West Branch Brandywine (Chester), 04/03/10

mystillwater

Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2009
Messages
131
Saturday... Opening day... yowzer... it was my first opening day trout experience. probably my last. there were Bubbas spaced out about 10 feet apart the length of the creek by 8am.

with that said, my buddy and i managed to find some decently quiet water and waited it out until everyone caught their limit and went home. by 11:30am it was pretty much cleared out.

i realized the difference between spin fisherman and fly fisherman.... spinners complain about the bugs, fly fisherman rave about them...

anyway, the fisher were taking a little bit of everything. my buddy had a few takes on a small black beadhead woolly bugger. i'm convinced this fly will catch you a fish on the Brandywine 365 days a year. i brought my first Brookie to hand with a woolly as well.







bugs were hatching but only saw 2 or 3 trout break the surface. we couldn't coax them into taking a dry.

went back out this morning and found it to be a little quieter but still surprisingly crowded for a monday morning. still, not hard to find a stretch to yourself. after not getting much action on the trusty woolly i rigged up a pheasant tail with a scud dropper. this was brilliant.

i'm fairly new to fly fishing in general and nymphing was a discipline that always intimidated me. i tired it many times but never had any success. its one of those things that i always think i'm doing wrong and until i catch a fish, i'll never feel comfortable that i'm getting it.

well, today things clicked. i was in a great spot. there was a pool below a bit of a drop in the creek and the water was kind of dumping off into the pool and shooting around some rock outcrop. past the outcrop, the water slowed a bit before dumping again below. i was able to cast a quarter upstream into the heavier current and watch my indicator as it moved into slower water at about 90 degrees. as it hit a quarter downstream it would begin to swing and the fish were begging for it at that point. i caught 4 in an hour and all on nymphs. 2 took the dropper and 2 took the pheasant tail. a rainbow, a brown and 2 brookies... the Brandywine Triple Crown. didn't manage a picture of all of them but here are a couple:





all released safely. my most succesful day on the fly. and i fell in love with nymphing. i'm certainly not a pro by any means but at least i tasted some success so i know i'm on the right track. and even better, i found out it was a blast to fish a nymph when they're taking! pretty cool day.

on the way out, i ran into these guys:









looks like many more happy days of fishing this spring on the Brandywine... might have to go out again tomorrow.

cheers!
 
From the number of fisher people you encountered, it's apparent you were in the stocked section near Hibernia. The PBFC doesn't stock brook trout in that stream. I'm guessing some private club does. Maybe the guys you photographed? Friends and I catch rainbows and browns (which don't hold over, LOL) downstream year around. All are stocked by so-called clubs and some individuals.
 
you are correct about the spot. my friends and i fish that run pretty much all year around as well. typically we're catching rainbow there... never seen a brown or a brookie there until this week. i didn't get a close enough to see what they were putting into the buckets... i'm hoping to find out the old fashioned way tomorrow 🙂

i actually caught a 19" rainbow there last year! that one i actually kept (which i rarely do... unfortunately i injured it trying to land the monster) and it was tasty for a couple of meals.
 
According to the PFBC website, it does stock rainbows and browns, but no brookies. Someone's doing it. LOL.
 
englishprof wrote:
According to the PFBC website, it does stock rainbows and browns, but no brookies. Someone's doing it. LOL.

thats interesting... the fist one i caught was way down past the bridge... right above flat rock... it was my understanding the PFBC wasn't stocking that area this year. maybe some privates were stocking down there too?


side note:


i'd love to find out how far the fish migrate from where they were initially stocked. i have a feeling they move a good bit when the water starts getting warm to find some cooler water.
 
Nice report there. I've fished that stretch. That does get a lot of bubba action for sure!

I think it's the Downingtown Trout Club (?) that raises a lot of brookies for the East and West Branch. They have the trout pens in Kerr Park.

On another sort of but not really related note, I caught 3 very small brookies that were perfect in health and appearance ranging from 3 - 5 inches in West Valley the other day in the regs section. I know they did not come from the aforementioned club. I can't imagine a scenario where they would have been planted as fingerlings or even fry. I'm puzzled as to where they came from. Not sure of any brookie tribs anywhere close to that section.
 
went back again this morning. same spot. caught my first on the first cast. gotta love that! caught a few more... mostly all about 6". Browns and Rainbows today. Caught a pretty giant. Was really excited thinking i had a nice trout. boo. then i hooked a REALLY nice Brown... got it almost to hand but it slipped off. i bet it was close to 15". i tried to find him again for the rest of the day.

interesting note: i had 4 or 5 fish surface and hit my strike indicator. had a couple to the same thing yesterday. is this common? i tried tying on a dry fly to use as an indicator but didn't get any hits on that and had a heck of a time following it in the fast moving water.

saw less fisherman today. still marvel at the fact that most of the guys in this area have no problem tromping thru your pool. they'd probably share your rock with you if they thought they'd catch a fish. drives me crazy.
 
Chunk,

Broad Run is a natural reproduction tributary to West Valley though it enters a good bit downstream from where you were. I believe it's known to hold browns, not brookies. This is interesting. Where's Rookie or whatever his name is now?
 
LOL right here eProf!

never seen a brookie in the 100 yards or so of Broad Run that I've fished (yeah I realize that's not really saying much) and it would be a real hike for fingerling wild brookies to make it from Broad Run to the SR section on west valley. Last year I saw what I thought was a wild brookie upstream from the SR. pretty big though so I dismissed it as a club stockie. But maybe there is something there after all. Non-Pfbc organizations definitely do stock brookies in W Valley and both branches of the Brandywine.

hopefully I will get out for stockies on west valley tomorrow for the first time this season.
 
another good day yesterday, here's one of the catches (foul hooked but he swam away ok):



short day today... decided to break out my 9' 6wt and try out a different nymphing stratagy... it ended badly:



i didn't have anything to cut the hook so i left it in and drove all the way back to west chester. i spent 30 min digging this thing out. bummer.
 
Back
Top