Spring Creek, Fisherman’s Paradise, Centre Co, 6-3-18

Prospector

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 7, 2015
Messages
1,195
City
Butler Co home, Forest Co camp
Time Fished: 6am - 10am

Weather Conditions: 63 degrees Cloudy, raining most of the time, sometimes heavy

Water Conditions: water temp was 58 degrees. Running heavy and was an offcolor brown

Insects: a few Sulphur and caddis

As I slid into the public lot at Fisherman’s Paradise the light drizzle I’d been driving in turned into a true down pour. My plan since the previous night was to use streamers but the weather conditions made that the only option. Sort of ideal conditions with heavy rain, off color water and the fact that it was very early in the morning.

I hadn’t been to Fisherrman’s Paradise since 1979 and it has changed a lot. The manicured grass up to waters edge is now replaced by 3 feet tall weeds along the streams edge. I’m sure this is better both environmentally and to supply more food, cover and shade to the fish but it sure makes it tough on a streamer fisherman. Roll casting with weeds around. stripping line into a tangled pile in the weeds and having to repeatedly pick up and move. This part was not fun. The good news is the abundance of willing fish made it worth the hassle.

I parked in the lower lot so I fished upstream to the upper limit of paradise. I used a yellow maribou and caught 5 browns on 25 strikes. I rarely count strikes but today I decided to keep track. I switched streamers at the top of the project. On the way back I switched to a feather wing streamer that I designed and It’s producing well enough to earn more playing time. It also had the added appeal of being a dark streamer and that would be in contrast to the lighter streamer I used earlier. Also I felt darker might be easier to see in the cloudy water. So when I reached the truck my feather wing fly had netted 7 browns on 42 strikes. I found it interesting that the dark fly accounted for 68% more strikes than the first fly.

Was it easier for the fish to see? Did it have better action? Did it match natural food better? Were the fish just more active later? Did the rain washing in “turn on” the stream?

I’m not sure but he earned more playing time again. The disturbing thing was... I generally assume 5:1 ratio of strikes to fish caught on streamers. The yellow marabou met those expectations but the feather wing fly dipped had a 6:1 ratio. I need to look at a refinement to pull that back in line.

But 11 trout on 67 strikes made this a worthwhile trip. That’s a strike every 3 minutes and 42 seconds. Streamers are underutilized but proper conditions do make a big difference too. Also if you are fishing streamers you must be committed to covering a lot of ground. First quickly and move on looking for aggressive fish.

I also had the whole section to myself. I didn’t have to avoid anyone.
 
Good report and some interesting results and data regarding your streamer effort. Thanks!
DW
 
Adjust your hook size, position or gape.

I'm a huge streamer fisherman and after years of experimenting with those 3 controllable variables ive got my hook up rate to over 90%.
 
Prospector wrote:

Was it easier for the fish to see? Did it have better action? Did it match natural food better? Were the fish just more active later? Did the rain washing in “turn on” the stream?

I’m not sure but he earned more playing time again. The disturbing thing was... I generally assume 5:1 ratio of strikes to fish caught on streamers. The yellow marabou met those expectations but the feather wing fly dipped had a 6:1 ratio. I need to look at a refinement to pull that back in line.

Fishing upstream vs downstream makes a difference as well, both for number of strikes and hookup ratio. Also, just being a bit more tired on the way back down might have affected hookup ratio. There are always more variables in fly fishing than we can really account for.

Still, I'm a great believer in the "dark day, dark fly" adage.
 
Sculpins are probably the main baitfish in Spring Creek. Many are dark olive in color, almost black.



 
Cool report. I do science and math all week as part of my job I would never have the mindset to do it at play. I fish to get away from all that. But I am glad there are those that do. That keeps the sport advancing, so thank you.

On the rare occasion I do fish "minners", I do miss alot more than I catch. I just remember the locations for next time.

N
 
Really interesting report, thanks!

I've tended to have poor hookup ratios fishing streamers on Spring Creek as well. But elsewhere I think it's probably 50% or so. Not sure what it is about the stream that they don't just go full attack mode (or that I've never experienced it). Maybe angling pressure??
 
Lol!
 
His ratios are not stellar enough. That said, if I had a dime for every "aaaaaaahhh!" I utter versus every "whooo-hooo!," I'd be a very rich man. And this answers the thread titled "Why?"
 
Back
Top