Monocacy Creek - Northampton County - 26/Aug/25

wgmiller

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
3,213
City
Lancaster County
In keeping with fishing trout streams in away towns where my daughter is playing field hockey, last evening found her in Bethlehem at Moravian University. Needless to say, there are plenty of fishing options in the Lehigh Valley, but I always had Monocacy Creek on my radar. With MU being right along the banks of Monocacy, I knew where I was headed. I fished from roughly 2 - 6 PM, which was the earliest I could make it to Bethlehem. I always try to catch the morning hours, but it wasn't possible yesterday. I fished two stretches of Monocacy: up through Illick's Mill park and up and downstream of Schoenersville Road.

Parking in the lot at Illick's Mill and working upstream I found low conditions and no fish. Being that this stretch is stocked, it wasn't surprising in late August to find tough fishing. I found one or two people fishing the dam and one fly angler downstream of the dam, so I headed above the dam. I fished this stretch up to the railroad bridge and threw in the towel, walking back to the car. As I came upon the dam, I saw one of the spin anglers in the water, apparently trying to free his rig from the bottom. As I neared, I could see had a fish on. A really big fish. He had no net, so I hopped in and waded to his aid. It turns out he was fishing the "shelf" below the dam and had a pig wild brown on. I netted the fish, he took some pics, he ripped the gut swallowed line off the nightcrawler hook, and returned the fish to the water. He knew the rules that browns couldn't be harvested and that the fish was a wild brown. I have no doubt there are some monsters in that hole, as spring seeps flow in and the hole has the depth.

IMG_2123.JPEG

A beautiful Monocacy wild brown.

IMG_2118.JPEG

Illick's Mill Dam in all its glory

I made it back to my car and then fished downstream a ways past the nature area. I didn't find any fish in this stretch, but it was some nice water. Upon returning to my car, I relocated to the Schoenersville Road area and fished downstream of St. Luke's/Moravian a bit, then fished back upstream. I was able to move several fish on streamer patterns, but had no takers. Whenever I fish new water the first time I'm less concerned about catching fish than I am with "seeing what's in there and where they are". Slinging a streamer seems to be the best way to get them to move and show themselves, even in low and clear water. It gives me an idea where they hold and provides a starting point upon returning to a stream.

IMG_2139.JPEG


IMG_2134.JPEG

Thriving in the shadows of industry

IMG_2130.JPEG

60 degree water in late August? I'll take it!

Thoughts on Monocacy:

It's yet another wild trout stream that the PFBC stocks fish over (in this case, rainbows over wild browns). It's a stream that sees a good bit of pressure, given its urban location and accessibility. Based on the number of nightcrawler containers I saw at various points along the banks, it also sees a good bit of harvest. Like so many other streams in urban areas, the threats this stream must endure are seemingly endless (thermal pollution, industrial pollution, angling pressure, etc.). It seemed to be in quite good shape yesterday, given so many threats. The flow was around 30 CFS, which was about half its seasonal average for this time of year.

On a related/unrelated note, I had my license checked by a WCO for only the second time in my angling life. As I was working my up the railroad tracks from Schoenersville Road, a WCO was walking down toward me. He checked my license and we chatted for a bit. It was WCO Rudd, who covers Northampton County. Super chill dude who was checking up on Monocacy after receiving reports of browns being harvested. He said they pay a lot of attention to boaters in the summer months, but he wanted to pay some attention to Monocacy during the slower months.

I know Monocacy has a lot of nice fish in it and it was fun to explore its waters for a few hours. I look forward to making it back someday to fish some new stretches and revisit known holding water. Maybe someday I'll be able to catch as many fish on Monocacy as Jun T Outdoors does! 😀
 
Graduated from Moravian back in 81. Spent many evening on the stretch you describe. At that time, the coolest part of fishing that area was seeing all the pheasants in addition to the browns.

The women's field hockey field was right behind the dorms. The pheasant mating rituals and early morning crowing would wake me up.
 
Stream is soo mid

For its location I find it pretty intriguing. It'll never be what it could be, simply based on its location. The fact it stays cold and supports a naturally reproducing population of wild trout is pretty impressive, IMO.

"Catch and release" from the bait/spin crowd will never bode well for the wild brown trout, but it's ultimately better than allowing 100% harvest.
 
Beauty fish. Very cyclical crick. It was something else 5 years ago and at other times further back. It may rise again, especially if Jun T reads all his negative comments, and then fall again, and so and so on.... 😉
 
Dear wgmiller,

I used to fish it 30 plus years ago. When I got out of the USAF in 1987, I had a buddy I served with who was from Hellertown. He showed me a lot of places that he used to fish when he was younger. One of them was the Monocacy.

We fished it with him a couple of times and while we never hit any hatches, we reliably caught fish on muskrat nymphs, cress bugs, and sow bugs. My brother and i went back without him too. It was funny fishing in backyards off Rte. 512, but no one seemed to be bothered by us, and we certainly didn't bother them. Unfortunately, by the time I moved to upstate NY landowners on the stream started getting a little pissy about access.

I haven't been back there since about 1993 or so. It's good see there are still fish in that over-developed corridor.

Regards,

Tim Murphy 🙂
 
Only a middle school English teacher watching the daily torture of the language would get that. Ok, maybe the father of a 12 y/o girl. 🤣
Well Jifigz is a highschool freshman English teacher so the shoe does fit. I was just trolling WGMiller. It’s a nice stream and a very nice post. I wasn’t being serious.
 
I know very well what jifigz does. I got the years wrong. He's still in a better position to recognize that teenie slang than most of us. I had boys and they're both 30-ish. Their jargon was less annoying and dramatic.
 
I know very well what jifigz does. I got the years wrong. He's still in a better position to recognize that teenie slang than most of us. I had boys and they're both 30-ish. Their jargon was less annoying and dramatic.

Yeah the use of the word “mid” was to get Jifigz riled up and Jordan creek is a is an inside joke for the some of the Lehigh valley regulars on here. None of it was serious. We’re all friends.
 
Never even considered you might be targeting intentionally. I did know where it would lead, so good job then.
 
Monocacy was great in the early 90s. Off of Macada Rd. there is/was a long flat stretch. The fish were always tough there because they had all day to inspect your flies and were very picky. One particular day, a guy was already fishing that section. I watched him really raking the fish. I stopped to say hello before heading downstream several blocks to my favorite section. He was using a black #20s midge pupa (simple black thread, gray antron for tiny wing and black dubbing for head), and would cast it real close to a rising fish before giving the fly quick strips over the trout's head, which then resulted in explosive strikes. A really good technique that worked for me there in future visits. I can only imagine what that creek is like today with all of the development there.
 
Back
Top