Jersey Shore (IBSP), Ocean Co., NJ, 12/02/11

Fishidiot

Active member
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
9,921
With all the great reports and internet buzz about the great fall run on the NJ shore, I had to make it back, if only for a day, to see for myself. Heading straight out from work on Thursday evening to complete the drive, I was able to be out before dawn today. Conditions: blue sky, high temp in the low 50s and water temp about the same; sporadic bird activity but nothing close to shore except some cormorants patrolling the wash. Wind was from the S/SW at about 5-10 mph. Moderate to heavy surf with clear water. No bait was visible in the water.
I had considered a different location at the shore, maybe Long Beach Island, due to the accounts describing very heavy fishing pressure at Island Beach State Park lately. Nevertheless, IBSP is a long time favorite of mine and I figured, being a weekday, the crowds would be tolerable. This morning in Seaside Heights, they were. Beautiful morning and a tolerable number of anglers. I didn’t see a fish caught. After breakfast, I headed into the park and spent most of the day around Area 10 and 23. A23 was very crowded, the thickest I’ve ever seen. I didn’t even consider walking to the jetty as there were parked cars as far as I could see looking down the beach toward the jetty. I was able to squeeze in and fly fish a bit but, had folks been any closer, I would have grabbed a spin rod or gone elsewhere. I just don’t care to FF when it’s that crowded and the wind is blowing. There were also a ton of boats just off the beach in this section (see photo). Not sure how the boat guys did. I didn’t see them catching much when I paid attention. After hanging out a couple hours up to high tide, and seeing no fish caught by any beach anglers (and I watch with binos), I decided to head north. I like to fish the upper park when the tide is going out and there are often fewer fishermen. To my surprise, I had the maintenance shed section virtually all to myself. On my second or third cast, I got a bass and thought, “okay, it’s game time and I’m all alone!” Alas, it was the only strike I got and, after another hour of casting practice, I decided to call it a day about an hour before dark. The one bass I caught was the only fish I saw brought up on the beach today and I watched hundreds of guys throwing bait and lures all day. Maybe it went off somewhere at IBSP today but I checked much of the park and didn’t witness it myself. Anglers I’d talked to reported mostly poor to no fish caught (one fellow said there had been some good fishing at A23 early this morning).
Disappointing considering all the buzz. The salt season is over for me but, with the relatively warm water temps, it wouldn’t surprise me if good fishing continues well up to Christmas.
 

Attachments

  • Area 23.jpg
    Area 23.jpg
    35.7 KB · Views: 12
  • Big Surf.jpg
    Big Surf.jpg
    43.6 KB · Views: 17
  • Daybreak.jpg
    Daybreak.jpg
    30.8 KB · Views: 10
  • Striper 1.jpg
    Striper 1.jpg
    70.5 KB · Views: 9
Excellent report!
I also saw all the hype on the internet. I was going down myself, but I didn't want to have another bad fishing experience.
Sandbars are just before the boats in your pic. Most of the bass stay out past them and the surf casters can't reach the fish. If you had a small boat and a spin rod..... I"m pretty sure you would have bailed them pretty good.
Too many times I have had my heart broken with a fly rod wading at IBSP......... now I only go fishing there with a boat and regular tackle. I learned from experience!
 
I wish you would of told me you were coming down Dave I might of been able to join you .
 
An Alvey setup will hit the boats from the beach....even cast over them.. from the picture it is not that far to the boats even with a standard spinning rig..A fly rod no, but all ya do is find a slough going away from beach and throw some chum to bring em in past the bar..then hit them with the fly rod..
 
Fredrick wrote:
I wish you would of told me you were coming down Dave I might of been able to join you .

I thought about contacting you but the trip was spur of the moment and I wasn't sure I could make it until Thursday. Hopefully, we can team up at the shore in spring 2012.
Don't give up on the NJ shore anytime soon - I'm guessing the fish will be around awhile longer.
 
1wt wrote:
Excellent report!
I also saw all the hype on the internet. I was going down myself, but I didn't want to have another bad fishing experience.
Sandbars are just before the boats in your pic. Most of the bass stay out past them and the surf casters can't reach the fish. If you had a small boat and a spin rod..... I"m pretty sure you would have bailed them pretty good.
Too many times I have had my heart broken with a fly rod wading at IBSP......... now I only go fishing there with a boat and regular tackle. I learned from experience!


If this has been your experience, then by all means stick to boats and spin gear. It is indeed much easier.
Just speaking for myself, fishing from the beach is a personal passion. Ever since I was a kid, wading the suds has had great appeal. There's something about standing and fishing in moving water that comprises, for me, the essence of fishing.
As for spin fishing - while I didn't spin fish on this trip - I always take spin gear to the shore and have no qualms about using it. The beach is a long drive for me and I'm not going to get there and then spend the day at a sports bar because the wind is too strong for FFing. In this particular case, the spin guys weren't catching either. Perhaps if they were getting bass on metal out beyond the bar and FFing proved completely fruitless, I might have gone for my spin rod. However, when the winds are calm, I like FFing. I've caught enough bass and blues on plugs and metal and, while this is always a blast, I'd rather fly fish and catch one or two than spin fish and catch several.
As the saying goes, to each his own.
 
Great report! I will be on the surf a few nights this week.
 
Nice report Dave...I was up there on December 3rd, 2011. It was a spontanious trip, as well, and I just took out a party boat to Diamond Jig some bass. I had a good time and the drive was very reasonable. We'll have to do the surf fishing thing one of these times. I am a little intimidated, but with a knowledgable guy like you, I think I can figure it out.
 
Fishidiot wrote:
Fredrick wrote:
I wish you would of told me you were coming down Dave I might of been able to join you .

I thought about contacting you but the trip was spur of the moment and I wasn't sure I could make it until Thursday. Hopefully, we can team up at the shore in spring 2012.
Don't give up on the NJ shore anytime soon - I'm guessing the fish will be around awhile longer.


Call me anyway I would of called out of work to go with you and I could of helped you out on the drive some .
 
I was probably a few feet from you. Guys on the bar got a few but generally more of the same. No fish. I never schlepp the fly rod and stripping basket anymore. The tip of sandy hook is a fishy spot but again it timing. The surf is a low percentage deal unless you live at the shore. Look at it this way. Your getting skunked in the big pool in the first gamelands on the wb. Maybe so but there are a hundred fish within casting distance. Your getting skunked in the surf and the fish are a mile away. I Do it, probably Friday but it's a very low percentage deal. The guy who holds the striper record fished 200 days a year. He lived at the shore. Now, my wifes a peach but 200 days a year? The crowd looked like opening day on the wissihickon.
 
3wt7X wrote:
Nice report Dave...I was up there on December 3rd, 2011. It was a spontanious trip, as well, and I just took out a party boat to Diamond Jig some bass. I had a good time and the drive was very reasonable. We'll have to do the surf fishing thing one of these times. I am a little intimidated, but with a knowledgable guy like you, I think I can figure it out.

You bet. We'll round up Fredrick on the way over and hit the beach in spring 2012. As others have posted in this thread (and I frequently emphasize myself).....surf fishing is indeed a crap shoot and timing is everything. As this trip proves, even when the reports are spectacular, one can miss the fish. Speaking for myself, I still love it. I've had the opportunity to surf fish many, if not most, of the states between Texas and Maine. It's this way most everywhere, regardless of species. And for me, the drive time to the beach regardless of where I lived was, and is, measured in hours rather than minutes. Just seeing the ocean is something I'll never take for granted.
I try to keep this in mind when I see folks with out-of-state plates on my home waters here in central PA.
 
If I don't go to SR, I'm thinking of hitting the salt this weekend...
 
Back
Top