pwk5017 wrote:
The author hits the nail on the head why i use flouro for nymphing. In his test, he states flouro sinks 3-4x faster than mono. He then goes on to say this isnt that big of a deal, because on a normal conventional cast, in 30-60 seconds your bait would sink 2-4' more than mono. When nymphing, that sink rate is an enormous factor for me catching fish. I need all the help i can get out there, so spending another $30-50 a season for a flouro leader and flouro tippet isnt that big of a deal for me.
The price disparity between the two is a bit much.
Fredrick wrote:
I cant give you guys the link to the video but there is video on youtube testing the abrasion resistance of nylon vs fluro and nylon beat fluro out by a big margin .
afishinado wrote:
Fredrick wrote:
I cant give you guys the link to the video but there is video on youtube testing the abrasion resistance of nylon vs fluro and nylon beat fluro out by a big margin .
I saw the video. The guy ran the lines over sandpaper and counted the strokes. Don't believe everything you see on the internet.
Brands of line/tippet vary, but fluoro tests as more abrasion resistant under actual conditions. The real key to nylon vs fluoro is nylon absorbs water and becomes weaker, stretches more, and becomes less abrasion resistant when actually fishing it on in the stream.
Not long ago, I ran out of fluoro and used nylon mono tippet instead for nymphing. My tippet kept getting abraded on the rocks in short order with the nylon and I had to retie way more than I would when using fluoro.
Conversely, nylon is generally more limp than fluoro and floats better, so it may be a better choice for fishing dries. I use nylon tippet for dries.
Either will work, but especially for deep nymphing in the rocks, I find fluoro works best for me. Any savings I get by using the cheaper nylon tippet is eaten up by having to retie my rig more often. YMMV.
Fredrick wrote:
afishinado wrote:
Fredrick wrote:
I cant give you guys the link to the video but there is video on youtube testing the abrasion resistance of nylon vs fluro and nylon beat fluro out by a big margin .
I saw the video. The guy ran the lines over sandpaper and counted the strokes. Don't believe everything you see on the internet.
Brands of line/tippet vary, but fluoro tests as more abrasion resistant under actual conditions. The real key to nylon vs fluoro is nylon absorbs water and becomes weaker, stretches more, and becomes less abrasion resistant when actually fishing it on in the stream.
Not long ago, I ran out of fluoro and used nylon mono tippet instead for nymphing. My tippet kept getting abraded on the rocks in short order with the nylon and I had to retie way more than I would when using fluoro.
Conversely, nylon is generally more limp than fluoro and floats better, so it may be a better choice for fishing dries. I use nylon tippet for dries.
Either will work, but especially for deep nymphing in the rocks, I find fluoro works best for me. Any savings I get by using the cheaper nylon tippet is eaten up by having to retie my rig more often. YMMV.
The sandpaper was there to simulate the mouth of a bass or similar fish with sandpaper type teeth. I'm not giving up on my fluro because of the sinking properties and higher shelf life, but will be using mono a little more now in the future.
Dave_W wrote:
I use flouro often for abrasion resistance and for toothy critters.
A few months ago, I did a little experiment with 20lb mono and 20lb flouro: I pulled a length along a scissor blade (I though this was a good approximation of the sharpness of a muskie tooth). I assumed it would take more pulls to sever the flouro. In fact, it took 13 pulls to sever the mono and 13 to sever the flouro. I repeated the experiment and got roughly the same result.
I still like flouro for abrasion resistance but I'm not as confident as I used to be.
Bamboozle wrote:
Tossing science & shootouts aside, I stated using fluoro (Vanish) on my baitcasters years ago and couldn't be happier with the handling, abrasion resistance and the results however I still prefer mono on spinning reels.
For fly-fishing I was a dyed in the wool fan of mono for tippets but HATED the flat spots and resultant curly cues it got if I drew a knot improperly or from pulling a tangle from around a hard surface like a tree branch or rod tip. Not even a rubber pad would get rid of flat spot curls.
For that reason alone and because of my baitcasting experience I decided to try fluoro for my tippets and again, I couldn’t be happier with the results. I use it for dries too and have no problems with sinking flies and to be honest, I prefer my dry fly tippets to NOT float.
In regards to the cost difference…
On an average day I am hard pressed to use more than a yard or two of tippet since I tend to swap leaders versus fussing with cutting back or adding tippets when I go from surface to subsurface.
That two yards of fluoro represents about 25% of the cost of the gas I used getting to the creek, or the same percentage of the cost of the cigar I am usually smoking, the beers I drank beforehand or one of the strike indicators I may lose because I drank the beer.
In other words I don't fret about it.
afishinado wrote:
Bamboozle wrote:
Tossing science & shootouts aside, I stated using fluoro (Vanish) on my baitcasters years ago and couldn't be happier with the handling, abrasion resistance and the results however I still prefer mono on spinning reels.
For fly-fishing I was a dyed in the wool fan of mono for tippets but HATED the flat spots and resultant curly cues it got if I drew a knot improperly or from pulling a tangle from around a hard surface like a tree branch or rod tip. Not even a rubber pad would get rid of flat spot curls.
For that reason alone and because of my baitcasting experience I decided to try fluoro for my tippets and again, I couldn’t be happier with the results. I use it for dries too and have no problems with sinking flies and to be honest, I prefer my dry fly tippets to NOT float.
In regards to the cost difference…
On an average day I am hard pressed to use more than a yard or two of tippet since I tend to swap leaders versus fussing with cutting back or adding tippets when I go from surface to subsurface.
That two yards of fluoro represents about 25% of the cost of the gas I used getting to the creek, or the same percentage of the cost of the cigar I am usually smoking, the beers I drank beforehand or one of the strike indicators I may lose because I drank the beer.
In other words I don't fret about it.
Sounds like your trips are a combination of fishing and par-tee, with all the smokin' and drinkin'. Nice!....it great to get out there and have a good time.