This was the shop that I bought a wooly bugger that caught my first trout on a fly rod on the West Branch of the Octorara about 13 years ago... It certainly was a quaint, out of the way little shop..
FYI, I stopped by the shop last summer and she only accepted cash for payment. Be sure to take cash if you make a trip to stock up. This is a neat little shop, and it is only a few miles from West Branch Octorara.