Spring Creek, Centre County, 12/10/16 (Canyon & Milesburg)

DanL

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2014
Messages
287
I fished Spring Creek on Saturday, December 10th. Earlier in the week, I debated whether or not to try Erie for Steelhead or central PA, but as the weather reports came in, the decision was much easier to make as I didn't feel like dealing with lake-effect snow.

I parked at Fisherman's Paradise and walked up the canyon stretch and fished up to around the bend for about 3 hours. Air temps were around 25, and stream thermometer read 43 when I started. There were two anglers getting ready to fish but I had the entire canyon to myself as they stayed right near the parking lot.

I was hoping to see some BWO's popping off but didnt notice any so I nymped the entire time. Caught 2 on hot spot pheasant tail nymphs in the riffles. Fish were very spooky. Saw a pod of what seemed like 100+ post-spawn fish, almost appearing as if sleeping in the pool right above the bend. Some pretty big fish, can't wait to get back in the spring and try to catch them again when they are ready for action.

After a lunch break, I went down to Milesburg for a couple hours, and fished right around that new stream bank stabilization project that Spring Creek TU just put in. I caught 3 right along the wall as I worked my way up, using olive scud patterns.

Was a nice day to be out and not as cold as they said it would be. 5 hours of fishing is better than nothing. I ended up driving home Sunday morning because I didn't want to get stuck in the snow, but I probably should have just stayed there as it didn't get too bad from what I see.
 
DanL wrote:

Saw a pod of what seemed like 100+ post-spawn fish, almost appearing as if sleeping in the pool right above the bend.

Are you sure they weren't suckers?

In some of the slower deeper pools in Spring Creek you will see big pods of suckers laying on the bottom.


 
troutbert wrote:
DanL wrote:

Saw a pod of what seemed like 100+ post-spawn fish, almost appearing as if sleeping in the pool right above the bend.

Are you sure they weren't suckers?

In some of the slower deeper pools in Spring Creek you will see big pods of suckers laying on the bottom.

I was thinking the same thing troutbert.
 
I tend to see more suckers as winter goes on. Maybe that's just because the water becomes lower and more clear.
 
Also suckers migrate like crazy to find better water temps in the winter. I fish the Elk in WV a lot and they migrate like crazy to spots you don't see them in all year round.
 
3oh4 wrote:
Also suckers migrate like crazy to find better water temps in the winter. I fish the Elk in WV a lot and they migrate like crazy to spots you don't see them in all year round.

Where do they migrate from, and to, in the winter?
 
Well, in hind sight, it's possible that some were suckers, but every few seconds one or two would peel off and move a bit and I'm sure they were trout so maybe they were having a party together. This wasn't a super-deep pool but just slower moving water. (oh, and P.S: now I feel like an idiot...LOL)

 
Dan L--There's a lot of trout in that creek. Don't let these armchair anglers on here tell you what you saw.
 
Someone told me that suckers are really tasty. I've never had one. Has anyone tried them? Are they any good?
 
foxtrapper1972 wrote:
Dan L--There's a lot of trout in that creek. Don't let these armchair anglers on here tell you what you saw.

Of course there are a lot trout in that creek.

And no one said otherwise.

So, could you explain why you wrote that?
 
troutbert- Why should DanL now feel like an idiot? People who weren't there immediately saying those were suckers. DanL now doubting what he saw because guys who weren't there dispute him. I don't know him but he says he saw trout and trout do bunch up like that in that creek. (And mix in with suckers too) I've seen it.
 
I seen a sucker in that creek that was twenty inches long and it had red spots. It was hiding with some regular suckers.
 
foxtrapper1972 wrote:
troutbert- Why should DanL now feel like an idiot?

No one said that DanL should feel like an idiot.

There was nothing personal at all in my response to DanL.

My post was just ideas & comments on FISH, based on observations on Spring Creek.



 
Hi all, I was just saying that I felt like an idiot, in jest. I wasn't taking anything personally nor was I offended in any way, to be honest.

I'm just happy to get some fly fishing in this time of year before it got really cold!


 
It's pretty easy to get a rise out of troutbert. Even easier than getting one on Spring Creek
 
Hey Fox, the purpose of the stream reports is not to create conflict.

A statement was made and suggestions were made to correct it. Your input was not helpful nor is it welcome here in this forum.

Please refrain from being antagonistic in the stream reports.
 
Good Afternoon,

I for one can say I saw not one but two pods of brownies in the Gunpowder last week spawning like crazy with a few suckers in the mix. Not a betting man, but I can only figure the males were dominating the females and the suckers were there eating what eggs they could. I watched this take place over the course of about a 1/2 hour for each pod of fish I was watching. Not the first time I have seen this behavior in the beginning of winter.

Frankly catching a sucker on a fly is quite fun in my opinion.

My two cents 🙂
 
Maurice-Wait....I am of the opinion that they might be trout because I've seen trout in SPRING CREEK DOING WHAT DAN DESCRIBED ( he is making the report of what he just observed) (and immediately his report is questioned by people who weren't there) and I voice my view and that is antagonistic? I must have missed something? Go ahead delete my posts if they are offensive. I give up. Won't intrude on your blessed stream reports anymore.
 
Back
Top