Looking for a 100% water proof wading jacket.

Apologies for the alphabet soup.

Exactly.

I’m also a big fan of NOS (New Old Stock), especially with Simms gear. Pre-2022 (buyout by Vista) NOS NWT Simms gear is arguably both cheaper and better quality than the newest stuff
Might have to check into this. Thanks.👍
 
I’ve been on rivers many times when a strong storm with wind, very heavy rain and lightning came up and we had to hunker down someplace off the river until the storm passed by. I don’t recall ever getting wet because my raincoat leaked. A recent customer review of Simms G4 Pro rain jacket echoes my experience with my Patagonia rain jackets:

“Had almost given up on finding a rain jacket that keeps you dry. This one does it. Have taken it steelheading multiple days in a row where it rained all day and not a drop of water got in. Feels like a pair of waders but lighter and more breathable.”

That Simms jacket is a $750 sticker price (can be found in the upper $500’s at times it seems, but still) jacket. And I bet it’s hot as can be to hike and fish in that thing. Not being critical if you like it (or one similar from Patagonia) and are willing to spend that kind of money on it. I’m just not.

Here’s how I look at it…If it’s warm enough to where I’d rather be wet than hot, then I don’t need the jacket. If it’s cold enough that I don’t want to be wet, and raining hard enough, I don’t go fishing, or if I whiffed on the forecast, I quit fishing. It’s the in between where I use my $50ish Columbia…40-60 degrees or so where I can be comfortable temperature wise with it on, and possible light or moderate rain, or more often intermittent rain. The days I use it I’m often taking it on and off multiple times as conditions change. And it keeps me dry enough to stay comfy on those kinds of days. Good enough for $50.

If you’re a hardcore fish in the rain, even if it’s cold out guy, I could see potentially justifying that kind of cost for a rain jacket, I’m just not.
 
If posters want others to read and understand a post lose the abbreviation lingo.
 
Last edited:
That Simms jacket is a $750 sticker price (can be found in the upper $500’s at times it seems, but still) jacket. And I bet it’s hot as can be to hike and fish in that thing. Not being critical if you like it (or one similar from Patagonia) and are willing to spend that kind of money on it. I’m just not.

Here’s how I look at it…If it’s warm enough to where I’d rather be wet than hot, then I don’t need the jacket. If it’s cold enough that I don’t want to be wet, and raining hard enough, I don’t go fishing, or if I whiffed on the forecast, I quit fishing. It’s the in between where I use my $50ish Columbia…40-60 degrees or so where I can be comfortable temperature wise with it on, and possible light or moderate rain, or more often intermittent rain. The days I use it I’m often taking it on and off multiple times as conditions change. And it keeps me dry enough to stay comfy on those kinds of days. Good enough for $50.

If you’re a hardcore fish in the rain, even if it’s cold out guy, I could see potentially justifying that kind of cost for a rain jacket, I’m just not.
My favorite jackets - fishing and non-fishing - are plain gore-text pro shells with huge vents and Velcro wrist cuffs. Because of the vents neither is hot. For fishing it’s the discontinued Simms Slick (I also have a G4 Pro, but i like the Slick better), and for non fishing it’s a Gore-tex brand shell. The major differences between the two are that the Simms has a tougher exterior and more tapered sleeves.

IMG_6528.jpegIMG_6530.jpeg
I would not have paid full retail, which for this pair was over $1000. I got both from the ‘bay for less than $300 total.
 
Last edited:
If truly water proof and budget friendly are the only 2 things you're after I would say go Grundéns. Kinda rough to put it on and it doesn't breath but if your not hiking 5 miles it will keep you dry and during summer you can get a good deal on one . View attachment 1641248211
That would also be my suggestion for fully waterproof, but they are made for the North Atlantic around the Arctic Circle 😉

Bluelining in Grundens will help you make weight for your next wrestling match, for sure.
 
That would also be my suggestion for fully waterproof, but they are made for the North Atlantic around the Arctic Circle 😉

Bluelining in Grundens will help you make weight for your next wrestling match, for sure.
Sorry, I meant to add that for trout I use a cheap-*** Frog Toggs jacket and had the "wading jacket" version of it before that. The newest one was 14 dollars.

The only complaint. They begin to get fuzzy because they catch every bramble. You will also become a great pollinator. Seeds and burs collect the fuzzier they get.
 
Last edited:
My favorite jackets - fishing and non-fishing - are plain gore-text pro shells with huge vents and Velcro wrist cuffs. Because of the vents neither is hot. For fishing it’s the discontinued Simms Slick (I also have a G4 Pro, but i like the Slick better), and for non fishing it’s a Gore-tex brand shell. The major differences between the two are that the Simms has a tougher exterior and more tapered sleeves.

View attachment 1641248222View attachment 1641248223
I would not have paid full retail, which for this pair was over $1000. I got both from the ‘bay for less than $300 total.
I use an earlier vintage Simms Gortex packlight shell. I've been using it for years. It is so good that I have multiples of said jacket(3). It only has 3/4 zipper.
Only word for it excellent. I have used over down in Fall down pours, Fall/winter/early spring snow/rain(lake effect), Spring showers, and summer thunderstorms. I've never been sticky underneath it.
Another positive very light weight. Packs into a small pocket.SIMMSJACKET.webp
Repair just like your waders with aquashield.
 
Watch regarding Durable Water Repellant rain gear:
 
That Simms jacket is a $750 sticker price (can be found in the upper $500’s at times it seems, but still) jacket. And I bet it’s hot as can be to hike and fish in that thing. Not being critical if you like it (or one similar from Patagonia) and are willing to spend that kind of money on it. I’m just not.

Here’s how I look at it…If it’s warm enough to where I’d rather be wet than hot, then I don’t need the jacket. If it’s cold enough that I don’t want to be wet, and raining hard enough, I don’t go fishing, or if I whiffed on the forecast, I quit fishing. It’s the in between where I use my $50ish Columbia…40-60 degrees or so where I can be comfortable temperature wise with it on, and possible light or moderate rain, or more often intermittent rain. The days I use it I’m often taking it on and off multiple times as conditions change. And it keeps me dry enough to stay comfy on those kinds of days. Good enough for $50.

If you’re a hardcore fish in the rain, even if it’s cold out guy, I could see potentially justifying that kind of cost for a rain jacket, I’m just not.
Think the main problem is that flyfishing gear compared to gear from other outdoor sports (serious hiking, climbing, mountaineering, back country skiing, and even hunting) typically kinda sucks— mostly bc there’s no real urgency to provide something that you can truly entrust with your life. I don’t care if you spent 50$ on a frog togg jacket or 700$ on Simms, most FF gear just ain’t built for the type of punishment serious use can dish out. You can blame all the nerds who immediately give something a 5 star review with accompanying text that reads something like “just received my new wading jacket, so excited to try it out once trout season opens”

I would find out what kind of jackets/gear that people who do stuff like fishing off Cape Cod in November wear (Joe Goodspeed does a lot of that on the fly, but I actually mean the guys in boats doing it for their livelihoods). I’d also watch out for people who get free gear in exchange for shilling for these sh*tty brands because there’s seemingly no actual unbiased reviews of FF gear anywhere.
 
Last edited:
1768694072428.png
1768694072428.png

This is pretty light weight but I find it keeps the wet out and breathes pretty well. I don’t fish as much as most here but it’s always in my car.
 
I bought a Orvis jacket years ago that was perfect for a sauna. Id lose 50 lbs. in sweat with that thing on. One day I was at the local fly shop and I find I am staring at a G3 Simms jacket. I owner walks by and say's I can walk out the door with that for much less $. He remembers that I bought Simms boots and waders a couple weeks prior. I bought the jacket and it is comfortable.
 
Between buying gear and clothing for my (growing) son and me, I've become fairly adept at finding high-quality gear at blowout prices. Most of it has been brand new, and some of it has been used, especially when my son was growing like a weed. There are other fishing and outdoor forums that have very active member classified sections, but I'm not sure whether it's appropriate to post them here.

As others have mentioned, haunting websites like Sierra and Steep and Cheap, sometimes for months at a time, can pay off big. About a decade ago, Patagonia used to blow out past season's models and colors for up to 50% off. Then it went to 40%, and now it is usually 30%. Patagonia typically has two big sales per year, but not every item is cleared out every year. They usually clear out winter stuff in the spring and summer stuff in the fall.

I once picked up a Cabela's brand Gore-Tex Paclite jacket in their Bargain Cave for $26, but those days are over. I also grabbed a returned Simms Bulkley insulated wading jacket in the Bargain Cave for $100.

I bought my son a Sitka Gear Delta PRO Wading Jacket for 50% off MSRP a few years ago online from Rogers Sporting Goods. It's a fully-featured Gore-Tex PRO shell with a great design, good pockets, pit zips, etc. I paid $249 for it, and it compares favorably to a high-end Simms or Patagonia jacket costing more than twice the price. But, it's camo, and that might not appeal to everyone. Since I was footing the bill, my son had to be OK with camo, lol.

Orvis sometimes has fantastic sales on their website, but you need to look at their site almost daily because you never know when they'll blow something out, and, when they do, items don't last long, especially in the more common sizes. I've noticed that Orvis often blows out good stuff from early February through Presidents' Day. Sometimes local fly shops have great in-store deals, and they typically have something you can't pass up if you attend the Fly Fishing Show and rifle through their clothing racks, but sizing can be spotty.

Kuiu (high-end hunting clothes) now makes a high-quality waterfowl jacket, and it comes in colors other than camo. Occasionally they have sales for up to 40% off or more on their website, but it's often when they discontinue or update a model. The key is to keep looking for things you need before you absolutely need them and then strike while the iron is hot.

If you want expensive, high-quality gear at bargain basement prices, you need to actively search it out like it is a hobby unto itself. But, it can be found.
 
Last edited:
Here is a link to a Sitka Gear Delta PRO Gore-Tex wading jacket on eBay for $225 with the "Buy it Now" option. Says it's new with tags, and it looks like it judging by the pics. It's a size medium. I'm just posting this as an example of what can be found. These jackets now sell for $550 MSRP.

The Gore-Tex PRO fabric is about as high-end as it gets in a wading jacket.

Sitka Gear Delta PRO
 
This one caught my attention last year but I'm skeptical about all the seams and stitching possibly leaking , good idea though
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20260117-233320.png
    Screenshot_20260117-233320.png
    280.4 KB · Views: 30
To each his own but, I don't know what I hate worse, fishing in the rain or wearing a rain jacket.

I only carry a proper rain jacket (an inexpensive nylon job) if I am positive it may rain when I plan to go fishing someplace where I'll be too far from shelter to avoid the deluge...

The rest of the time I carry one of these and there are a few stashed in my vehicle:

High Priced Rain Gear.jpg


When I was a kid, I carried a 30 gallon trash bag that could be used for litter if it didn't rain... 😉
 
To each his own but, I don't know what I hate worse, fishing in the rain or wearing a rain jacket.

I only carry a proper rain jacket (an inexpensive nylon job) if I am positive it may rain when I plan to go fishing someplace where I'll be too far from shelter to avoid the deluge...

The rest of the time I carry one of these and there are a few stashed in my vehicle:

View attachment 1641248267

When I was a kid, I carried a 30 gallon trash bag that could be used for litter if it didn't rain... 😉
 
Back
Top