Thinking about building a rod or 2

Joined
Jul 1, 2009
Messages
222
I have been thinking about what rod I wanna build first. This probably won't happen til next winter but trying to decide what I wanna build.

I have been really intrigued by the looks and reviews for Temple Fork Outfitters rods. I have been most interested in the Lefty Kreh Pro and the Lefty Kreh Finesse rod.

I was thinking about building a rod that is light for brook trout fishing, even though I have never fished any small mountain streams for these little natives, I'd love to try it. I mainly fish Penns, so I was thinking maybe I could get something that work for both. I currently use an Eagle Claw, 9' 5 weight.

I was thinking about a 2 or 3 weight.

Any input would be appreciated. Also, any suggestions for small sized reel that would fit something like that would also be helpful.

Thanks
 
A small mountain stream, and Penns are two completely different streams. You're going to need 2 different rods as you need them to do different things. For a small stream, I would suggest a 7' 3wt. Something with maybe a medium action. TFO rods are pretty stiff. I have an 8wt TFO TICR, and it is great for tossing a lot of line. The stiffness really punches it out there for me. That's not what you want in a small stream rod (in my opinion). You want something you can bend to bow and arrow, and something you can lay an accurate cast down.
Now with Penns, you're probably going to want a 9' 5wt. The TFO might do that for you. You want length to nymph, and enough of a backbone to handle some of the bigger fish in that stream you may encounter. A 2 or 3 wt isn't going to cut it. It isn't built to throw lengthy casts, especially into some wind, or have the length you need to do proper nymphing. You also want something not to be able to throw some dries during the hatches, and a 9' 5wt is a good all around rod for that too.

If you were building 2 rods, that would be my recommendation.


Ryan
 
I agree with Ryan.
also, you'll never be able to throw a green drake dry fly very far with a 2 wt!
a 5 or 6 for penns is perfect. it's big water with big fish that eat big flies
 
1) I would not spend more than $50 on your first blank. There is a sharp learning curve. There are several things you can do to greatly reduce that curve and improve results, but still...

2) In the short and light blanks you have lots of economical choices that will produce great rods. Start by taking a look at Batson's Rainshadow and Forecast line-ups. (I'm not a huge fan of TFO for a number of reasons.)

3) I would just choose either a rod for small streams or a rod for big streams. If you really want a compromise, a 7'6" or 8" 4wt would do, but you'll still be way under-gunned when Penns has good flow.

4) I still like the Orvis Battenkill Barstock's fo my trout rods. The BBSII is a great 2-3wt reel.

Kev
 
blackandgold4ever05 wrote:
I have been thinking about what rod I wanna build first. This probably won't happen til next winter but trying to decide what I wanna build.

I have been really intrigued by the looks and reviews for Temple Fork Outfitters rods. I have been most interested in the Lefty Kreh Pro and the Lefty Kreh Finesse rod.

I was thinking about building a rod that is light for brook trout fishing, even though I have never fished any small mountain streams for these little natives, I'd love to try it. I mainly fish Penns, so I was thinking maybe I could get something that work for both. I currently use an Eagle Claw, 9' 5 weight.

I was thinking about a 2 or 3 weight.

Any input would be appreciated. Also, any suggestions for small sized reel that would fit something like that would also be helpful.

Thanks

That is some great info. Thankyou. I will check out those reels for sure. Also, I guess I failed to mention that I have built my own rod before, but it was in school in 8th grade. Im now 31. I do have a good idea what I need to do. My buddy even has the stand and tools.
 
Hey Kev, do you mind saying what you do not like about TFO. Not looking for a debate here, just wondering. I have never used one, and for that matter, I've only cast a couple different rods. Thanks again.
 
Also another question. I have been looking and getting a feel for stuff at mudhole.com. Is there any other sites I can check out? Thanks
 
blackandgold4ever05 wrote:
Hey Kev, do you mind saying what you do not like about TFO. Not looking for a debate here, just wondering. I have never used one, and for that matter, I've only cast a couple different rods. Thanks again.

I haven't been impressed by the the finished TFO rods I've handled. There are a lot of imported rods on the market now. From what I've seen, TFO's quality is not any better than even less expensive rods and their performance is not much better than most other brands in the same price range. I don't think they would be anywhere near as popular as they are without Lefty Kreh's name on them.

I think the reasons to buy a TFO start to dissapear once you begin talking blanks. There are a several blank-only companies that can offer better performance and quality at comparable price points because they don't have to prop up a line of finished rods. Compare features of blanks from any company that sells finished rods with similiar blanks from blank-only sources. The blanks from the rod companies are usually more expensive.

As for places to shop, mudhole.com is pretty good. They sometimes come up a little weak fly rod specific components but overall they have a very good selection and are a good company to deal with.

Shoff tackle is another good site. Their overall selection is not as big as Mudhole but they often have everything I want/need.

Hook and Hackle is yet another good company. Their selection seems to grow every year. They specialize in fly fishing so they have a good selection for fly rod building.

I usually end up buying from a couple different sources to get exactly the parts I want. I've quit settling for parts that are not quite what I want, so I bite the bullet and pay double shipping.

Kev
 
Everything that Kev said.

You will be hard pressed to find a better starter blank than a Batson Forecast. They are a solid performing blank for a very fair price.

I also agree with the comments on the lower end TFO blanks but I have built several rods on the TiCrX blank series and have been very pleased with the performance. Yes, they are heavy but they are also line cannons. I am not a very good caster and with one of the 9wts I built for a guy I was throwing the entire line with ease.

As far as rod building supply houses, I agree that Mudhole is tops. For Batson products I go with Utmost Enterprises.


matt



 
janns netcraft and anglers workshop are both good resources as well.
good luck with whatever you decide to build, and remember to keep it fun!!
 
The Lamiglass " international graffite" 9ft. 2pc blanks are around $50.
 
I think building a small brookie rod first is actually ideal.

Less wraps and less to worry about. Yes it will be harder to wrap at the tip, but not too discouraging.

Like mentioned above, it's not going to look the best so build a "main" rod like a 9' 5wt.

If the wraps are ugly and the guide not alligned correctly it's not going to matter one bit on a brookie stream.

You'll see a great improvement between rod number 1 and 2; especially if done close together.
 
Thanks very much for all the input. Still looking at blanks and other stuff. This is more than likely gonna be a winter project.
 
Back
Top