Bear in mind this post is solely my opinion after experimenting for the past 13 years with chasing carp with the fly rod.
Starting with hooks. I like a 2X heavy standard wet fly hooks. I tie with the 2X heavy because I have had standard wire hooks fail on me on some really good carp over the years. If I had only one hook to tie a carp fly on it would be a Daiichi 1530, size 6. (Mustad and Tiemco also have good hooks that would cross reference with the Daiichi) I tie most of my carp flies on size 6 hooks but occasionally go down to an 8 if I want a bit smaller presentation.
I tie most of my carp flies with medium size black bead chain eyes (Clouser style). This gets them to the bottom gently and gets the fly riding hook point up. As far as materials - I use a lot of natural materials in earthy tones (black, brown, olive, tan, rust) that provide good movement. Marabou for tails, soft hackle collars out of partridge, pheasant, grouse, woodcock or my favorite soft hackle collar on one of my top producing carp flies uses a crow covert feather (which I harvest myself). I sometimes use a little bit of flash but I generally use it very sparingly. You’ll hear different schools of thought on this topic but I never use any kind of adhesive on my carp flies. If a fly falls apart from catching multiple carp that’s a good thing - I just blade it off the hook and spin up a new one.
As far as patterns - here are a few of the patterns that have consistently produced for me over the years. Some of them are my own creations and some are patterns like Gartside’s sparrow and Clouser’s swimming nymph and Foxxee Redd Minnow all tied with bead chain eyes. The only other top producing fly for me is my deer hair mulberry fly and that is a whole topic of its own.
Get your fly into the zone right in front of an actively feeding carp without the fish knowing you are there and you’ll be in business!!
Good luck with your tying and carpin’!
View attachment 1641255003
View attachment 1641255004View attachment 1641255005View attachment 1641255006View attachment 1641255007