Penns Creek, Union County, 5/22-26/21

DaveKile

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 13, 2021
Messages
7,514
City
Pennsylvania
I said I wasn’t going to spend my whole trip on Penns Creek this year. I did get one one day on the Little J, so I guess I stuck to my guns. This stream just sucks me in to meet the challenges and think that I can figure out her out. I did better and learned a few things, but I only gained feet not yards on this trip.

Many of the guys up for the Unofficial Jam went to Penns on Saturday. Maurice and I then left and stayed at a place in Millmont next to Penns until Wednesday. With the warmer weather over the previous two weeks I fully expected to see Green Drakes when we moved downstream after The Jam. We did and it turned into more of an obsession for several days about where and when they would hatching than I thought.



Weather - the early part of the trip the skies we very clear and temps were in the upper 80’s. The last couple of days things gotten better with temps in the barely in the 70’s and cloudy days.

Water - It had not rained for several weeks and Penns was low at about ~250 CFS during the trip. This was ideal for me and found it a lot easier to find the best riffles and runs. Water was very clear of course.

Hatches - Things really varied from day to day and location to location. Generally, we found sulfurs in the evening. Also in the evenings every night there were spinners of all kinds. I ran into a magnificent sulphur spinner fall Saturday night on Tunnel Road in the riffles of the faster water. Everything from Sunday through Wednesday was a mix of location and times.

The Green Drakes and Coffin Flies were full on and seemed like for several days below Weikert when we got that way on 5/23. There were moving upstream as they usually do and peaked on 5/24 in Weikert from 10-11 am we heard. The Coffin Flies were in full force most of the days. But completely gone in Millmont by 5/25. Upstream Green Drakes emerged steady during the day, but never in a condensed hatch.



We ran into evening sulphur hatches on 5/22, 5/23 and 5/24. These were on different parts of the stream depending on our day. But we also had nights when sulfurs we coming off and 100 feet away we didn’t have anything going on. We could have had Cahills, but the drakes, sulphurs and spinners in the evening overwhelmingly took the stage. Caddis were very sporadic everyday.



Evening spinner falls were generally pretty big very night. There would be be a mix of March Brown, sulphur, Cahill?, and Coffin Fly spinners all around in the evening depending on the day and location. Classic Penns Creek bug soup.



Generally, fishing turned out to be as crazy as the conditions. Saturday (5/22) with everyone on Tunnel road turned out to be a tough day with the blue bird skies even during the evening hatch and spinner fall. Didn’t do much better on the next day downstream. Things improved for me Monday night with the sulphur hatch around Weikert. Tuesday we keyed into the Green Drake hatch and missed a lot and caught some. That evening I did okay with my B52 Rusty Spinners.

Plenty of other people chasing Drakes and heard the Cherry Run parking was packed. We stayed away from that area.



Penns Creek really sucks me in with the the trout and beautiful setting. It was fun to hang out with Maurice and find some new places. I caught one of my better wild browns on drake at almost 20”. Penns is not easy on the legs with all those greased bowling balls on the stream bed. It can really beat you up and to think when I was younger I would run around there without a wading staff? Another great trip, as I caught more than I normally do on Penns, but she is a tough mother.

 
Great report! I was also up there all week but I was part of the Cherry mayhem. Spinnerfalls were AMAZING and it was a great drake hatch as usual. I met some new friends this trip and hung out with my boy disco and I think everyone on the river was smoking fish left and right. Great week to be up there that's for sure.
 
Is it just me or was the GD hatch earlier-than-normal this year? I don't ever recall it coinciding with the Jam(ish) dates...

Some nice feesh ya got there!
 
Nice report Dave. My favorite stream and there isn’t a close second. Hoping temperatures moderate for some early summer fishing now that the green drake madness is about done for the year.
 
wgmiller wrote:
Is it just me or was the GD hatch earlier-than-normal this year? I don't ever recall it coinciding with the Jam(ish) dates...

Some nice feesh ya got there!
I think the Jam was just later this year than normal based on Memorial Day falling on May 31. So Jam was at a later date and the drakes were about the same time.
 
wgmiller wrote:
Is it just me or was the GD hatch earlier-than-normal this year? I don't ever recall it coinciding with the Jam(ish) dates...

Some nice feesh ya got there!

It may have been a little early because of the warmer weather two weeks prior. Mo and I calculated that they must have started 5/19 or so in Glen Iron this year. I think last year was later. Very hard to predicate other than they will usually start about May 25 +/- 5 days at Glen Iron is my planning.

I have looked at some old stream reports to get some of the data.

Since we were in the middle of it, we had time to see a little more of the emergence and spinner (coffin flies) timing as it moved upstream. For example Millmont was full-on coffin flies Sunday and by Tuesday everything gone. We stayed next to the stream and they got into everything. They were in our kitchen, bathroom and even on the bottom of our mugs.

Crappy coloring due to the light, but this is a tree full of coffin flies next to the stream on Sunday night.
 
This shot is a classic, Dave. Amazing! Happy you guys enjoyed the trip.
 
Did you see the same thing upstream?


I had to leave late Thursday and the coffins were just starting to get thick, not quite like your photo just yet. I had a group of friends stay till saturday and said it was amazing though. We were catching drake dun fish all week so again I missed the huge swarm but still had a great hatch.

 
McSneek wrote:
Nice report Dave. My favorite stream and there isn’t a close second. Hoping temperatures moderate for some early summer fishing now that the green drake madness is about done for the year.

I would be interested to hear when things finish with the drakes on Penns. I find it completely fascinating the whole emergence timing.
 
Does anyone know what the lowest point on Penns is that has a drake hatch?
 
Great report and pics Dave. I was on Penns (Cherry Run lot) this weekend, Thursday, Saturday, and Monday evenings (and heading back out there in a few minutes) and saw massive coffin swarms Thursday and yesterday. Thursday it seemed to hit around 7:30 and was thicker than yesterday, but yesterday was impressive nevertheless. Those combined with sulphur spinners and sulphurs hatching made for a real bug soup. Also saw spent caddis on the water, though I haven't seen a lot of caddis lately. Saturday was cold and rainy and all I saw was an hours-long heavy sulphur hatch in the afternoon, nothing in the evening. It was nice to almost have the stream all to myself that day though and getting to fish a single hatch made it easier for me to hook up.

When I was fishing with drakeking Mon/Tues last week I couldn't keep the massive shucks that littered the surface off my hook. Good problem to have I guess.

 
Drake report - last night there were a handful of coffins around Cherry Run, but not nearly in the numbers of the few days before. Sulphurs dominated the evening. Cahills popping up too.
 
Great report. I fished Penns the weekend the 23rd-26th and was finally able to hit the drakes after usually getting out that way 2 weeks too early in most years. Was as advertised and a great time in the evening to experience it in person finally.
 
Back
Top