First Brookie on a fly
- Thread starter JK Reed
- Start date
wildtrout2
Well-known member
Congrats on your first. Hopefully many more to come. It's tough to tell with that one, were you fishing a stream that could possibly have stocked trout in it, or were you in a remote setting where stocking wouldn't be possible?
Either way, it's a great catch you won't soon forget.
Either way, it's a great catch you won't soon forget.
CinnamonJoe
Well-known member
I'm going to say, 'yes, native'! And a nice one at that!
To my eye, the spots, parr marks, and coloration: esp the reds, and darker purple pigments outlining the fins are a bit more authentic than those seen on a stocked brookie. No clipped fins I see either.
(Well-wait-is the top fin clipped, or it it just flopped to the side/folded?)
Well done!
Joe
To my eye, the spots, parr marks, and coloration: esp the reds, and darker purple pigments outlining the fins are a bit more authentic than those seen on a stocked brookie. No clipped fins I see either.
(Well-wait-is the top fin clipped, or it it just flopped to the side/folded?)
Well done!
Joe
JK Reed
Member
No the top fin wasn’t clipped. I was told by the local fish warden that they don’t stock brookies up in this area, but you need know. This stream is stocked further downstream but we were pretty far upstream and it is known for wild fish.
nd1001
Well-known member
I’m with Joe, looks wild to me! Congrats!! That sort of fishing is as good as it gets, in my view 🙂
Congratulations on a beautiful fish!
I also caught my first wild brookie this year in a small laurel Highlands creek.
rustbeltwilds
Well-known member
Looks wild to ne those parr marks and the clean spotting and straight white anal fin border. Nice
5footfenwick
Well-known member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2006
- Messages
- 712
Congratulations! Always nice to see a Forest mountain gem like that. Looks wild to me too with a lot of color on the dorsal fin. Now good luck not getting addicted to brookie fishing!
Last edited:
wildtrout2
Well-known member
And, it is addicting.
JK Reed
Member
Yep, think I'm already there. Three years into FFing and we're just now starting to catch them. But I've always been drawn to these small mountain streams. Temp was 61 where we first went in and dropped a few degrees the further we went upstream. Fished Confluence on the 3rd and again on the 12th but got skunked both times.
5footfenwick
Well-known member
- Joined
- Dec 20, 2006
- Messages
- 712
It’s tough this time of year with the heat. A lot of guys struggle. Ok we all do! If it is low water too, they get a little bit Spookier than a Zara Pooch in a hayride on Halloween. You want some rain, but not too much. Get this dialed in right and it’s usually great conditions to try wet wading on the small creeks in summer. If your feet are cold you are going too slow or in the creek too much. If you are too hot get into the creek and slow down at the holes more. Looking forward to your next brookie already!
Cougarbaby
Well-known member
I thought that Pa doesn't clip fins anymore to time consuming and expensive,but that looks wild to me,I caught 13 brookies on a stocked stream and no fins were clipped
salmo
Well-known member
Ain’t nuthin like a brookie in my book. Tight lines my friend!
wildtrout2
Well-known member
Very true. It's where you need to go to catch natives, that I like the most about them.
CinnamonJoe
Well-known member
nymphingmaniac
Well-known member
yes. I recall posts about people fishing a small spring creek that runs through a rough part of Harrisburg. I also saw a good number of wild browns living in a small creek that flows through (partially) a mall parking lot . The lesson is water quality I guess.
I've fished that spring creek in Harrisburg, and I've caught trout there.
Some of the best brown trout streams flow through or past industrial looking settings. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.....or sumpin' like dat.
wildtrout2
Well-known member
The Elkhorn in WV is a good example, but it's got some great wild brown trout fishing, despite the raw sewage that gets dumped directly into it from local homes.
I've yet to see native brookies living in ugly places though.
rustbeltwilds
Well-known member
Yeo browns r tough !!!!
