Lifestraw

henrydavid wrote:
I like the Sawyer products, however whichever brand or type of purifier you use I recommend trying it out first before you head out.

LifeStraw is probably best for sipping, Sawyer would be better for longer term water supply. Just be aware you need a "dirty" water bag or container and not to mix it up with your filtered water container.

Thanks, my usage of the lifestraw would be limited to just sipping, I will still carry water on day trips, but wanted an alternative for when I just pop out for a bit and dont want to carry a bunch of weight, and on an off chance I need a sip I have that opportunity.

Thanks again everone
 
JerryCoviello wrote:
I use grayl water press to filter water when out fishing, especially out west in high altitudes

https://www.thegrayl.com/

Thanks, Jerry
 
Interested in getting something simple to filter water to put in my pack for mountain stream fishing. Debating on whether it’s to eliminate carrying water or emergency/filler use. Came across this thread in search. Can anyone add to this since there’s been several years worth of experiences to pass along since this thread was started? Are your choices the same?
 
There are a few other names popular now, although LifeStraw and Sawyer are still probably the most popular. You can even find them on the shelf at Walmart.
 
I have a Steripen, a UV water sterilizing pen. It’s a bit bigger, and more expensive, than the Lifestraw, but worked well the few times I’ve used it.

One thing about using a Lifestraw, for those who have trouble sucking water through it, is that it might help to first pour the water through a cloth before using it to get any large particles or debris out that might be in the water.
 
I have the original Lifestraw, as well as the Lifestraw squeeze plastic bag. The squeeze bag is awesome, and folds up to basically the size of the filter and fits easily in the corner of my pack.

The original straw design works great, but I always hated bending down to suck in water, or carrying a cup to scoop water into. The bag eliminates that issue, and it lets you squeeze water into a pot if you’re camping.
 
Interested in getting something simple to filter water to put in my pack for mountain stream fishing. Debating on whether it’s to eliminate carrying water or emergency/filler use. Came across this thread in search. Can anyone add to this since there’s been several years worth of experiences to pass along since this thread was started? Are your choices the same?
I bought a Sawyer filter w/bag about a year ago. It has essentially quadrupled the amount of water I drink in a day of fishing without the need to carry 4 times as much water. I still usually start the day with a bottle of water, I drink it, then use the filter to refill it, drink that, then refill for the walk out and also drink a full pouch of water before the return trip

The luxury of not needing to ration water in exchange for just a couple ounces of extra gear is well worth it.

With that said I am cognizant of how clean the water is chemically. The Sawyer filter removes pathogens., not chemical contaminants, so I don't get carried away using it on certain streams. As far as taste is concerned, every cool, clear running water source has tasted good. Usually better than most municipal water sources.
 
A slightly better option in my opinion is just to go full on water filter instead of a straw gadget. I have a Katadyn 10L Base Camp Gravity water filter. Only weighs 10 ounces and filters 2+ gallons in 5-7 minutes with zero effort or pumping. Just fill and hang. We all take 5 minute breaks while fishing right? . Why not produce some drinkable water while we do it? Especially near that cold spring or trib! Bring a 20 ounce Gatorade or 32 ounce Gatorade bottle and you have drinking water for a week. If you carry this and a filled water bottle you can refill, you have unlimited drinking water for the day. It is a little big. But in a compression bag I can get it down to the size of half of a small hoagie. It’s nice to have and worth its weight.
 
A slightly better option in my opinion is just to go full on water filter instead of a straw gadget. I have a Katadyn 10L Base Camp Gravity water filter. Only weighs 10 ounces and filters 2+ gallons in 5-7 minutes with zero effort or pumping. Just fill and hang. We all take 5 minute breaks while fishing right? . Why not produce some drinkable water while we do it? Especially near that cold spring or trib! Bring a 20 ounce Gatorade or 32 ounce Gatorade bottle and you have drinking water for a week. If you carry this and a filled water bottle you can refill, you have unlimited drinking water for the day. It is a little big. But in a compression bag I can get it down to the size of half of a small hoagie. It’s nice to have and worth its weight.

Because I don't need 2 gallons of water all at once. And, as you admit "it's a little big."

The smaller devices store away easily even in a smaller pack and produce unlimited clean water on demand.
 
Just my opinion. Yes the base camp is bigger. But not too much bigger packed. I like the sawyers, they are just slow and require more effort and I still need to fill a bag. When I take a break I wanna rest, not squeeze tubes of aquafresh toothpaste. 😉 The gravity filter’s overall capacity in addition to it being filled to max is what dictates the flow speed, hence the 10L capacity. The two gallons isn’t needed to drink. It is doing all the work. It’s the pressure of the weight pushing the stream of water through the filter and into a tube of a decreased diameter at an increased rate. It’s 2 gallons capacity so it is extremely fast getting that first 20-40oz with zero effort required after filling the bag.

Sounds like we do exactly the same thing and it does improve hydration, just with different tools and I’m sure we are both preferential to the way we have already done it for years. But you are right it is a little bigger to be honest.
~5footfenwick
 
How about attachments? Is Katadyn threaded to accept a standard threaded bottle or water bag? I can get a few store bought plastic bottles on my Sawyer filter.
 
How about attachments? Is Katadyn threaded to accept a standard threaded bottle or water bag? I can get a few store bought plastic bottles on my Sawyer filter.
The bag is already attached to the filter and always comes with it. It can fill any container with any size opening
 
Lifestaw in the get home bag, along with a silcox key.

Sawyer mini going into fishing load.

Grayl system for camping, hiking and overseas trips. Warning on this one; It can be confiscated by customs in certain countries to prevent you from bringing in contaminates from other countries. Check with the consulate before you add it to your kit.
 
My son and I used Life Straws on our recent trip to Montana. We used them several ways; 1) We had compatible bottles; and 2) My son used them to sip the water directly from the stream. So far no ill effects. I think that they work pretty well at a reasonable cost.
 
i have often thought about this as well. but you have to consider a few things like everything that the roads collect then rains and dumps into rivers such as brake dust, motor oil, transmisson oil, and road salt etc...or lets say theres a dead animal upstream thats rotting away. does the life straw or any other thing similar product protect you from these things or are they strictly a life saving device during a survial situation?

if water bottles and such are weighing you down or you just dont want to carry them, maybe consider one of those camel back water systems that tuck into anything. all you have to do is move your head to the side and the straw is right there for a drink. my buddy use to tuck one inside his fishing vest. nowadays there are tons of options with backpacks, sling packs, or vests.

just something to think about for whatever route you wanna take. enjoy.
 
i have often thought about this as well. but you have to consider a few things like everything that the roads collect then rains and dumps into rivers such as brake dust, motor oil, transmisson oil, and road salt etc...or lets say theres a dead animal upstream thats rotting away. does the life straw or any other thing similar product protect you from these things or are they strictly a life saving device during a survial situation?
Most of these small filters remove particulate pathogens only. Bacteria, parasites, sediment, micro plastics, etc. They do not typically remove dissolved chemicals.

As I've already mentioned, I keep in consideration the water source. I'm in no hurry to drink AMD discharge, for example. On the other hand, private wells and municipal water sources are not always free of worrisome chemicals either.
 
I’ve got a 2L hydration bladder & have run out before in summer on day long trip, wishing I had more. One of these may be the answer.
 
I use a Grayl. In fact, I used it on the Junita this weekend at the WW “Josh” jam. It is a water bottle style that I put “spring” water in from the fridge, then I use stream water to refill it. It's big and heavy, but I never run out of water. It stays clipped to my chest pack.
 
Problem solved,you won't even know it's there ,helps protect while traversing low under growth also,LOL
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20250818_181941_Chrome.jpg
    Screenshot_20250818_181941_Chrome.jpg
    61 KB · Views: 13
In all seriousness I've considered the life straw for several yrs ,I just pack in flimsy bottles that can crunch up into almost nothing and carry them out
 
Back
Top