Help me decide my next rod.

Don’t get me wrong I’ve fished streamers on my Redington 5WT. The smallie on my profile pic was on it and ironically my pb wild brown as well throwing a streamer. Things start to get messy when I need to get distance or add weight to get down. Maybe adding weight is a mistake when throwing streamers. Do people add shot? I usually put it right above the knot haha.

Yes I add shot when needed. The more weight you add the more rod you’ll need to effectively throw it. But on medium sized WW streams during low Summer flows when I’m normally rushing them, the beadhead or a little weight tied into the fly is plenty IMO.
 
Don’t get me wrong I’ve fished streamers on my Redington 5WT. The smallie on my profile pic was on it and ironically my pb wild brown as well throwing a streamer. Things start to get messy when I need to get distance or add weight to get down. Maybe adding weight is a mistake when throwing streamers. Do people add shot? I usually put it right above the knot haha.
Dear Andrwhite610,

Yes, you can add split shot with a 5 weight but eventually you reach the practical limit for the rod to huck and chuck.

If you need to get deeper maybe you can consider a sink-tip or even an intermediate line. But then you run into the expense and the hassle of buying, carrying, and changing out spools on the water. If you are securely seated in your kayak that shouldn't be hard, but when wade fishing it may require a back out to shallower water just to make sure nothing goes wrong.

I solved most of my problems by buying a couple of used STH 5678 cassette reels and multiple cassettes. The reels are a bit heavier than your standard 5/6 weight reel, but they are fully machined with a disc drag, The ability to swap lines on the fly makes up for it. I do only really use the reel on 6 to 8 weight rods, and all of my rods have fighting butts which helps with the balance of the heavier reel.

I bought everything on eBay except for a couple of spare cassettes that I bought from a seller on this board earlier this year. Actually I'm pretty sure he just sent them to me for the cost of postage because they were surplus to his needs. I've got well over $ 1000.00 worth of fly lines from WF5 to SA Titan sink-tip WF8 in floating, sinking, sink-tip and intermediate and only actually bought 3 lines. The first STH 5678 I bought came with 6 cassettes with entirely usable lines in a padded case for the princely sum of $ 109.99.

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Two of the rods you list (path and carbon) are pretty fast / stiff. If you haven't cast one, you probably should before buying. Many guys won't like the feel or have trouble timing the cast.

For streamer fishing, you CAN use just about any rod. You also CAN dig a house foundation with a serving spoon. If you are going to dedicate yourself to streamers, dedicated streamer rod is your ticket. Strong 9'6" in 6wt is perfect for most bigger trout waters and for popper smallie fishing. If you plan on tackling big water (rivers) or chucking #2 sex dungeons....7wt all day. Quality floater line gets the job done. Add a variety of poly leaders if you want to go deep.

You'll have a learning curve for mixing flies, leader length and fly weight. Sometimes a Clouser on floating line will snag immediately and a D&D on a super fast sinking poly leader only gets 6 in below the surface. You have to experiment and get the hang of what flies sink fastest, what speeds of water allow it to sink the fastest and where the fish are that you're targeting. In a slow section, you can get a fish to go down and pick your fly off the bottom. In other areas, the fish will come up from underneath like a shark attack and want the fly higher in the column.

There will be a significant difference in elbow/wrist strain when casting a 8'6" floating 5wt and a 10' sinking tip 7wt.

Excellent lower price streamer stick is the Redington vice (if they still make it).
 
Here is a
Demo for
209.
 
Option 1-
9’ 5WT Orvis Clearwater.

My thoughts with this is that it will be a significant enough upgrade from the super cheap Redington Crosswater 8’-6” that throwing streamers will become significantly easier.

I would only consider this if you are really unhappy with the 5wt you already have. From a purely functional standpoint, the 9' 5wt and 8' 6" 5wt are the same dang thing. Yes the clearwater would be an upgrade IMO.

Option 2-

Lamson Liquid combo 9’ 7WT (or 8wt?)

With a dedicated streamer rod I assume I will be much more satisfied throwing streamers around a river like the Lehigh. One question is can I take that same rod and take it small stream fishing and throw around a smaller fly like a bugger. Can a 7Wt be “too much” for a smaller trout streamer and be more difficult to cast in tighter areas?

Your 5wt is adequate for most of the trout streamer fishing you will encounter in this state. Hell, I've fished 5wt's with streamers quite a bit on bigger western waters on many occasions. On the other hand, a 7wt is a good smallmouth rod and you could also use it for large streamers on large water for trout. Additionally, if is a decent choice for steelhead if that's something that interests you. However, I cannot ever think of a time I've felt I needed something heavier than a 5wt on streams smaller than Penns or LJR for trout, even when I'm primarily fishing streamers. If I was pressed to choose one rod for streamers I would probably go with a 6wt, but if I was forced to use a 5wt that would be a small inconvenience. A 6wt was also my preferred rod when I was still frequently fishing the Erie tribs.

Overall I would like the cheaper option, the Orvis Clearwater to be enough of an upgrade from the Redington to increase my enjoyment of throwing streamers and be an upgraded Indicator and dry fly rod to become an overall workhorse. However if that 9’ 5Wt’ will still leave me wanting more when throwing a streamer maybe I should just commit to a dedicated streamer rod. I’m not sure but Im leaning toward the 9’ 5WT Clearwater. For most bang for buck.
Let me know what you think. thanks!

If you want to upgrade for dry fly fishing, go 9' 4wt. 4wt is heavy enough to do most things well enough but are very pleasant for casting typical PA dry flies. Is the difference from a 5wt significant? Probably not, but I do like fishing 4wt rods. I think the versatility of a 4wt is enough that this would be a better choice than getting another 5wt.

I guess this is the long way of me getting to the point where I say I think you should buy a 9' 6wt or 7wt, depending on how much non-trout stuff you intended to do.
 
Here she is. With the hydros reel and SA infinity textured fly line. Looking foward to indicator Nymphing, dry dropper and stepping up on some dry fly…the streamer rod will come in time. Hoping this rod is my workhorse for many years.
IMG_5126.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top