Fishpond switchback pro first day review.

poopdeck

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 7, 2013
Messages
3,214
Finally took the switchback out for its inaugural trip today so I felt like giving my initial impressions of it. I wore it with the singular cross shoulder strap with an attached fishpond insulated water bottle holder complete with a 34oz yeti plastic water bottle that I placed on my left hip so the strap help support it.

The pack itself was very spacious for me since I only carried four fly boxes, a sandwich bag of pretzel sticks and a granola bar. The pack does not have many, if any, niches or places to hang the little doodads from outside of the compartments. With the cross strap I did not want to wear my lanyard so I was a little befuddled with where to put my nipper, floatant, and forceps but I’m confident I’ll figure this out as it’s something very different to what I’ve always done.

The water bottle holder was a waste of money. It is too big for a 16 or 20 oz water bottle. The diameter is great for a 34 oz water bottle but it’s not deep enough to handle the length of the bigger water bottles. There are no water bottle pockets on the pack. I think this is a serious short coming with the pack and requires buying the water bottle holder which is subpar at best. The insulation on the bottle holder did very very little and my ice was melted in very short order even though it was not hot out. The attachment area on the belt just did not want to hold a big water bottle with any comfort or security. I ended up just attaching the holder to the web strapping on the belt and it worked great. I actually liked where I put it because it’s weight was supported by the cross strap. I like the placement so much I think I’m going to try out the heavy insulated double walled metal Yeti in it so I can have icy cold water. I think fishpond leaves all the doodad holders and water bottle pockets off the pack so they can sell you more attachments to the pack, this is a serious demerit.

The little fly holder on top of the pack was worthless and I lost 3 of 4 flies that I put on it to dry. Kind of normal for all exposed fly patches that aren’t wool.

I really like the magnetic catch of the front compartment. The ease of sliding the pack back and forth was awesome. This is a feature that worked really well and is very practical. So thumbs up on the slide.

I would have deemed this pack mediocre if not for one very important factor……… it was probably the most comfortable pack I’ve ever used even though it is the largest pack I’ve ever used and I had one big giant water bottle as well. Because of the comfort I think I’m going to really like the pack once I get use to a few things and figure out where best to carry a few things.

Well that’s the initial, i’ll see how it goes and keep my fingers crossed the comfort remains.
 
The pack doesn't have hypalon attachment points? That would be a step back.
 
The pack doesn't have hypalon attachment points? That would be a step back.
Had to look that one up. No it does not but I’ve never had a pack that had them. The shoulder strap does have a few sewn on attachment points that are similar, minus a D-ring, but the pack itself does not. Not a big deal for me since I’ve usually carried my doodads on a lanyard suspended between my wader straps since my pack was always behind me. If the pack did have such points I would probably use them since it’s very simple and efficient to slide the pack to the front.

EDIT - I went and looked at the pack a little closer. There are 4 attachment points on the pack outside of the handles and zipper pulls which I won’t hang things from. There are two attachment points on each end that seem to be very functional. I just moved my tippet holder to one of them. There are two additional attachment points on the front of the bag but hanging anything from them would interfere with accessing the magnetic compartment. These seem way less functional and thrown on last minute to add attachment points.

Also wanted to add the that the net holder has the chance of being the best out there. It’s on the belt and not the bag so it will stay put when you are sliding the pack back and forth. I stopped carrying a net years ago due to the PIA nature of carrying a net with a sling or lumber pack. I may have to take the net next time out.
 
Last edited:
I actually just made my maiden voyage with my switchback pro this weekend as well! Sounds like our experiences were similar - loved the pack (especially the magnetic pocket) and the size is perfect but I agree that being able to comfortably carry a water bottle is all that is keeping it from being my daily driver.

Weird that your fly holder didn't do its job - mine worked as intended. Out of curiosity, does yours have the teal-colored original tacky holder or the newer 2.0 version?

I was gifted a box with the 2.0 insert and was tremendously disappointed but have had great luck with the teal-colored tacky silicone.

download.webp


1776088403852.png
 
Mine has the beige tacky. I have the pack on my right, casting side, so maybe that had something to do with it. I do like it on my dominate side as compared to my left side. This is how I worked the water bottle. You can see that the bottle is much taller than the holder so it wants to pull away from the body. The problem is lessened when I put it on the strapping rather then the attachment point on belt. I smaller bottle would probably help but I prefer 34 oz of water over 20.

IMG_0299.jpeg
 
If you could stand having your water bottle a little further back like here:

IMG_0299.jpeg


AND your water bottle pouch has additional MOLLE/PALS webbing, you could weave the MOLLE straps through the area I circled AND the webbing on the water bottle pouch and the bottle won't pull away from your body.

IF your water bottle pouch DOESN'T have additional MOLLE/PALS webbing, there are plenty of MOLLE water bottle pouches out there that do...

IF attaching your water bottle further back doesn't work for you, there are many MOLLE/PALS belt adapters out there that go around a belt and have MOLLE/PALS loops to attach gear.

The one I like & use is made by Helikon-Tex.

I assume you know this, but that long strap with the snap on your water bottle is NOT supposed to be used as a belt loop, it is a MOLLE strap for weaving through PALS webbing. That's why it is so floppy when wrapped around a 1-1/2" - 2" belt.

If you use a proper MOLLE belt adapter, you can put a water bottle or any other MOLLE pouch anywhere you want and if you have a water bottle pouch with additional PALS webbing and weave the strap, it won't budge or flop around.

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
I see 5 attachment points in your photo.
Yes but that’s on the strap and the ones on the pack belt do not offer any support unless you really wear the belt tight. The belt itself is great as a wader belt, back support belt, and the slide feature is sweet. As for attaching stuff to it, not so great. Jury is still out if I will continue to use the strap. Right now it’s a yes but only to support the water bottle. I will keep experimenting with load because the slide feature really that good.

If you could stand having your water bottle a little further back like here:

View attachment 1641250353

AND your water bottle pouch has additional MOLLE/PALS webbing, you could weave the MOLLE straps through the area I circled AND the webbing on the water bottle pouch and the bottle won't pull away from your body.

IF your water bottle pouch DOESN'T have additional MOLLE/PALS webbing, there are plenty of MOLLE water bottle pouches out there that do...

IF attaching your water bottle further back doesn't work for you, there are many MOLLE/PALS belt adapters out there that go around a belt and have MOLLE/PALS loops to attach gear.

The one I like & use is made by Helikon-Tex.

I assume you know this, but that long strap with the snap on your water bottle is NOT supposed to be used as a belt loop, it is a MOLLE strap for weaving through PALS webbing. That's why it is so floppy when wrapped around a 1-1/2" - 2" belt.

If you use a proper MOLLE belt adapter, you can put a water bottle or any other MOLLE pouch anywhere you want and if you have a water bottle pouch with additional PALS webbing and weave the strap, it won't budge or flop around.

Good luck!
Where you marked yellow is where I placed it initially. I did weave it through the molle/pals attachment points and it just did not offer the support. It’s clear to me that the water bottle is too tall and heavy for the holder. Cinching the belt super tight would help but like skinny jeans, that’s not for me. Just as the strap with button is not a belt loop, where the long strap goes around is not an attachment point but this is what worked the best. It offered the best support, easiest access and least weight bearing on my hip. I’m guessing that simply attaching attachment points to existing subpar attachment points still ends with a lousy attachment point.

I like the placement of the water bottle but I’m thinking zip ties through the molle/pals on the water bottle holder may secure it a little better.

I have both the original and pro. Army surplus style 32oz canteens and canteen holders work great with these belts.
Hmmmmmmmmmm. A lower center of gravity. I think I have one of those laying around. At least I had one laying around but I may have thrown it away. I’ll have to check. Wetting the inside of the cover offered decent insulating qualities.
 
...Where you marked yellow is where I placed it initially. I did weave it through the molle/pals attachment points and it just did not offer the support. It’s clear to me that the water bottle is too tall and heavy for the holder. Cinching the belt super tight would help but like skinny jeans, that’s not for me. Just as the strap with button is not a belt loop, where the long strap goes around is not an attachment point but this is what worked the best. It offered the best support, easiest access and least weight bearing on my hip. I’m guessing that simply attaching attachment points to existing subpar attachment points still ends with a lousy attachment point.

I like the placement of the water bottle but I’m thinking zip ties through the molle/pals on the water bottle holder may secure it a little better.

Does the water bottle pouch have extra PALS loops or just the strap with the snap?

If it doesn't have extra loops it will never sit tight or low.

If it does, a MOLLE belt adapter will solve your problem.
 
IMG_0300.jpeg


Perhaps I am being confused by terminology. It has these under the strap. The attachment point on the belt is still to far back for my liking. I may go out again tomorrow where I can fiddle around with it some more. Trying to decide between boat or waders.
 
Why is going fishing so confusing!

People like to spend money. None of this is neccessary. There's some guy out there with the Walmart combo chuckin' Fairplay branded Pheasant Tails and limiting out every weekend.

Poor dumb bastard doesn't even know what he's missing not sitting on gear boards comparing the proper attachment points for their Yeti waterbottles and Fishpond satchels.

Imagine that! He probably thinks he's having fun catching fish, if he only knew, right?
 
View attachment 1641250358

Perhaps I am being confused by terminology. It has these under the strap. The attachment point on the belt is still to far back for my liking. I may go out again tomorrow where I can fiddle around with it some more. Trying to decide between boat or waders.

That's what you need...

If you weave the strap through those slots and similar slots on a MOLLE belt adapter (and there are a zillion versions out there), it wont budge or flop around and you can position it higher or lower on the belt adapter as needed.

 
Last edited:
People like to spend money. None of this is neccessary. There's some guy out there with the Walmart combo chuckin' Fairplay branded Pheasant Tails and limiting out every weekend.

Poor dumb bastard doesn't even know what he's missing not sitting on gear boards comparing the proper attachment points for their Yeti waterbottles and Fishpond satchels.

Imagine that! He probably thinks he's having fun catching fish, if he only knew, right?
Not hardly, I like money more than most people. After a lifetime of not spending money I’ve achieved my number one laser focused goal of retiring early with complete financial security. Time to spend a little. One fishpond pack and a yeti water bottle does not make one a gear junkie. So I guess you’re out on the fishpond switchback pro.

That's what you need...

If you weave the strap through those slots and similar slots on a MOLLE belt adapter (and there are a zillion versions out there), it wont budge or flop around and you can position it higher or lower on the belt adapter as needed.
I totally get how the system works but if the adapter is simply attached to same attachment point on the belt it’s still a weak floppy connection, right?
 
...I totally get how the system works but if the adapter is simply attached to same attachment point on the belt it’s still a weak floppy connection, right?

A belt adapter is designed to loop ANYWHERE around a conventional belt like a wading belt or even a leather belt. Depending on the adapter, this can be something as simple as belt slots, a Velcro strap or something fancier that has screws to secure.

The adapter will have a patch with one or two rows of PALS slots cut into the front. For your water bottle holder you only need a single row. If your water bottle had two straps, you would need a double row belt adapter.

Two straps would be more stable, but because your water bottle has MANY PALS slots, you have MUCH more flexibility to position it where you want on a belt adapter.

Some belt adapters are flexible, other are rigid. The ones I use that I linked to above are flexible with a wrap around strap secured with Velcro. I use them to attach some small MOLLE pouches to the harness on my Richardson box.

They don't budge...

HOWEVER, you also could try something as simple as leaving your water bottle where you like it on the belt, and weaving the strap through rows of PALS slots before snapping it closed.

Depending on where you want the holder to sit, you may loop through a row first, then the belt, then a row or two before snapping it closed. Obviously the closer the strap is to just being around the width of your belt, the less flopping you will experience, but with all the slots on your water bottle holder you should be fine.

The problem with this method is, depending on how thick the belt is where you want to attach the water bottle, the strap may not be long enough to snap close.

BUT, there are separate double length MOLLE straps available or something called a MALICE Clip that is made of plastic that come in different lengths that will save the day.

You would take the separate MOLLE strap or MALICE Clip and slide it behind MOST or all of the PALS slots on your water bottle holder bottom to top, THEN you loop and weave it through SOME rows so it is as close to just being around the belt as possible before securing the strap.

Below is a video on how to use MALICE clips. Separate MOLLE straps work the same way:


I will admit that the weaving thing isn't as easy as it looks and sometimes I have reverted to using a pair of long nose pliers, but if you get it right, it is VERY very stable.

If you go the MALICE or separate MOLLE strap route, when you have your holder attached just loop your existing strap once around the belt and snap it closed to keep it out of the way.

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CRB
Good info bamboozle. Attaching to the entire belt and not just the attachment piece is the answer. Thanks for your help!
 
Third time out with it and I am overall very happy with it. Next time I’m leaving the shoulder strap at home. Even with the 34 0z water bottle on the belt I don’t think the shoulder strap is necessary. I can go back to hanging a lanyard across my wader straps which I really like for my nippers and such.
 
Back
Top