9’ 4wt Orvis Clearwater, TFO Blue Ribbon or St Croix Connect

Ok I think I am understanding a little better now. You want a backup rod to your small stream rod that could also serve you on larger streams.
To me an 8.5 would seem your best option. It would be more practical as it would serve as your backup small stream rod and your main medium stream rod. It could be your backup then to your St. Croix 6 on larger streams like Little Juniata or Penn’s.
Yeah I pondered an 8.5. One of my 2 piece rods is an old Clearwater 8.5 5wt. I did take it out on small water a few times like I did with my 9’6wt to get a feel for that length. It was too in the middle if that makes sense. Preferred the reach of the 9, and the 8.5 was too long for the benefits of using a shorter rod. Only reason I’m hanging on to it is in case my son ever wants to give fly fishing a shot.
 
For those of you who own or have fished the Redington Classic Trout, any issues with the single tightening nut? Wasn’t able to cast but was at least able to see and hold a Classic Trout and TFO Blue Ribbon today and the single nut really stuck out to me.
 
Thanks for all the responses, suggestions and experiences. Ended up with the Classic Trout 9’4wt. They had a few at Public Lands so took a ride. They also had several St Croix Connect just not the size I wanted. The St Croix looked and felt like a nice rod. Had 20% off so $160 was hard to pass for the Redington.

Haven’t had it on the water yet but hope to Friday. Enjoyed casting a small piece of indicator yarn in the yard. Definitely a different feel from what I’m used to and was really easy to cast with accuracy. Feels like it’ll be great for roll casts also.
 
Have a Clearwater 7’ 4wt and was looking for a second rod for backup to pack when hiking in more than a few miles from the truck. Generally fish smaller streams. Would also be nice to have the option of more length on some streams when the situation arises. Fish mostly dries and streamers but do nymph on occasion but not crazy into that.

Have a few Clearwaters in other weights/lengths and they’ve been good. Love my St Croix spinning rods and the one older Pro Graphite fly rod has been good to me. Never tried TFO.

Other than lack of keeper on Clearwater any major differences other than warranties? Don’t want to overthink it.

Thanks
Slide one of them small indicator o rings down over your top eye on the bottom section,heck I did 2 for double nymph and you can slide them up and down for different tag lengths,never missed the hook keeper on my couple of Clearwaters since
 
Back
Top