Grey's Lance, 9' 6-weight

GANGGREEN

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
508
I've been wanting a 9' 5-weight for a while to fill an empty spot in my quiver and I didn't wish to spend an arm and a leg. I've been watching various reviews and shootouts for a while and finally decided to take a shot and purchase the Grey's Lance 9' 5-weight sight unseen. It came yesterday and I opened it up, put an Orvis CFO IV reel strung with SA GPX 5-weight line (I think) and started lawn casting the rod. Geez Louise, what a delight. I'm able to cast extremely well, extremely accurately, pick up a lot of line without backcasts and lie it back down accurately, etc. etc.. I then tried the same rod with a different reel (Hardy clone) and a Cortland peach 5-weight and this time the rod was nowhere near as impressive. Went back to the SA line (I think it's the SA GPX, but I'm still not 100% sure and didn't put a label or a note on the reel) and once again, it's truly, TRULY a delightful combo to cast.

BUT, I went to do so again this morning saw the rod tube said 9' 6-weight. Geez, I know I ordered a 5-weight, I wonder if they just ran out of tubes and used the 6-weight tube for my 5-weight. Nope. I looked at the rod and it's labeled 9' 6-weight. I presume that it was MY mistake and I ordered the wrong rod, but I'm now in the position to decide whether to keep the rod, fish it as a 5-weight with a 5-weight line (I know that many/most fly lines are half a weight to a full weight heavy), to exchange the rod where I got it for the 5-weight that I wanted (I'll have to pay shipping I'm sure) or to sell the rod and purchase the 5-weight that I want, since it likely WAS my mistake in ordering the wrong thing.

Obviously, I've only lawn cast the rod and don't know how that rod/line combo would handle a double nymph indicator rig, a streamer, etc. etc. and I don't want to be disappointed or frustrated, since I would probably use this rod for indicator nymphs about 70 percent of the time, for a dry-dropper about 20% of the time and for a streamer about 10% of the time. Does anyone else have the Lance in a 5-weight or in a 6-weight who has some thoughts or experiences that might help me decide whether to return/exchange, keep or sell this rod? For what it's worth, most people would say if the rod is such a delight to cast, why sell it, but I already have a Sage 6-weight and I'd really prefer to try to avoid too much duplication because I already have too many fly rods.
 
Well, by way of a follow up, I looked where I got mine and the 9' 5 weight was out of stock. I did find a few 9' 5 weights elsewhere, but they wanted more than I paid for this one. I got a good price on an 8'6" 5-weight and jumped on it, so that one's enroute to me now. I'll lawn cast it, lawn cast the 9' 6 weight some more and then decide what to do with whichever I choose to let go. I'm still curious what peoples' thoughts are who have cast or fished with any of these rods. At this point, I'm actually quite curious how much difference you'd find between the 9' 5 weight and the 8'6" 5 weight. Is it typically more an issue of a similar casting rod with 6" of length difference or might they cast entirely differently? I get that the longer rod would arguably cast a bit further and might be easier to mend with, but regarding casting ability, similar or possibly quite different?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top