West Branch of the Delaware River, Wayne County, 5/30/09-06/01/09

3wt7X

Active member
Joined
Nov 19, 2008
Messages
704
I had a break in my schedule, which allowed me to get away for a couple of days, so I called up a fishing buddy and we took the trip up to the famous Upper Delaware River region. We arrived on 05/30/2009 at about 06:00 pm and immediately noticed the high water levels. The West Branch was running at about 1700 CFS and the water was slightly off colored. The Main Stem was still pushing at close to 7000 CFS, so we chose to stick with the West Branch.

Upon entering the West Branch, we noticed that the water was moving pretty good, but wading was managable. That evening the air temperatures were in the 60 degree range and there were numerous bugs on the water. I observed green drakes, Slate drakes, sulphers, and numerous caddis. There were other mayflies, but my identification ability is limited. The wind was blowing pretty hard until about 07:45 pm, so I started by nymphing and my buddy was throwing an olive bugger. He missed a trout almost immediately after our arrival and I did not get a hit on my prince nymph. At about 08:00 pm, we noticed thousands of spent mayflies on the water and the fish started slurping the top. It was one of the most frustrating evenings fly fishing that I have ever had with so many naturals on the water. I found myself simply setting the hook to the rise forms in the area of my fly, which left me empty handed. My buddy had the same luck and we returned to the truck amazed at the spectacle that we witnessed, but a little perplexed as to what to do the next night to prevent getting skunked again.

The following morning was a definate redeemer. I had read about the alewife population in the reservoir above the West Branch and I decided to get up at 05:00 am and throw some white streamers. This produced immediately as I landed a nice 18 inch female brown on my third cast. I was the first one on the river, so I waited for my buddy to arrive after his morning coffee to move upstream. He tied on a similar pattern and was hooked up shortly after with a beautiful 19 inch hook jawed male that fought like a much bigger fish. I then found a nice side channel to the river with some overhanging trees and root systems. I made a decent presentation and started stripping the fly as fast as I could and witnessed an eruption. After about a 15 minute battle, I landed a very thick 21 inch brown. I think the the key to that streamer fishing was a fast presentation because those fish really wanted to attack the fly. Shortly after, the sun rose above the mountain and the streamer fishing stopped. My buddy's brother, who joined us from Connecticut, landed a nice brown on a caddis pupa nymph, but the fishing slowed significantly for the better part of the mid-day.

We rested for a while and did some local exploring in the truck. We also spoke to some local guides, who suggested a size 14 rusty spinner as a consistent pattern for the evening hatch. Monday evening was cloudy and more humid and warm than previous night, but the insects were not nearly as thick. The water did not seem to drop much on the second day, but it did appear much clearer. I set up on a nice looking eddy that I scouted during the previous day and the fish began to rise at about 08:10 pm. I immediatly stuck a small brown on the rusty spinner and three cast later at the end of a long drift my dry fly was slurped again. I set up on this fish and it was in my backing in seconds, so I started chasing it down stream. I finally caught up to it about a football field away from my original spot and managed to get it into slow water. My buddy's friend helped me net it and I observed a very health 19 inch wild rainbow. That fish was by far the hardest fighting stream trout that I've taken, but those Upper Delaware Rainbow's reputations proceed them. It got dark shortly after and I returned to the truck a very happy fly fisherman.

The next morning was rainy and cloudy and we did manage a fish or two early, but we had to hit the road by noon. In all, as some of you may have experienced, the Upper Delaware System is an amazing fishery. We only covered about a mile and a half of one of the branches and we were very fortunate. I feel that this is one of New York and Pennsylvania's top notch resources and it deserves the respect and protection to ensure that it stays that way for a long time. I know that I will be paying a lot more attention to the politics surrounding the Delaware now that I've had the opportunity to enjoy it.
 
I love your reports and pics! Keep them coming man. Just beautiful!
 
I can't tell who is smiling more that brownie or the fishman.
 
Fantastic report and great photos (as usual). That big brown will be a fish to remember. I still think people who don't like streamer fishing are missing out on some great fishing, esp for large fish.
 
Great report. Makes me look for time in my schedule to make the trip up there. Hope you don't mind if I shamelessly copy your strategies.
 
Nice report! You timed it well. Those red brown spinner patterns in the eve can slay trout!
 
You guys certainly head to deal with a lot more water than I did when I fished it in april.
The west branch was running between 200 and 300 cfs then.
It made wading and reaching fish very easy. But, on the other hand, they were very spooky
Glad you had a good time there
 
Excellent report and nice fish!

Did you see didymo up there? I had heard it was a big problem, but you seemed to be in fly fish heaven up there.

I was near Phoenecia, NY, and I am sad to report that the didymo is a serious problem on the Esopus in and around Phoenecia.
 
Sunra,
I do think that I saw a lot of Didymo on the West Branch. I've seen the stuff on the Gunpowder and it looked very comparable to what was on the Delaware. It was most prevelent attached to the grassy edges of the islands. It did not seem to effect the bug or fish activity.

Izzitart,
I hope that you make it up there. I would not begin to claim those techniques as my strategies. We just used the proven methods of the local experts and it produced. I think that next year, I am going to make a full week long trip of it during the latter part of May. I honestly don't believe that anyone can even scratch the surface of understanding that fishery in a couple days of fishing.
 
If you were in Didymo clean your boots, waders. line, net, even flies. Freezing will kill the stuff, or a clorox solution. The internet has several websites that explain how.
 
excellent report and beautiful fish. I'm glad to hear that you enjoyed your trip to the Delaware system.

As you know, the WB Delaware has confirmed didymo. If you haven't already, please be sure to clean your fishing gear before your next trip and keep PA free of didymo. Here is a link for cleaning solutions for anybody who has fished waters with didymo, just scroll to the bottom.

http://www.dec.ny.gov/press/53996.html
 
ns023 and Martinlf,
I greatly appreciate you concern for containing the Didymo problem. I was already a couple steps ahead of you and I've done everything that I know to decontaminate my fly fishing equiptment. I've seen the affects of Didymo on Gunpowder falls in Maryland and I refuse to fish that stream because I do not want to risk spreading the invasive. I did not realize that the West Branch had confirmed cases of Didymo until I fished it, but I have to admit that it is not going to stop me from fishing it again.
 
Back
Top