Boat w/ trolling motor/fire extinguisher

jifigz

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 8, 2013
Messages
6,871
City
Miff-Co, PA
Not sure where this belongs, but we'll call it "gear." In PA, all "motorboats" are required to have at least one fire extinguisher. Is a basic jon boat pushed by a trolling motor a motor boat? I'm going to assume the law will say yes since I have a "motor." I usually don't bring a fire extinguisher if that's my setup.

You all are going to say it's best to have one and not worry about it, but what do you think of the law on that one? Is that a "motorboat?"
 
A wild guess would be NO because I often rent Jon boats with a transom mounted electric trolling motor at Octorora Reservoir. They follow ALL the rules & requirements when they rent you a boat, PFD's, whistle, etc., and they have never issued me a fire extinguisher.

Then there is this (Note numbers 1 & 2):

58 Pa. Code § 97.2 - Fire extinguishers

(a) All motorboats shall carry at least the minimum number of Coast Guard approved hand portable fire extinguishers required for their class as specified in Appendix B, except that motorboats less than 26 feet in length, propelled by outboard motors and not carrying passengers for hire, need not carry fire extinguishers if the construction of the motorboats will not permit the entrapment of explosive or flammable gases or vapors.

(1) Fire extinguishers shall be carried on motorboats that meet one or more of the following conditions. The motorboats have:


(i) Closed compartments under thwarts and seats where portable fuel tanks may be stored.
(ii) Double bottoms not sealed to the hulls or that are not completely filled with flotation material.
(iii) Closed living spaces.
(iv) Closed stowage compartments in which combustible or flammable materials are stowed.

(v) Permanently installed fuel tanks.

(2) The following conditions do not, in and of themselves, require that fire extinguishers be carried:


(i) Bait wells.
(ii) Glove compartments.
(iii) Buoyant flotation material.
(iv) Open slatted flooring.

(v) Ice chests.

(b) Motorboats engaged in a race which has been officially sanctioned, as set forth in 109.6 (relating to special marine events), or while engaged in tuning up for a race which has been officially sanctioned, need not carry the extinguisher required by this section.

(c) The following apply:

(1) Fire extinguishers carried in compliance with this section shall be maintained in good and serviceable working condition and in compliance with the specifications on the manufacturer's certification label , meaning all of the following:

(i) It shall not be expired.
(ii) It has a pressure gauge reading or indicator in the operable range or position, if there is one.
(iii) The lock pin is firmly in place.
(iv) The discharge nozzle is clean and free of obstruction.
(v) The extinguisher does not show visible signs of significant corrosion or damage.

(2) In prosecutions for violations of this section, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that a fire extinguisher is not usable if its gauge shows that the extinguisher is discharged.

(d) Fire extinguishers shall be installed and maintained so that they are immediately available within arms reach of the operator or passengers on the boat.

Notes
58 Pa. Code § 97.2
The provisions of this § 97.2 amended June 3, 1994, effective 6/4/1994, 24 Pa.B. 2795; amended April 19, 1996, effective 4/20/1996, 26 Pa.B. 1822; amended December 12, 2003, effective 1/1/2004, 33 Pa.B. 6061 Amended by Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 52, No. 49. December 3, 2022, effective 1/1/2023

The provisions of this § 97.2 amended under 30 Pa.C.S. § 5123.
 
Last edited:
A wild guess would be NO because I often rent Jon boats with a transom mounted electric trolling motor at Octorora Reservoir. They follow ALL the rules & requirements when they rent you a boat, PFD's, whistle, etc., and they have never issued me a fire extinguisher.

Then there is this (Note numbers 1 & 2):

58 Pa. Code § 97.2 - Fire extinguishers

(a) All motorboats shall carry at least the minimum number of Coast Guard approved hand portable fire extinguishers required for their class as specified in Appendix B, except that motorboats less than 26 feet in length, propelled by outboard motors and not carrying passengers for hire, need not carry fire extinguishers if the construction of the motorboats will not permit the entrapment of explosive or flammable gases or vapors.

(1) Fire extinguishers shall be carried on motorboats that meet one or more of the following conditions. The motorboats have:


(i) Closed compartments under thwarts and seats where portable fuel tanks may be stored.
(ii) Double bottoms not sealed to the hulls or that are not completely filled with flotation material.
(iii) Closed living spaces.
(iv) Closed stowage compartments in which combustible or flammable materials are stowed.

(v) Permanently installed fuel tanks.

(2) The following conditions do not, in and of themselves, require that fire extinguishers be carried:


(i) Bait wells.
(ii) Glove compartments.
(iii) Buoyant flotation material.
(iv) Open slatted flooring.

(v) Ice chests.

(b) Motorboats engaged in a race which has been officially sanctioned, as set forth in 109.6 (relating to special marine events), or while engaged in tuning up for a race which has been officially sanctioned, need not carry the extinguisher required by this section.

(c) The following apply:

(1) Fire extinguishers carried in compliance with this section shall be maintained in good and serviceable working condition and in compliance with the specifications on the manufacturer's certification label , meaning all of the following:

(i) It shall not be expired.
(ii) It has a pressure gauge reading or indicator in the operable range or position, if there is one.
(iii) The lock pin is firmly in place.
(iv) The discharge nozzle is clean and free of obstruction.
(v) The extinguisher does not show visible signs of significant corrosion or damage.

(2) In prosecutions for violations of this section, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that a fire extinguisher is not usable if its gauge shows that the extinguisher is discharged.

(d) Fire extinguishers shall be installed and maintained so that they are immediately available within arms reach of the operator or passengers on the boat.

Notes
58 Pa. Code § 97.2
The provisions of this § 97.2 amended June 3, 1994, effective 6/4/1994, 24 Pa.B. 2795; amended April 19, 1996, effective 4/20/1996, 26 Pa.B. 1822; amended December 12, 2003, effective 1/1/2004, 33 Pa.B. 6061 Amended by Pennsylvania Bulletin, Vol 52, No. 49. December 3, 2022, effective 1/1/2023

The provisions of this § 97.2 amended under 30 Pa.C.S. § 5123.
Ahhh, nice. Thanks for being better at finding it than I was.

Catching any nice snakeheads from the reservoir? Aren't there some tanks being caught from there?
 
Ahhh, nice. Thanks for being better at finding it than I was.

Catching any nice snakeheads from the reservoir? Aren't there some tanks being caught from there?

I ran into a kayaker there who was targeting them and reporting success, but I have never caught one or seen one, maybe because they are not on my radar...
 
Dear jifigz,

The easiest thing to remember is if the boat is less than 26' long and does not have an internal gas tank in the hull with flooring above it then the fire extinguisher is not required. That's pretty much the simple explanation for paragraph a) above. I had a 17' Crestliner deep V with an inboard tank and console steering, it had a fire extinguisher compartment built into the helm console. Most boats I've seen built similarly also have the compartment built in.

I've never operated an open hull boat with a portable gas tank and had a fire extinguisher on board. I've been checked by WW patrolmen in NY and PA, and even the USCG in DE and never had an issue. They did give a little guff for not having the boat registration card onboard though. That's a stupid law!

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Dear jifigz,

The easiest thing to remember is if the boat is less than 26' long and does not have an internal gas tank in the hull with flooring above it then the fire extinguisher is not required. That's pretty much the simple explanation for paragraph a) above. I had a 17' Crestliner deep V with an inboard tank and console steering, it had a fire extinguisher compartment built into the helm console. Most boats I've seen built similarly also have the compartment built in.

I've never operated an open hull boat with a portable gas tank and had a fire extinguisher on board. I've been checked by WW patrolmen in NY and PA, and even the USCG in DE and never had an issue. They did give a little guff for not having the boat registration card onboard though. That's a stupid law!

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
I was once on a friend’s boat who was issued a ticket for having a portable fuel tank under a bench seat that hinged up and down, thus making it in the eyes of the WCO “enclosed”.
 
I was once on a friend’s boat who was issued a ticket for having a portable fuel tank under a bench seat that hinged up and down, thus making it in the eyes of the WCO “enclosed”.
Or put another way, in an enclosed space. that portable fuel tank under a hinged bench seat was enclosed in a space where gas fumes can build to an explosive level. Gas fumes are only explosive once they get above a certain fumes/O2 ratio. That’s why you can smoke around a gas can with very little chance of ignition (not that I would recommend such a behavior). The fact that the bench seat was hinged does not make it un-enclosed. Fumes still condense and build just waiting for a spark or worse waiting for some unsuspecting smoker to open the lid unknowingly allowing a great concentration of gas fumes to escape into a lit cigarette.

Thankfully the WCO was there protecting, serving, and educating. The WCO saved someone from potentially selecting themselves out of the gene pool.
 
Or put another way, in an enclosed space. that portable fuel tank under a hinged bench seat was enclosed in a space where gas fumes can build to an explosive level. Gas fumes are only explosive once they get above a certain fumes/O2 ratio. That’s why you can smoke around a gas can with very little chance of ignition (not that I would recommend such a behavior). The fact that the bench seat was hinged does not make it un-enclosed. Fumes still condense and build just waiting for a spark or worse waiting for some unsuspecting smoker to open the lid unknowingly allowing a great concentration of gas fumes to escape into a lit cigarette.

Thankfully the WCO was there protecting, serving, and educating. The WCO saved someone from potentially selecting themselves out of the gene pool.
We were just 16 year old kids at the time. A quick explanation as to why it was technically enclosed would have sufficed.

But yes, thank god the WCO was there to write a ticket and save our lives. Thank goodness it wasn’t a day when he was assigned to be a glorified crossing guard for a trout stocking or we would have surely perished.
 
We were just 16 year old kids at the time. A quick explanation as to why it was technically enclosed would have sufficed.

But yes, thank god the WCO was there to write a ticket and save our lives. Thank goodness it wasn’t a day when he was assigned to be a glorified crossing guard for a trout stocking or we would have surely perished.
Whew. I, too, am glad you made it out alive.
 
Whew. I, too, am glad you made it out alive.
You’d have thought for such a dangerous and possibly deadly situation that we were in, we wouldn’t have been issued a fine and then allowed to continue using the boat for the rest of the day.
 
Back
Top