Swattie87 wrote:
For the Simms guys…are those things indestructible? I’ve looked at them, and they do seem very nice and well built, but I’ve never owned a pair. I’ve always treated waders as a consumable. I’ve basically found on average you get about 1 year of leak free performance for every $100 you spend. It’s then up to you as to how long you repair and nurse them along dealing with leaks before popping for a new pair. I typically have gone the cheap route, in part so that I don’t get too attached or economically invested in a pair, and feel the need to spend too much time and effort on repairing them. When they start to leak too bad, throw em’ out and buy another $100 pair.
I’ve gotten about 1 year plus or minus a few months out of the typical $100 Cabelas or BPS house line jobs. The last pair of chest highs I bought was a pair of Bean Kennebec’s (normally $200, although I got them on a sale at $150). I’m at about 2 years leak free on those, and have been very happy with them. Admittedly though, in that time I also bought a pair of WJ waist highs off of STP that I’ve been using on some of my warmer weather Brookie outings, so that’s saved the Beans a little bit from some of the harder miles.
The math is clear though…
$100 BPS/Cabelas / 1 year leak free = $100/year
$200 Bean Kennebec’s / 2 years leak free = $100/year – So far…The Beans may ultimately prove to beat this average.
I’d need to get about 4 or 5 years out of a pair of the higher end USA made Simms to break even in the long run, or 5+ to come out ahead. Is that realistic to expect when using them as a primary wader for both bigger streams, and the brush busting and seem stretching climbing while Brookie fishing? There’s no doubt in my mind they’re better, but how much better?