Sugar Creek, Venango Co, 5-10-2025

Prospector

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2015
Messages
1,195
City
Butler Co home, Forest Co camp
Time Fished: 635pm - 825pm

Weather Conditions: Around 73 degrees and Sunny

Water Conditions: I forgot to take a temp but since their were rising fish, it had to be warmer. Creek was bank to bank, lots of water, probably 4-5 foot visibility.

Insects: I saw a dark bodied spinner around a sz 14 and I saw a tan caddis. Only 5 total rises

I got on Sugar with a tight window to fish. Plan A came together when no one was fishing the place I planned to start. My mindset coming in was that the stream would not be very clear. So I tied on a streamer at the road, but the water was more clear than expected. First streamer pass concluded without a fish being caught but having 4 misses.

I went back to the top of the riffle and tied on an olive woolly below a royal coachman wet fly. That combo fished pretty well. All 3 browns took the bugger and the lone rainbow favored the coachman. Second pass I switched the point fly to a white woolly bugger and caught another brown on it. I started a 3rd pass but a spin fisherman arrived and cut me off. I took that opportunity to move downstream.

The water downstream was really flowing heavy. The first part of that riffle was very deep, so I felt most fish didn’t have a chance. I worked it about 40 yds before I had a strike. After that point the trout turned on and several were able to see the fly. Once again a rainbow chose the Royal Coachman with the other rainbow and brown attacked the bugger.

All told, I caught 5 browns and 3 rainbows on 31 total strikes. I weeded out 2 rainbows for my wife’s lunch on Sunday.

I caught a few smaller browns (8”-9”) that could have passed for wild trout. Not sure of their true origin, it just seemed odd.
 
Last edited:
Took a stomach contents photo (for those that care about such things). Both stomach’s behind. I thought there might be something more interesting, so I just included it.

IMG_1636.jpeg
 
Thanks for the report, Prospector. I'm not looking for spot burning but can you give me an idea of what area is best on this stream? I plan on making a trip up there soon. I've fished the lower end where it comes into French Creek with little luck. Is this section very productive? Are there consistently better areas? Thanks.
 
Thanks for the report, Prospector. I'm not looking for spot burning but can you give me an idea of what area is best on this stream? I plan on making a trip up there soon. I've fished the lower end where it comes into French Creek with little luck. Is this section very productive? Are there consistently better areas? Thanks.

I've had good luck at almost every bridge crossing. There is plenty of access from Rt 27 to the mouth. The creek is much smaller north of Cooperstown where East Branch S.C. joins the main branch.

It gets a lot of stocked fish from Cooperstown to the mouth. My only knock against Sugar is that there are some stretches of flat featureless water that don't hold fish. Good habitat will have fish.
 
Last edited:
I've had good luck at almost every bridge crossing. There is plenty of access from Rt 27 to the mouth. The creek is much smaller north of Cooperstown where East Branch S.C. joins the main branch.

It gets a lot of stocked fish from Cooperstown to the mouth. My only knock against Sugar is that there are some stretches of flat featureless water that don't hold fish. Good habitat will have fish.
To add to your point, one day I was fishing at the bridge upstream from the golf course. The creek was up and discolored and a light rain continued. Two guys in their 20s came fishing past me and they had a jumbo net with them. They were obviously targeting large browns in the best conditions in a long stretch that gets little pressure. So I spot burned one stretch but there is another stretch that I know of that has big brown potential, for those folks that are up for that challenge.
 
Does School House run feed into Sugar Run? Been a long time since I fished there. GG
 
Fished it 5/5 in high water. I think they stocked that day because I caught a couple dozen, Missed a very large RB that missed my hornberg about 3 ft from the bank. There were 4 golden rainbows swimming in the high water but they could still be seen, I was at what I always referred to as Fetterman's Bridge. Next day I took wife to intersection in Cooperstown and she caught a couple on a spinner. I fished E Branch briefly and caught 3 there. On Creek Rd heading towards Pap's camp,
 
Back
Top