GANGGREEN
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 26, 2016
- Messages
- 508
I've been wanting a 9' 5-weight for a while to fill an empty spot in my quiver and I didn't wish to spend an arm and a leg. I've been watching various reviews and shootouts for a while and finally decided to take a shot and purchase the Grey's Lance 9' 5-weight sight unseen. It came yesterday and I opened it up, put an Orvis CFO IV reel strung with SA GPX 5-weight line (I think) and started lawn casting the rod. Geez Louise, what a delight. I'm able to cast extremely well, extremely accurately, pick up a lot of line without backcasts and lie it back down accurately, etc. etc.. I then tried the same rod with a different reel (Hardy clone) and a Cortland peach 5-weight and this time the rod was nowhere near as impressive. Went back to the SA line (I think it's the SA GPX, but I'm still not 100% sure and didn't put a label or a note on the reel) and once again, it's truly, TRULY a delightful combo to cast.
BUT, I went to do so again this morning saw the rod tube said 9' 6-weight. Geez, I know I ordered a 5-weight, I wonder if they just ran out of tubes and used the 6-weight tube for my 5-weight. Nope. I looked at the rod and it's labeled 9' 6-weight. I presume that it was MY mistake and I ordered the wrong rod, but I'm now in the position to decide whether to keep the rod, fish it as a 5-weight with a 5-weight line (I know that many/most fly lines are half a weight to a full weight heavy), to exchange the rod where I got it for the 5-weight that I wanted (I'll have to pay shipping I'm sure) or to sell the rod and purchase the 5-weight that I want, since it likely WAS my mistake in ordering the wrong thing.
Obviously, I've only lawn cast the rod and don't know how that rod/line combo would handle a double nymph indicator rig, a streamer, etc. etc. and I don't want to be disappointed or frustrated, since I would probably use this rod for indicator nymphs about 70 percent of the time, for a dry-dropper about 20% of the time and for a streamer about 10% of the time. Does anyone else have the Lance in a 5-weight or in a 6-weight who has some thoughts or experiences that might help me decide whether to return/exchange, keep or sell this rod? For what it's worth, most people would say if the rod is such a delight to cast, why sell it, but I already have a Sage 6-weight and I'd really prefer to try to avoid too much duplication because I already have too many fly rods.
BUT, I went to do so again this morning saw the rod tube said 9' 6-weight. Geez, I know I ordered a 5-weight, I wonder if they just ran out of tubes and used the 6-weight tube for my 5-weight. Nope. I looked at the rod and it's labeled 9' 6-weight. I presume that it was MY mistake and I ordered the wrong rod, but I'm now in the position to decide whether to keep the rod, fish it as a 5-weight with a 5-weight line (I know that many/most fly lines are half a weight to a full weight heavy), to exchange the rod where I got it for the 5-weight that I wanted (I'll have to pay shipping I'm sure) or to sell the rod and purchase the 5-weight that I want, since it likely WAS my mistake in ordering the wrong thing.
Obviously, I've only lawn cast the rod and don't know how that rod/line combo would handle a double nymph indicator rig, a streamer, etc. etc. and I don't want to be disappointed or frustrated, since I would probably use this rod for indicator nymphs about 70 percent of the time, for a dry-dropper about 20% of the time and for a streamer about 10% of the time. Does anyone else have the Lance in a 5-weight or in a 6-weight who has some thoughts or experiences that might help me decide whether to return/exchange, keep or sell this rod? For what it's worth, most people would say if the rod is such a delight to cast, why sell it, but I already have a Sage 6-weight and I'd really prefer to try to avoid too much duplication because I already have too many fly rods.