BOA system VS laces

mute

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 8, 2006
Messages
1,785
City
Montco
Whats your guys experience? Im traditionally a lace guy, Simms, Orvis Pros and more so in the years lately been trying all the Korkers brands. I like Korkers universality and concept of being able to swap the bottom spiked soles on any of my Korkers boots depending on which ones i want to wear during a certain season.

Ive never had a BOA system however. I tried them on and do like how quickly i can get them on and off compared to laces. I also loved the uniform tightness of the boot around the whole foot. I guess the only thing that keeps me from committing to them is the failure point of the BOA system VS traditional laces. A broken lace can easily be remediated, long term or short term. But a BOA system, whether the chances of failure are slim or not. Its always going to be when youre using the boots, miles into a mountain. Yes they have the field service kits to fix them, but now thats another item to uselessly carry in the pack.


Thoughts? Experiences?
 
I’ve never owned a BOA pair, and I know guys who swear by them, but IMO you’re adding complexity to something that doesn’t need it.

I’ve had two different fishing buddies blow a BOA lace, miles from the car, and they didn’t have a whole lot of fun the rest of the day. If you break a traditional lace, you can tie a knot and it’s not a day wrecker.

If you’re gonna go BOA, buy and carry a spare lace with you.
 
I've been using BOA boots (Korkers Devils Canyon) for about seven years. I replaced my first cable this summer. It's not a big deal to carry a replacement.

I just got a new pair for Christmas after I saw them on sale and hinted to my wife. There's still some life left in the old ones. I don't see myself going back to laces for two reasons. One is how much easier they are to get on/off. The second is the ability to tighten them up and keep them snug.

My only complaint is that it can be a little difficult to release them with cold/numb hands.
 
I’m on my second pair of BOA boots. First pair, had for two years before soles wore out. Replaced one lace. I currently have a two year old pair of BOA boots and have replaced two laces. Laces are covered under warranty from BOA and their service is good. Replacement took me about 10 minutes. You can see the cables start to fray so you have time to prepare. I like the simplicity and tight fit with BOA. Also, still have separate lace boots as backups.
 
Go laces- BOA will fail when you least want it to and your boots will be useless. On that note, bring an extra set of laces with you on any fairly committing trip too.

I watched a climber lose a mountaineering boot to a BOA failure above 18k on Denali and he required a high angle rescue and still probably lost his foot.
 
Had a pair of Boa's once. Had a wire break fairly quick. The company sent me 2 new ones quickly at no cost. After a while , they started to cut grooves into my wading shoes. Fishing in the winter, they would ice over making them just about impossible to get the boots off. I would have to sit in the truck with the heat on to let them thaw before I could loosen them. Used them about 3 years, haven't gone back.
 
I'll stick with traditional lace wading boots and simply keep back-up laces with me. I've yet to have a lace break while on the stream, or otherwise,
 
Got my first pair of BOA boots this year. My experience is very positive. Being older I’m not as flexible as in times past. My oversized gut makes bending over for long periods difficult. My suit up time is greatly reduced. Boot removal is quick and easy. Please note that I don’t get the stream time many on this site have.

For a 76 year old duffer they are “the bomb!”
 
Been using Korkers w BOAs for 3-4 seasons and won't go back. I do have a replacement wire kit in each of my bags - compact, light, and cheap at ~$10-15. The pop on/off convenience makes it worth it, BOAs don't come untied as you're wading up a stream, they're easy to adjust tightness on the stream (no different than laces I guess) and so on.

To be objective, and although I haven't had the need to make a field repair, it feels like it would be a lot more of a PITA compared to carrying a spare boot lace: allen keys and small screws - that sort of thing. Even with that, I'm very happy with my Korkers BOAs.

If you do make the BOA jump, one note about replacement kits: wire length varys boot to boot. Just make sure the replacement kit you're buying is compatible with the boot you're wearing.
 
And if you have a wide foot or high arch you will need a longer cable.
 
I have wanted to get BOA's but I have been talked out of them because of jamming and other mechanical issues. Maybe someday I will give them a try.
 
Back
Top