Are any PA Orvis stores staying open?

Same as every time I went into the Downingtown store
I agree. I went to the Downingtown store many times over the last few years. There was never really any traffic. Most of the time it was me and two employees. Sorry for the folks that worked there, but not surprised.
 
I got an email this morning that the lancaster store is closing but the fly fishing section in that store was the size of a small closet
 
Like has already been mentioned, Wolfe's is an Orvis dealer, not an Orvis company store...

The difference is like night & day.

FWIW - The fly shops of my youth (Eyler's, Cox's & The Sporting Gentleman) all sold Orvis more than any other brand, but all were dealers.

IMHO, that business model beats the pants off a "company store" and if the dealers stick with the brand, the consumer will be better off unless they are in the market for a dog nest, fatwood or an overpriced wallet...

BTW - Precision, TCO, Cabela's & Bass Pro Shops are all Orvis dealers....
You bring back some memories from the time machine mentioning Eyler's and The Sporting Gentleman. Long ago from a different era, and my opinion,a better era....
 
You bring back some memories from the time machine mentioning Eyler's and The Sporting Gentleman. Long ago from a different era, and my opinion,a better era....

Agreed!!

Do you remember Cox's on Lancaster Avenue in Bryn Mawr? They weren't in the same league as Eyler's or The Sporting Gentleman and were probably better known as a tennis outfitter.

However, the first thing this wide eyed, broke-a$$ kid would drool over when I walked into the shop was a rod rack full of Orvis bamboo rods.

I still have a couple of Wheatley fly boxes I bought there many moons ago which required to me save lawn cutting money and other windfall for a LONG time to fund the purchases.
 
And I thought I was the only one to remember Cox's. Shot 22's in the basement as a child. Went to a FF night school taught by Jim at Radnor. Evern was at their farm a few times. I was a lucky kid! PeteL
 
And I thought I was the only one to remember Cox's. Shot 22's in the basement as a child. Went to a FF night school taught by Jim at Radnor. Even was at their farm a few times. I was a lucky kid! PeteL

Ingrained in my mind is a particular visit to Cox's...

I was standing at the front counter looking at some stuff I couldn't afford when a well heeled sport entered and asked to see a particular Orvis bamboo rod in the rack. He waggled it a few times, asked what it cost, bought it and walked out...

I about died with envy...

I guess that's analogous to seeing the same thing happen today with a Helios rod...

...minus the envy... 😉

Another wild memory occurred one day during one of my frequent multi-hour hang out sessions at the Eyler's Bryn Mawr store.

A different well heeled sport walked in said he was going on some salt water fishing trip and needed gear. As I sat there and silently watched, Tommy proceeded to show him what he needed that included a rod, reel, line, leaders, flies, waders, etc. The guy bought everything to the tune of several thousand bucks, thanked Tom and walked out..

Tommy looked over at me and shot me that infamous smirk of his letting me know life was good at the shop that day!!

Eyler's Hanging Sign.JPG
 
I a
Agreed!!

Do you remember Cox's on Lancaster Avenue in Bryn Mawr? They weren't in the same league as Eyler's or The Sporting Gentleman and were probably better known as a tennis outfitter.

However, the first thing this wide eyed, broke-a$$ kid would drool over when I walked into the shop was a rod rack full of Orvis bamboo rods.

I still have a couple of Wheatley fly boxes I bought there many moons ago which required to me save lawn cutting money and other windfall for a LONG time to fund the purchases.
l also got the privilege to fish there pond as a child ( my first fish on fly rod ). They both were one of kind people, he had a table with green felt and a fancy pistol with the bullets laid out under glass that I thought was sooo neat and got a pop that day and got to crush the can ! It was a magical day for me .
 
Anyone been to d-town lately. Should I bother for some hooks and tying materials and maybe some deals or just drive to TCO?
 
Anyone been to d-town lately. Should I bother for some hooks and tying materials and maybe some deals or just drive to TCO?
Was there last week. They are pretty wiped out, but they still playing games with some stuff is discounted, some not. Even some rods at $100 off are cheaper at the dealers. No bargains here, move along.
 
Back in 1986-87, I worked at a sporting goods shop in Baltimore (Tidewater Specialties from over in Easton when they tried to have a shop on the Western Shore). They mainly catered to duck hunters and gun dog people, but also had a lot of clothing and were branching out into fly fishing and fly tying. It's almost impossible to make a go of it selling fly fishing stuff in a retail setting because we fly guys are a very picky lot.

I'm looking for fine wire size 14 hooks with a 2xL shank. Sorry, we only have 2xl fine wire in 12 and 16. Oh, well no thank you then.

Do you have Orvis tippet? No, only Maxima. No sale.

How about dyed yellow deer body hair? No, we've got green, white, black and natural. Sorry, I really need yellow.

I'm looking for a 5 weight WF Jim Teeny line. We only carry Cortland. No, it's gotta be Jim Teeny.

You get the idea. The ratio of inventory you need on hand to the actual number of sales you make is astronomical. Plus the cost of rent, utilities and paying some grunge rock college kid with an addiction to fly fishing to mind the store, and it quickly becomes a tough way to make a buck.
 
Back in 1986-87, I worked at a sporting goods shop in Baltimore (Tidewater Specialties from over in Easton when they tried to have a shop on the Western Shore). They mainly catered to duck hunters and gun dog people, but also had a lot of clothing and were branching out into fly fishing and fly tying. It's almost impossible to make a go of it selling fly fishing stuff in a retail setting because we fly guys are a very picky lot.

I'm looking for fine wire size 14 hooks with a 2xL shank. Sorry, we only have 2xl fine wire in 12 and 16. Oh, well no thank you then.

Do you have Orvis tippet? No, only Maxima. No sale.

How about dyed yellow deer body hair? No, we've got green, white, black and natural. Sorry, I really need yellow.

I'm looking for a 5 weight WF Jim Teeny line. We only carry Cortland. No, it's gotta be Jim Teeny.

You get the idea. The ratio of inventory you need on hand to the actual number of sales you make is astronomical. Plus the cost of rent, utilities and paying some grunge rock college kid with an addiction to fly fishing to mind the store, and it quickly becomes a tough way to make a buck.
Dear Jim,

Your story reminds me of the old Sportsman's Outpost in Burlington NJ on Rte. 130. They sold everything from boats to birdhouses and all manners of hunting fishing and flyfishing gear too. Sometimes I didn't want to drive to the Pocono's or State College and after Edelman's closed their shops the Outpost became my go-to place. Between them and the Army-Navy store about 5 miles up Rte. 130 if you couldn't find what you needed at those stores it clearly wasn't needed. My heavy winter coat and thermal underwear and snow shoveling gloves were bought there along with fresh and saltwater fishing gear over 30 years ago and all of them are still in usable condition.

For better or for worse depending on how you view things the ability to buy something and just use it seems to be a lost art. I learned to make do and it's a hard habit to break for me. Of course, there some items that can't easily be substituted for, and for those I will travel or search online for them. But I still make do more often than not.

I guess I'm just an old fart? 😉

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Back in 1986-87, I worked at a sporting goods shop in Baltimore (Tidewater Specialties from over in Easton when they tried to have a shop on the Western Shore). They mainly catered to duck hunters and gun dog people, but also had a lot of clothing and were branching out into fly fishing and fly tying. It's almost impossible to make a go of it selling fly fishing stuff in a retail setting because we fly guys are a very picky lot.

I'm looking for fine wire size 14 hooks with a 2xL shank. Sorry, we only have 2xl fine wire in 12 and 16. Oh, well no thank you then.

Do you have Orvis tippet? No, only Maxima. No sale.

How about dyed yellow deer body hair? No, we've got green, white, black and natural. Sorry, I really need yellow.

I'm looking for a 5 weight WF Jim Teeny line. We only carry Cortland. No, it's gotta be Jim Teeny.

You get the idea. The ratio of inventory you need on hand to the actual number of sales you make is astronomical. Plus the cost of rent, utilities and paying some grunge rock college kid with an addiction to fly fishing to mind the store, and it quickly becomes a tough way to make a buck.

A big problem is there are no more SALES people working in retail, just cashiers...

I spent my fly-formative years in stores that have had WAY, WAY, less choices than what shops stock today and I was sold on what they had in inventory. You walked in, asked for X, the owner handed you Y and told you WHY, Y would be just as good or better than X...

And you walked out smiling with X. Been there, done that a 1000 times.

I guess that's why I have a "if it ain't broke" mentality with most activities in life and sometimes I don't even bother looking at new stuff if I'm not having issues with what I am using.

Today, it is like going to a restaurant. Some feel there needs to gluten free options, vegan options, non-dairy, sugar free, heart healthy, smaller portion choices and a non-peanut zone...

But somehow, the local hash house that doesn't give a rat's arse still has folks waiting to be seated... 😏

I KNOW I am an old fart!!! 😉
 
Last edited:
Back
Top