Penns Creek, Union County, 5/14-19/2026

DaveKile

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 13, 2021
Messages
7,514
City
Pennsylvania
This is a bit of composite report for the last several days from me while staying on Penns and during the Jam last weekend. I wish I could say it was a specturalur experience fishing, it has not. There have bee some good days but more often then not it has been very lack luster days especially in the evenings.

Weather:
The weather over the last several days started off very nice with day time temps in the mid 60's. In the evenings an extra layer was needed at dusk as it was getting colder into dark. By May 18 and 19 the temps started really cranking up into the lower 90's during the day. Just plan hot. A few cloudy periods and a quick passing shower or sprinkles, but nothing that has had any really impact on the stream for many days.

Stream:
With no rain the stream as been steadily dropping since the beginning of the month when I arrived. Last night the stream was at 240 CFS and started off at 300 CFS on May 14. The stream has been very clear of course and in great shape for wading. Water temps did jump up last nigh after the two hot days into the mid 60s.

Hatches:
The hatches have been dominated by March Browns and now seeing some of the smaller Grey Fox variants showing up. The March Browns are never really heavy, but sporadically hatch during the day and into the evening. What ihas been very missing for me is the lack of any real sulphur hatches. I have yet to see a good sulphur hatch at 8:15 with dozens of fish exploding. Zero. BWO have been around but not in any numbers or at good time of day with any impact on the fishing.

Fishing:
I think most anglers would say fishing has been tough. I do expect a few tough days on Penns, but not for days on end. There are a few guys nymphing hard that get a good day, but dry fly fishing is difficult and not very productive. I have fished many many locations from Tunnel Rd all the way down to below Wiekert. Poe Paddy was very busy over the weekend. It has been the same thing. I did have one good night in a small section of stream with sulfurs for a short blast, but it was very brief and isolated. I have not heard any angler I have spoken with saying they had a good or great night. I'm sure there are some, but not int he many locations I have hit. It has me wondering if the last years constant high rains for the month of May in 25 on Penns had some sort of impact on hatches this year? My guess is good as anyones. They are calling for 1.5" over the next few days with lower temps, let's see if that breaks up the pattern.


IMG_5532.jpeg



IMG_5521.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I've fished 10 of the last 12 nights. FWIW, hatches and risers were muted on other Centre and Blair Co streams last week. It actually made me question if the hatches were over. You can head hunt and get fish on top. Last night was the first time I experience a significant, intense hatch.
I think low water and unusual temps just has the hatches out of sync.
 
Last edited:
Also fished Penns over the weekend and it was tough on top. Saw a lot of March Brown spinners above Coburn which saved the trip fishing wise,but overall it was a lot of effort for little reward.
 
thanks for the report. it has been a tougher-than-normal spring for sure.
 
Wow those 2 guys in that picture have to be professional fishing models!

I was standing essentially in the same spot Thursday night and saw a bunch of what I assumed were little black caddis on the water. I was able to pick off most of the risers I saw with an #18 black ant.

Friday I was on Penns all day and hooked 2 and landed zero. Had a couple misses during that scene in the picture but hooked nothing. Fished through a pretty solid afternoon sulphur hatch with the Gambers on Friday and none of us saw a fish even so much as poke it's head up to look around during it. Even tried nymphing the riffle and not a take.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the report. I'm considering making a run up that way next week, I was hoping maybe for some drakes but who knows.

When I went up there in the beginning of May the hatches weren't great either, most of my fish were caught on a streamer or a nymph. I attributed it to the cold front/rain. I feel like the heat/sun from the last couple of days has the same effect
 
Wow those 2 guys in that picture have to be professional fishing models!

I was standing essentially in the same spot Thursday night and saw a bunch of what I assumed were little black caddis on the water. I was able to pick off most of the risers I saw with an #18 black ant.

Friday I was on Penns all day and hooked 2 and landed zero. Had a couple misses during that scene in the picture but hooked nothing. Fished through a pretty solid afternoon sulphur hatch with the Gambers on Friday and none of us saw a fish even so much as poke it's head up to look around during it. Even tried nymphing the riffle and not a take.
Finding professional fly fishing models is difficult. Thank you and Greg for standing in making it look easy.
 
Wow those 2 guys in that picture have to be professional fishing models!

I was standing essentially in the same spot Thursday night and saw a bunch of what I assumed were little black caddis on the water. I was able to pick off most of the risers I saw with an #18 black ant.

Friday I was on Penns all day and hooked 2 and landed zero. Had a couple misses during that scene in the picture but hooked nothing. Fished through a pretty solid afternoon sulphur hatch with the Gambers on Friday and none of us saw a fish even so much as poke it's head up to look around during it. Even tried nymphing the riffle and not a take.
I was also out last Friday - fished all day, caught 3 small brook trout. The browns just weren’t moving much.

Had a great opportunity at a really nice fish tucked under a tree branch on a March brown dry - perfectly executed bow and arrow cast, drag free drift, big eat, whiffed on the hookset.
 
My GF and I fished it downstream from the tunnel road lot last friday, way down by the right/left bend. Things started slow, but eventually we had rising fish, and then lots of rising fish. We each caught some,all browns, and all good size, first with sulfur parachutes, then with the largest rusty spinners I had, which were too small, but worked anyways. I had to drag Lissy off the stream at dark! She did exceptionally well for her first day on penns, I told her it's not always like that! I think it all comes down to location, timing, and luck. We happened to be at the right place at the right time. Her biggest one was about 16, mine was about 18. The rest were in the 12-14 range.
A bonus was the river otter/weasel??, the bald eagles, and the man eating watersnakes!!
The next night we went to the stretch above coburn, and pretty much nothing happening. we got a couple out of there, but it was tough. A few nights later, Shakey and I go to the same stretch and we had a fantastic 45 minutes of action at the end of the evening, so yeah, nothing is a given on Penns, and that is why we keep going back.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top