Stream thermometer recommendations

I hung one of these from a zinger before I was gifted a fishpond. It’s waterproof and although it has a pointy probe it doesn’t have to be opened to work. You can just dunk it.
Under $12 at amazon. https://a.co/d/8BRwtL4
View attachment 1641247103
Did you check it at all? If you don't have a lab thermometer, and most decent humans don't, you can put it in a thermos of 50/50 ice water and see if it registers 0 C. a 1 point calibration check, better than nothing.
 
When I want to find out the stream temperature. I use a aquarium strip thermometer laminated in plastic, with a hole punched in it on each end. One hole tied to mason string other I attached a fishing 1/2 ox weight. Doesn't weigh that much does not clank and they are fairly inexpensive. A+/-1 deg accuracy good enough for me.

[
1765725914496.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kms
It is very easy to do a two (2) point check. One: the 50/50 ice water measure (0 C/ 32 F) or very close, plus you can do the second point check by sticking the device into a small pot of boiling water (100 C / 212 F), again or very close.
Hope that this helps to some degree.

Enjoy the Day and keep warm.
 
Serious question. If you have a thermometer that is calibrated and accurate to +/- 1 deg F what is your fish/no fish number in deg F?

So say you've just driven 2 hrs to get to the stream and your cutoff number is 65.0 F and your thermometer reads 64.7F - do you fish or not? What if it is 65.1F - yes or no?

If accuracy is +/- 1 F then a reading of 64.0 could be 63.0 ( I can fish) or 65.0 (I can't fish) so how do you know whether to fish or not.

I guess the bigger question is how accurate do we really need to be.
 
Before taking a water temperature, put your hand in the water and make a guess. With enough practice you can get yourself "calibrated" pretty well.
Exactly.. I carry my thermometer with me pretty much all the time, but only actually use it if what I get when I dip my fingers seems surprising in either direction. I'm usually within a couple of degrees when I dip my hand. Takes a couple outings each year before the sense kicks in with enough accuracy to trust, though.
 
Did you check it at all? If you don't have a lab thermometer, and most decent humans don't, you can put it in a thermos of 50/50 ice water and see if it registers 0 C. a 1 point calibration check, better than nothing.
I used a hand mixer, dropped it in, and bonus, it floats.
IMG_6374.jpeg
 
I still use a liquid thermometer.

Current one I have is an Orvis in the green case
Easy to read
Seems to be pretty accurate too.
I check it about once a year in an ice bath
Reads just about right on zero, and I'm OK with that
I use this and it is has a 1 degree C margin of error in my experience, which is acceptable for fishing imo
 
When I want to find out the stream temperature. I use a aquarium strip thermometer laminated in plastic, with a hole punched in it on each end. One hole tied to mason string other I attached a fishing 1/2 ox weight. Doesn't weigh that much does not clank and they are fairly inexpensive. A+/-1 deg accuracy good enough for me.

[View attachment 1641247153
I am going to attach one of these later today on my long handle net. I'm thinking I could clear coat or clear epoxy over it to make it a bit more durable. I think clear tape will probably make it a mess.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2565.jpeg
    IMG_2565.jpeg
    472.9 KB · Views: 21
Amazingly, I still have/use the glass shielded one I bought @ Flyfisher's Paradise in 1994.

Joe
 
I am going to attach one of these later today on my long handle net. I'm thinking I could clear coat or clear epoxy over it to make it a bit more durable. I think clear tape will probably make it a mess.
Cling makes a stick on that’s around $10 and has a more useful temperature range. It’s also probably more durable than the fishtank version.
IMG_6775.jpeg

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CRB
I've given up on those liquid thermometers. They they don't last very long for me and I end up getting bubbles in the tube. I was considering one of those cheap instant meat thermometers but the long probe always seems like a dumb idea for me. I got enough problems of keeping all my crap together without poking myself. I might have to just bite the bullet and get the Riverkeeper as it seems like a very good product.
I use a Thermoworks exec mini. Small, manageable, and dishwasher safe ... which only means it's fully submergible. I drilled holes in the sheath and electrical taped it on so I don't really have to worry about the pointy probe. Gets all the flow it needs to read the water.

As far as accuracy @Bamboozle , I just ignore what's after the decimal point.

20260314_212752.jpg
 
I actually just bought this one:


Haven't tried it yet so I can't give any feedback but I wanted something digital this time round.
My wife got this for me for Christmas. Very thoughtful of her.
 
Back
Top