I asked the same OP question on another thread, as I too have a "glob of sealant and patches" where the booties used to be. I can't recall who, but someone pointed out that neoprene usually starts to leak from material compression after walking around in them over some length of time. Leaks from holes and tears in neoprene can be patched successfully. Not so for leaks from compressed neoprene. That said, I replaced my frugally priced waders with another pair of frugally priced waders (of another brand). The old ones haven't been discarded since I'm holding onto the notion that I can find a pair of booties for a SCUBA drysuit, that can be rubber cemented in place on what will then be backup waders.
So next question... Are neoprene wet-wading socks waterproof, or do they just keep grit, mud, and leeches off your toes? I've seen them for ~$25/pair.