It really depends on if you want to fish with the headlamp on, or with it off. If you want to fish with a headlamp on, I think your best bet is going to be either red or blue LED's. With white LED's, the light wavelength intensity is pretty high, and could create a glare on the water that will spook fish. Red or blue leds have a much lower wavelength intensity, and won't have the same effect. That's why when you turn on a white LED in a car, the windows will light up like a lamp with glare, but if you turn on a red or blue LED you don't have the same effect. I am by no means an expert, this is all info I gleaned from working at a store during college that sold LED's.
A lot of headlamps out there now have a white with red or blue option.
Although you can never go wrong with Petzel, I bought the Badlands 12 LED Headlamp, and I really like it. For people like me with Barry Bonds-sized noggins, the strap over the top is kind of nice. And for normal retail cost (about $23), it's a pretty good value.
http://www.badlandspacks.com/index_reload.php
But I do LOVE fishing mice and streamers on western rivers at 2AM. The big boys come out to dance.