Blue lines 1wt vs 2wt vs 3wt

I own 1, 2, and 3 weight rods

IMO, they're basically for very small streams.
And they were kinda fun for awhile.
However, I found out that even tiny streams always seem to have some big holes in them.
Big enough that I needed to make some longer casts.
These things make doing that a real chore.
And are kinda self defeating in that regard

Naturally of course, they largest holes are where the biggest/most fish reside on water like that too
 
What were they made of??

Save for a select few, the majority of my 3wts are glass which are my preference for bushwhacking. In regards to "yanking a errant backcast out of a tree," take a page from a Tenkara angler and and NEVER do that!!

Pull straight or better yet grab your line and yank that."
I was a younger man, then, with less patience and probably more money 😉
 
The common answer is the right one here.
A heavier and longer rod than you think you need is likely the best tool for the job. 7’6 4wt is probably a nice sweet spot. I have a 7’9 5wt I like, but admittedly it’s hard to find (graphite, which I prefer) 5 weights shorter than 8’6 now. Even with that, I find I’m grabbing my workhorse 8’6 5wt more and more now for small stream stuff.

Short version the heavier rod does small stream stuff easier, and I find situations present themselves far more often where I’d want the longer rod than the shorter one. Though both do occur.
 
I already responded and suggested that I agree with many/most posters that 1 and 2 weight rods can be toys and while probably fun to fish, maybe not the best choice, but I guess I must be in the extreme minority who has ZERO problem fishing a 3 weight in a "blue line stream" and even frequently fish them on medium-sized waters and for much larger fish than you'd find in the typical Pennsylvania blue line. Unlike some of you apparently, I have ZERO issues casting larger or bushier dry flies (assuming we're not talking about a size 4 with a 2" tail on it or something) and don't even have any trouble casting a dry-dropper or indicator rig (which isn't what the OP suggested that he'd be using, he specifically said "dry flies only, no dropper"). Personally, a 4WT is my average/go to rod weight on medium-sized or fairly large streams and a 5WT actually seems pretty robust to me compared to the rods that I use 80% of the time (either a 3 or a 4WT on anything under the size of a large stream or river). When fishing a 3WT rod, I almost always use a line rated for 3 weights (although admittedly, some of them are a bit on the heavy side of their listed rating) and only over-line if I'm dealing with a larger stream than most blue lines and fairly substantial wind.

I'm not suggesting that anyone else's advice is wrong or that I'm more correct about this topic than any of you, I just admit to being a bit surprised that I'm in the extreme minority who thinks that a 7', 7'6" or 8' 3WT is a fine option for blue lining for Brook trout (or wild Rainbows or wild Browns in 98% of circumstances). For what it's worth, I've also never broken a fly rod because it was a 3WT (the only rod that I EVER broke on a stream was a 4WT and given what I did, it would have broken had it been a 3, 4 or 5WT rod).

Once again, I know that I enjoy being on the lighter end of things generally, but I don't consider myself a true ultralight fly rodder and I'm shocked that there aren't more of you fishing 3 weights if you're really targeting smaller trout on lighter flies (especially for purely dry fly fishing). I fish small to medium-sized streams in northern PA, in the southern Appalachians and occasionally in the American west a LOT (probably at least 50 days per year), catch what I believe to be a fair number of trout on average (those 50 days equate to at least several hundred fish), fish dries a lot, but also occasionally fish a dry-dropper or a nymph indicator rig (sometimes with 2 nymphs) and I only rarely fish anything heavier than a 4 weight. If I average 50 days per year on small to medium streams, I'd guess 20 days are using a 3WT, 25 are using a 4WT (more on medium-sized streams or stocked trout streams versus true Brookie streams and often bamboo) and maybe 5 are spent using a 5WT (and that might be a 7' or 7'6" bamboo rod as well).

Just an opinion that differs some from the majority on this thread.
 
I already responded and suggested that I agree with many/most posters that 1 and 2 weight rods can be toys and while probably fun to fish, maybe not the best choice, but I guess I must be in the extreme minority who has ZERO problem fishing a 3 weight in a "blue line stream" and even frequently fish them on medium-sized waters and for much larger fish than you'd find in the typical Pennsylvania blue line. Unlike some of you apparently, I have ZERO issues casting larger or bushier dry flies (assuming we're not talking about a size 4 with a 2" tail on it or something) and don't even have any trouble casting a dry-dropper or indicator rig (which isn't what the OP suggested that he'd be using, he specifically said "dry flies only, no dropper"). Personally, a 4WT is my average/go to rod weight on medium-sized or fairly large streams and a 5WT actually seems pretty robust to me compared to the rods that I use 80% of the time (either a 3 or a 4WT on anything under the size of a large stream or river). When fishing a 3WT rod, I almost always use a line rated for 3 weights (although admittedly, some of them are a bit on the heavy side of their listed rating) and only over-line if I'm dealing with a larger stream than most blue lines and fairly substantial wind.

I'm not suggesting that anyone else's advice is wrong or that I'm more correct about this topic than any of you, I just admit to being a bit surprised that I'm in the extreme minority who thinks that a 7', 7'6" or 8' 3WT is a fine option for blue lining for Brook trout (or wild Rainbows or wild Browns in 98% of circumstances). For what it's worth, I've also never broken a fly rod because it was a 3WT (the only rod that I EVER broke on a stream was a 4WT and given what I did, it would have broken had it been a 3, 4 or 5WT rod).

Once again, I know that I enjoy being on the lighter end of things generally, but I don't consider myself a true ultralight fly rodder and I'm shocked that there aren't more of you fishing 3 weights if you're really targeting smaller trout on lighter flies (especially for purely dry fly fishing). I fish small to medium-sized streams in northern PA, in the southern Appalachians and occasionally in the American west a LOT (probably at least 50 days per year), catch what I believe to be a fair number of trout on average (those 50 days equate to at least several hundred fish), fish dries a lot, but also occasionally fish a dry-dropper or a nymph indicator rig (sometimes with 2 nymphs) and I only rarely fish anything heavier than a 4 weight. If I average 50 days per year on small to medium streams, I'd guess 20 days are using a 3WT, 25 are using a 4WT (more on medium-sized streams or stocked trout streams versus true Brookie streams and often bamboo) and maybe 5 are spent using a 5WT (and that might be a 7' or 7'6" bamboo rod as well).

Just an opinion that differs some from the majority on this thread.
My opinion that OP would be better off with a 4w is mostly based off of them saying they are a newer / beginner angler. I agree that a 3w is a good small stream tool, but IMO it shouldn't be your first small stream tool. Personally I don't think a 3w can do anything that a 4w can't, where a 4w can do some things better than a 3w could. I actually use a stiff 7'6 5w on the small streams around my camp up north. There are very few spots where I can actually cast the line. The stiff rod with heavier line lets me roll cast, flick cast really, way better than a light line rod could.
 
My opinion that OP would be better off with a 4w is mostly based off of them saying they are a newer / beginner angler. I agree that a 3w is a good small stream tool, but IMO it shouldn't be your first small stream tool. Personally I don't think a 3w can do anything that a 4w can't, where a 4w can do some things better than a 3w could. I actually use a stiff 7'6 5w on the small streams around my camp up north. There are very few spots where I can actually cast the line. The stiff rod with heavier line lets me roll cast, flick cast really, way better than a light line rod could.

I can absolutely understand your point and don't disagree with you, but it seems that many who have posted here have taken the position that a 3 weight is a toy and that NOBODY needs a 3 weight or that a 4 or 5 weight is ALWAYS preferable and I vehemently disagree. I own more 4 weights than any other weight rod (I'd have to think about it, but I probably have 4 or 5 4 weights), but I think under most conditions on a blue line stream, especially if intending to fish dry flies only, I'd enjoy the experience more with a 3. If the argument is that a beginner might see some benefit from a 4 or a 5 weight or that a beginner sometimes finds casting in close easier by overlining his 3 weight, then I'd agree with those assertions, but not as absolutes for any angler.
 
Only times I've truly been limited with the use of a 1 wt I was trying to land a 26+" Steelhead on a Lake Erie Trib. I acualy thought I would brake my fly dod. I've never Had a problem landing 18"

Exactly. I've never owned a 1-weight, but I've caught hundreds, probably thousands of trout on 3-weights (and some on 2s) and many of them were 18-20" stream bred trout with shoulders. While I don't discount that it may be marginally easier for a beginner with a 4-weight or by overlining his 3-weight, I'm simply blown away that so many guys on this board are summarily discounting the use of a 3-weight or calling them toys. I mean, the OP's question regards fishing blue lines for native Brookies for God's sake. We're talking about casting dry flies to 8" fish here guys. And believe me, I want to be prepared and know that sometimes large trout mysteriously show up in such places (especially spawning wild Browns), but I still don't understand......And, as HAS been pointed out by previous posters, the rod rating is typically more a function of how well it will cast X, Y or Z and not whether it can handle the outsized trout that MIGHT be in the stream. Dry flies, anything up to the largest size that you'd use for Brookies (what, a size 10 or 12, even if it IS bushy and large in profile?) are EASY to cast with a 2 weight or a 3 and probably easy enough with a 1-weight, we're not slinging articulated streamers with heavy heads here.
 
I use a 4 weight for all of my PA trout fishing needs. If I ever want to specifically go chuck big streamers at trout or something, I'll use a 6, but those times are so rare that I do it less than once a year on average.

4 weight is the love of my life for PA troutin'.
 
I choose my line weight roughly based on unweighted fly sizes I expect to use that day. Charts like this are out there, even in the old Orvis fly fishing book.

1761261551701.gif


So a 2-4 weight would cover a lot of my dry fly fishing, I used 6 and 7 wts this past season for cicada and big green drake flies, and generally carry a 5 or 6 for most streamer fishing. Rod lengths vary based on stream conditions, etc.

For small brookie streams with dry or small dry dropper a fiberglass 3 is perfect for me. I also really enjoy a 3 wt for tricos, BWO and midges. The Winston WT 8.5' 3 weight is incredible for those flies/hatches.
 
I fish 4 and 5 weights almost exclusively now

But I used to fish Spring and Fishing creeks with a Loomis IMX 7' 9" 2 weight.
It worked pretty well for me and was a lot of fun.
But there were still quite a few times on the larger pools, that I was kinda outgunned with it.
Just made things a little harder than it should have been some times

I now use my Far and Fine 5 weight there
Just as much fun, and have more oomph to hit the spots I want to
 
The Swattie rule of rods…

“Heavier (within a line weight or two) does light stuff better than lighter does heavy stuff”. So unless you’re just tossing small to mid size dries (which is a-ok), heavier in most cases is the better choice. For small stream stuff, yeah, I want to just fish dries, but sometimes a dry dropper is just the ticket. Way much more fun on a 4 or better yet a 5 weight, than a 3 weight. And if you get lucky and get to chop the dropper off, the heavier rod will handle the single dry fine. If all you’re tossing is dries to Brookies on a tiny rhodo stream in the Summer, yeah, the small light rods have their place, and I own two. But I fish my 4 and 5 weights on small streams way more often.
 
The Swattie rule of rods…

“Heavier (within a line weight or two) does light stuff better than lighter does heavy stuff”. So unless you’re just tossing small to mid size dries (which is a-ok), heavier in most cases is the better choice. For small stream stuff, yeah, I want to just fish dries, but sometimes a dry dropper is just the ticket. Way much more fun on a 4 or better yet a 5 weight, than a 3 weight. And if you get lucky and get to chop the dropper off, the heavier rod will handle the single dry fine. If all you’re tossing is dries to Brookies on a tiny rhodo stream in the Summer, yeah, the small light rods have their place, and I own two. But I fish my 4 and 5 weights on small streams way more often.
I like that rule.

There’s really no good reason to fish anything lighter than a 3 or 4 wt (euronymph rods could get a pass as explained previously although I don’t like any of those lighter than a 3 either).

Never understood the need to match tackle to water type. Below 3 wt, one is really only getting poor casting performance while suffering from a lack of understanding about leader construction and matching turnover to fly size/weight.

And most importantly you’re probably gonna either break off or play to exhaustion any surprise bigger fish that pops up in water that mostly contains smaller fish. Like it or not, losing that freak 14” brookie or 17” wild brown while undergunning with a 1 wt = failure as an angler.
 
I like that rule.

There’s really no good reason to fish anything lighter than a 3 or 4 wt (euronymph rods could get a pass as explained previously although I don’t like any of those lighter than a 3 either).

Never understood the need to match tackle to water type. Below 3 wt, one is really only getting poor casting performance while suffering from a lack of understanding about leader construction and matching turnover to fly size/weight.

And most importantly you’re probably gonna either break off or play to exhaustion any surprise bigger fish that pops up in water that mostly contains smaller fish. Like it or not, losing that freak 14” brookie or 17” wild brown while undergunning with a 1 wt = failure as an angler.
I dont think that a 1, 2,or 3 weight would be very practical on the Delaware.

One day while on my way down to fish the Yough, I accidentally grabbed the wrong Loomis tube.
And got down there to find I had a 7'9" 2 weight, instead of a 5 weight.
I had to fish with it, or just turn around and go home
So I tried it
And did manage to catch a few fish that rose pretty close to me.
But I certainly wouldn't want to make a habit out of fishing that rod there again
 
I dont think that a 1, 2,or 3 weight would be very practical on the Delaware.

One day while on my way down to fish the Yough, I accidentally grabbed the wrong Loomis tube.
And got down there to find I had a 7'9" 2 weight, instead of a 5 weight.
I had to fish with it, or just turn around and go home
So I tried it
And did manage to catch a few fish that rose pretty close to me.
But I certainly wouldn't want to make a habit out of fishing that rod there again
nothing like having to double haul for a 40 foot cast 🤣

I’ll run my T&T 10’9” 3 wt up on the Delaware for nymphing (I’ve handled plenty of 18-22” browns and rainbows on it) but again those rods are a totally different animal than the ones being talked about here for small stream fishing
 
I primarily fish small tight streams and have fished a range of line weights and sizes over the years. I have settled on a 8’ 9” 3 wt as my preferred rod finding it to be the most versatile small stream rod for me. The longer rod is not a liability on small streams, but rather a plus. I like the way rods of this length cast and manage line on the water. There are a few sections of streams, mainly headwaters, where I fish a 7’ 9” 3 wt, but this is a small percent of my tight stream fishing.

Equally, if not more, important is the choice of line and leader. For most of this type of fishing I have settled on a SA Amplitude Creek Trout 3 wt line and a Meck Brush leader. I like the way it loads the rod at small stream fishing distances, both standard and roll casts. With this set up, I can fish dries or dry droppers. For the rare hole that seems to be better fished with a tightline rig, I paint the leader at the leader-tippet junction with HnD Neon wax and nymph the hole. The longer rod is helpful to manage tightline drifts. Then I just wipe off the wax and go back to dry fly fishing by adjusting the tippet as I move upstream.
 
I am using a 6'6" 3wt or 4wt or a 7'0" 3wt or 4wt most often...

As far as an 8'9" rod at "small tight" streams; at places I define as "small tight" you couldn't even lift a rod that long over your head to roll cast or to either side of the stream...
 
Back
Top