Penns Creek, Centre County, 5/14-16/20

DaveKile

Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 13, 2021
Messages
7,514
City
Pennsylvania
I had a fun week on Penns Creek this past week. Something I have been looking forward to for a long time. Usually, I only get a couple of days out in May so fitting in almost a week for a trip was awesome. I'll probably write more about the trip in a blog post shortly.

The weather was great for this time of year. We had a mix of sunny, but mostly cloudy days and only one day with some passing showers. Nothing that affected the water levels. Temps started off pretty cool with even freezing temps one of the mornings. Typically in the upper 50's during the day and even caught one day in the upper 70's, which felt pretty hot.

We fished several different areas of the stream. I need to say that the stream was crowded pretty much everywhere we went. Plenty of fly fishermen, other anglers, hikers, kayakers and even horseback riders. The most people I have seen near or on that stream.



The water on Penns was in excellent condition. Some very big storms the previous week helped us with the water coming down to ~650-580 CFS while we were fishing. Clarity of the water was ideal and typical for Penns with some of the mild stained green. I lost my thermometer last month so no clue what the temps were like.



The hatches on Penns evolved over the week. Not a lot of caddis, but pretty common to see March Browns and Gray Foxes during the day. (Yes I know some people regard them to be the same) Sulphurs really only came off in earnest on 5/15 and 5/16 after 8:00 pm. Big march brown spinner falls in the evening. I only saw them hit the water on 5/16.



Fishing was mostly nymphing during the day and big stonefly nymphs worked along with sulphur nymphs. The trout were not rising for much of anything during the trip even during the evening sulphur hatches. I was using some wet fly techniques with some flies that helped me land several.



 
Nice report, things were about the same for me with every fish coming on the nymph. This was the first time I got to see anything close to a March Brown spinnerfall and I'm going to make a point to hit one because even the staging looked awesome.

I also need to branch out more as I go to Cherry and work up EVERYTIME lol
 
Was there yesterday planning to fish for the next 3 days......Unfortunately seeing 12 cars at 7am in the parking lot at Cherry Run caused me to pass..... Went to Ingelby and more of the same.... Not in to "combat fishing" , so I stopped at Jonas' place and was told " since nobodies working it's been like Green Drake Week every week so far"...… Guess I'll have to wait till next year to fish it, when things go back to normal.....
 
I don't know if I'd give up that easy. Walk thru the tunnel on Tunnel Spur Rd and walk down 1.5 mi or so and you'll see less people.
 
We parked at Cherry Run and stayed for one afternoon. Yes that parking lot was overwhelming as well as some of the stream in that stretch. We found a few spots not as common to hit up for some fishing. A lot of Class A now open heading towards Glen Iron to spread things out too.
 
Thanks, Dave. Looks like you guys had fun. I'm guessing Spring Creek was even more crowded? I was going to head up for a few days, but now having second thoughts. I may have to go to Plan B ... which is actually Class A. 🙂
 
I fished Penn's last Friday evening and Saturday morning. It was definitely crowded. I had a group of seven descend on me below the wire on Saturday morning. Five went in 40' below me and the other two 70' above me. I finished nymphing the pocket I was in and exited and went fifty yards upstream of them. Five minutes later I was again surrounded. Comparing it to Erie steelhead fishing seems more accurate than GD Penn's pressure. I called it quits, not my scene.

We went to the lake (Poe valley) mid afternoon. I took a drive down to Poe Paddy. The parking lot at the end and both sides of the road were completely full. It was insane. The water levels dropping, nice weather, and the campgrounds opening must have been the perfect storm. It was more fun fishing it at 3000 CFS a couple of weeks ago.
 
Dave, it was nice meeting and speaking with you stream side on Thursday. Indeed, the creek was quite crowded. But if you knew where to look, and carried the patterns appropriate for the day - plenty of dry fly action could be had.

Jeff
 
I fished Penns on Friday, 5/15, in the C&R section and ran into the same crowds as the day went on. Yes there is a lot of water but more and more people kept showing up and staking out their spot in anticipation of the evening rise. It got ridiculous by about 6:00pm and I packed it in. Never saw so many vehicles in the parking area and along the road at Poe. I’ll be back after the green drake madness and hopefully enjoy less crowded conditions.

Although it’s a week later now, nymphing as usual picked up fish. #16 bead head pheasant tail was my best producer. Did get a couple on sulphurs when they started to trickle off mid-day when it clouded over for a bit.
 
Shoulda been there yesterday.

8k5rS0Z.jpg



DkD3XKI.jpg
 
Quick Late afternoon trip to Penns yesterday. Rain varied from light mist to heavy drizzle so only saw 2 other fisherman. Stood in a pool and enjoyed great top water action on brown drakes until the fish decided they wanted to take something else. Love that place!
 
5-23-5-25

Great Weekend Trip to Poe Paddy. Water was in great condition. Nymphing was slow throughout the day. A productive hatch of sulfurs and march browns came out in the evening both nights.
 
Penns Creek Angler reported hi temp of 69 the other day. That seemed high for the weather we have been having.
 
Was at Penns today in vicinity of Swift Run. Water was up a little and stained, but otherwise in real nice shape. I didn't see any risers and sparse hatches, so I just went with a Golden Retriever #8 with a little bit of lead and that did the trick. Netted a bunch (including two stocker rainbows that may have come from Big Poe) and also had some LDRs. I also broke a large fish off on 4x that freight trained for the heavy current as soon as I hooked him. I had at least 400yds of the stream to myself before the next person came into view. If you're getting crowded out- explore as there is plenty of productive water outside the regulated areas.
 
I love that heavy water right below Swift! And the rock wall above Swift. Looks like we won't make Penns this year so thanks for the reports!
 
To many people for me there this time Of year I don’t bother going until fall unless it’s a early 4:30-5:00 am lots of other just as good streams around there
 
Back
Top