Bamboo rods and silk lines

Tightlines

New member
Joined
Nov 8, 2008
Messages
6
Today I’m fishing vicariously through anyone who responds to this post. I have no experience with bamboo rods or silk lines, but I think I'd like to set up a 3wt., 1pc. bamboo rod with braided silk line. It sounds like the fly fishing equivalent of hunting with a flintlock rifle. Any thoughts?
My thoughts:

• Is there anything special that I need to know about attaching "silk line to backing" or "silk line to leader"?
• How much maintainence does silk require; Is Mucilin as good as anything for dressing?
• Is the rod a consideration? bamboo (1pc, 2pc), graphite or other?
• I use a 3wt. graphite rod that's overweighted with line and I like the way it works. Will a 3wt. silk line be heavier than plastic? • Are all silk fly lines created equal? You can get a 27 meter braided 3wt. DT for about 50 bucks on Ebay. Made in China (good thing or bad thing?).click here: http://cgi.ebay.com/NEW-Silk-Fly-Fishing-Line-DT-3-Braided-at-27-meters_W0QQitemZ350131048665QQcmdZViewItemQQptZLH_DefaultDomain_0?hash=item350131048665&_trksid=p3286.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2%7C65%3A10%7C39%3A1%7C240%3A1318
• I would think braided silk line won't stretch as much as mono. Will it make a big difference in playing a fish?

Any information would be appreciated. Thanks!
 
i would think you might want to go a bit heavier than a three weight if you switch to cane.the reason being that fighting a fish on a three weight plastic rod is said to feel similar to fighting one on a five or even six weight bamboo rod.a four weight might make the most sense unless you are indeed only fishing for tiny brookies.i use 5/6 weight bamboo for anything short of salt,even tiny stuff.

i only have one silk line,a vintage gudebrod,and the only care i use is to put mucilin on it before fishing and to thoroughly dry it after fishing.i can not speak for the chinese lines.

you might want to ask these questions at www.clarksclassicflyrodforum.yuku.com too,you'll be sure to get more informed answers than mine there.

if you live near fluffya i'd be glad to let you try a (much heavier)silk bamboo combination.
 
Lots of good information on silk lines at the site listed below. If memory serves me correctly, the preferred way to attach the line to the backing is to whip finish a loop on both. This allows you to remove the line to dry. You may want to get some feedback on the line maker as one maker's weight is not necessarily another's. I understand there may be a lot of variables involved, especially with the lighter weight lines. I second going over to the Classic Rod Forum. The big kids are there when it comes to silk. Good Luck,
Rolf

http://www.overmywaders.com/index.php?essays
 
and by the way,they are discussing the chinese lines in the ephemeralla section at clark's right now.also see the fishing bamboo rods section for discussing silk.
 
TL:

I would think long & hard about a "flintlock".

From experience:

First of all silk lines while dreamy to cast have no major advantages over modern plastic lines other than life span and decreased diameter. As far as an advantage on a modern bamboo rod I don't buy it and I fish bamboo rods; unless of course you are talking about a rod that is between 50-100 years old with smaller guides.

Silk lines MUST be completely stripped from the reel and dried completely if stored for any length of time or they can rot. If you presently don't clean your REGULAR plastic lines after every fishing trip you shouldn't consider silk because it is even more work than what you are NOT doing now.

Red Mucilin is a great floatant but expect to have to dry and re-treat the working portion of your line during the day if you plan to fish for more than a few hours. That typically involves stretching the line between a few trees while you sit there waiting. Also a greased line doesn't float nearly as well as a plastic line and pick-up can be a hassle when it starts to get waterlogged.

If you still want to try one; go for a cheap line or a refinished old line FIRST before taking the serious plunge. If the maintenance doesn't scare you off then spring for a Phoenix. It will pay for itself in a few seasons and is well worth the money.

Presently I use silk on a old F.E. Thomas rod with small guides that I will occasionally trot out to swing wets. Other than that I prefer plastic lines with a standard taper on my bamboo rods like the Sci Angler Trout, Cortland 444 or Rio Classic. Some folks like the Cortland SYLK which has a diameter that approaches silk without the maintenance hassles of the real thing.

As far as knots go; knots to the backing and leader are no different than plastic with an Albright being fine for the backing and a nail, needle or whipped loop being fine for the leader. Silk doesn't have the coating pull-off problem that plastic lines do so knots hold fine.

In regards to bamboo rods; while one piece rods are the pinnacle of smooth action they are freaks that require a perfect culm and IMHO the skills of an expert to build correctly to take advantage of the lack of a joint. They also are a pain to transport and if you break a tip; you're screwed with an investment that will be worth a WHOLE lot less than what you paid. There is also a bit of maintenance required on a bamboo rod that may not be critical on plastic or even fiberglass. Neglecting it can spell disaster.

If you want a flintlock and have no experience with bamboo or silk I would advise you to take a look at some other "flinty" options like a sweet lightweight graphite with soul or a fiberglass 3wt that will give a bit of advantage back to the fish while saving you countless dollars and hours of maintenance time over classic tackle.

In case you decide to travel the route regardless; gut leaders are no flintlock either so at least save yourself that hassle!

;-)
 
I don’t know that much about silk fly line. However, I do know a little (I mean a little) about bamboo. Over that past year I have been working with one piece Quads and have not been disappointed. I have built a 4’10 4 wt, 5’10 4 wt, and 6’ 3 wt (and a few bait casting rods for the kids). I like the 4’10” 4 wt and the 5’10” 4 wt better than the 6’ 3wt, but that could be the taper. I converted it from a 2 pc. 6’ 3 wt that I liked in a hex. So, now I have 6 different one piece quad tapers that I’m working on, (3) 6’ 3 wt. (2) 6’ 5 wt and (1) 4’ 4wt. IMO there is no equivalent to a flintlock and a bamboo fly rod. The bamboo fly can cast and handle fish the same as a plastic rod (but you don’t want to bring a knife to a gun fight either).

IMO, re-think the 3 wt if it is going to be the only bamboo fly rod that you are going to own. Depending on the streams that you fish a 4 wt you’ll be able to fish light streamers and buggers if you need to, even if you’re going to fish only dries I think the 4 wt would be better, but a 3 wt. is sweet and so are the 2’s and 1’s (1’s not recommended IMO unless you know the marker or are one or you point the rod and let the big ones break off, they can make trouble in short order if you’re not ready to fight big fish with that light of a bamboo fly rod).



Joe E
 
Don't have a silk line, so can't help you there. I did cast one once, and I have to say it casted much nicer than standard lines, I was impressed. I wouldn't say its like a flintlock at all, it may actually be an advantage in the fishing arena. However, I could simply not put up with taking care of one, too much work for me. I'm the type of guy who throws the stuff in the truck wet and leaves it there for a while.

As far as bamboo, I echo what someone else said. I wouldn't go with a 3 wt, I'd go heavier. I have a 5 wt and its a joy to cast, though I didn't think so at first, I had to get used to it. The weight of the rod is the kicker, at first it feels like a brick, but after a while the increased momentum makes the rod cast itself after you start the stroke. If making the switch from graphite, you might want to get a faster action (on the bamboo scale, which is still fairly slow for graphite).
 
Back
Top