I used the orvis battenkill reels for a long time. Inexpensive, decent quality, and it is mostly just a spool for the line anyway.
However. I got into fishing the upper delaware. 22-24" fish, 7 x tippett. That is when I gave up on the Battenkill. The clicks from one drag setting to another are not precise enough to control a big fish, in the backing, with fine tippet.
My favorite, the ross evolution. Light, well made, excellent drag.
For smaller streams you may not need the performance of a reel like this, but your flyfising will hopefully take you for more distant fishing on bigger water with bigger fish, even in PA, where you will appreciate a finer reel more.
I used to buy expensive rods and cheap reels. I have tended to buy less expensive rods and put more into reels lately.