a stated weight of 4.7 oz. If you rod has an uplocking reel seat, that further exacerbates the balance problem.
FWIW - I like my combos to be static balanced with about 4-5 feet of line out in front of me on the ground or water and I like that balance point to be as close to the winding check as possible. I'll also add that all of my trout rods have downlocking reel seats.
To achieve that winding check balance point on a 9'0" 5wt graphite rod, I am using a reel with a stated empty weight of 5.5 ounces or about an ounce heavier than your reel empty.
Of course there is a chance both of our reels loaded with line & backing weigh the same, but I don't choose a reel for a rod that way. I made a chart with of all of my rod combos that includes just the rod length & material it is made from and the stated empty weight of the reel that balances it at or near the winding check.
The chart has never failed me when choosing a reel for new rod....
In regards to your question about using a 6wt line on the Midwest custom rod 9' 5wt. I don't know the rod, but a heavier line will always load a rod deeper into the blank, in effect slowing it down.
Depending on the blank, that isn't always a bad thing, but SOMETIMES a whole line size heavier is more than you need to get it to feel the way YOU want.
Experiment to your hearts content, but just focus on the factors that WILL make a difference.
Good luck!!