I read a lot of the threads on the Tully and I didnt see any BS reports about that stream. It warms quickly in summer, the trout are mutant stockies, it gets pretty crowded, it is loaded with carp, bluegills, chubs and 3-4 inch smallmouth. That is the absolute truth about the Tully. Yes, the Tully can be a nice place to fish and there are some decent caddis hatches that will bring the fish up but there are much better places to fish. Whatever "BS" reports you might have read were to inform anglers seeking better water that the Tully might not be what they were looking for. After all it does get much better than the Tully in our state. I did not write or participate in any reports on the Tully that your referring too but I do remember reading them and I accepted them as the absolute truth.
