Dear bowmandjk,
I have a couple of float tubes and a pontoon. I like them but for different reasons.
If all you want to do is kick around a lake and fish nothing beats a float tube. You can fin kick a pontoon, but it is nothing like a tube.
You can carry more gear with a float tube including a couple of rods that are rigged differently. Try doing that with a float tube.
You really need to consider the waters you are fishing and your goals. On a big river like the Lehigh or the Delaware a quality float tube makes it easy to cross large pools vs. wading. Flybop is right though, they ain't for river running. Pontoons can't be easily returned to your starting point on moving water without a shuttle vehicle or a lot of work.
For lakes only all you really need is tube, but I would never own a doughnut style tube. I've seen some nasty accidents in those by people who were simply trying to walk to or from the lake. Get a more modern open ended tube like the Fish-Cat and you won't regret it.
Regards,
Tim Murphy 🙂