Little J, Huntington Co., 04/20/2009

3wt7X

Active member
Joined
Nov 19, 2008
Messages
704
I had the day off on monday, so I decided to experience my first grannom caddis hatch on the Little J. I made the decision despite the weatherman's prediction of rain throughout the day and it turned out pretty good. I arrived in Spruce Cr. at about 09:30 am and I immediately noticed multiple fish rising at the bridge. I assumed that they were eating BWOs, but upon closer look I observed the grannoms.
Earlier in the day the water conditions were nice with good clarity, but just enough of a green tint to keep the trout comfortable. The weather conditions were less than favorable with mid to upper 40 degree temperatures and light rain. The wind was variable and got annoying at times.
I began by using a standard size 16 tan elk hair caddis and I managed a few in the morning. At that point, I was observing most of the rise forms on the opposite bank, so I waded down the middle of the stream and made 40 to 50 foot casts along the banks. This technique produced strikes, but I got a little frustrated with the number of fish rising compared to the number of fish that I was catching, so I sat down a did a little observing. The first thing that I noticed was that the grannoms seemed to be coming off in spurts. In other words, there would be a period of about 10 minutes when I did not see a caddis on the water, then they would come off strong and the trout would get on them. I also had the opportunity to examine a few grannoms on the stream bank and I noticed how dark their bodies were compared to their light tan wing.
The final thing that I noticed after sitting on the streambank for about half an hour was the fact that there was numerous trout rising in the water where I was formerly wading as well as along the stream bank where I was sitting. I did the logical thing and made my next cast from the seated position that I was in and immediately hooked up. I slowed my approach for the rest of the day and shortened my casts. This seemed to improve my presentation and catch rate. I also notced that if you throw a couple mends during a single cast it emulates the fluttering motion of the caddis and usually triggers a strike.
I apologize for the long report, but I enjoyed fishing the grannoms on the J. The fish were all very healthy and I took a couple in the 14 inch range along with a nice one at the end of the day, which I did not get a chance to see. The water had risen and become off color and the fish immediately took off downstream with my caddis leaving me running after him with no avail. It could have been a 16 incher in strong current, or a 24inch Donny Beaver special brownie. I'm going with the later. :-D
 
I think that last one is wild. They are all awesome fish,
 
Not that there would be an absolute answer...but could we expect the grannom hatch to stay on through the weekend?

Boss_steb
 
3wt,

Nice report and beautiful fish.

Boss,

The hatch started in earnest Thursday April 16, I don't think the main grannom hatch will still be going this Saturday. There may still be caddis hatching though. Last year I was a little late for the grannoms, but there was a nice hatch of black bodied caddis in a size 16.

Here is a nice rainbow I took on the "J" Saturday the 18th.
 
jayL wrote:
I think that last one is wild. They are all awesome fish,

Not that I'm an expert on this subject, but I would second that. The fins and tail are perfect, and the spotting is completely different than the 2 fish above. All great fish none the less.
 
ryguyfi wrote:
jayL wrote:
I think that last one is wild. They are all awesome fish,

Not that I'm an expert on this subject, but I would second that. The fins and tail are perfect, and the spotting is completely different than the 2 fish above. All great fish none the less.

LOL!

Maybe we should be taking scale samples to determine the origins of our trout. I think these pics are inconclusive and over analyzing them is silly in this case. We know the J has stocked fingerlings and we know it has wild fish. We also know that they both grow up into big, fat, healthy, pretty, perfect looking trout.

Kev
 
PennKev wrote:
LOL!

Maybe we should be taking scale samples to determine the origins of our trout. I think these pics are inconclusive and over analyzing them is silly in this case. We know the J has stocked fingerlings and we know it has wild fish. We also know that they both grow up into big, fat, healthy, pretty, perfect looking trout.

Kev

No over analysis. Just think it's wild.
 
Albatross,
That is a very nice rainbow. Did you take him on top with the grannoms? I would like to catch one of those good sized Little J bows, but it seems like the browns rise a little more readily. I did not think that those pictures would cause a controversy, but for what it is worth I think the last picture was a wild brown.
 
The rainbow took a green emerging sparkle pupa near the bottom in about 4 feet of water where a riffle enters a pool.

I may have hooked this same fish twice in 10 minutes. Either that or I had her twin sister on the line for about 45 seconds till she threw the hook. Only thing I know for sure is I had two solid hookups on big rainbows standing in the same spot in a span of 10 minutes. These were my only two hookups all day.

I've had a small debate going recently with my fishing buddies about the possibility that we are seeing some naturally reproducing rainbows in the J. I caught the fish pictured above at least 4 miles from the Espy farm.
 
That's why guys love the river, beautiful fish
 
Back
Top