Hay Creek, Berks County, 5/21-22/16

Joined
Aug 10, 2013
Messages
248
City
Berks/Tioga County
Weather: Around 62° both days, cloudy with an occasional shower.
Clarity: Clear on 5/21 and off color on 5/22.
Time: 2-4:30 PM (5/21) 9-11:30 AM (5/22)
Hatches: Midges, Sulphurs

I started off on 5/21 using a black woolly bugger with a heavy line setup, fishing in the waterfalls that plunged into the pools. Had a few follows in the first hour, but couldn't convince a take. Switched over to a BH Prince nymph and got a small rainbow just before heading out due to rain. On my way out, I talked to a guy that gave me a fly to use to have better luck, and told me how to fish it correctly. The sulphurs were coming off lightly and he said it was the perfect time for the fly. The next day, 5/22, I went back to fish the same stretch in the now off color water. I used the fly that the man had given me, because it was working for him the previous day. Drifted it with an indicator I'm the same pools as the previous day and ended up hooking 4 rainbows, and losing one of them all on his fly. All 3 were around 14" and the one I lost was a bit bigger. Saw 4 other fly fishermen, and one young kid with bait there. Still some nice fish left in rustic park from the rodeo. If anybody can give a name to a size 16 hook with hares ear dubbing, a tungsten beadhead, and some pheasant tail as hackle, please let me know. As far as I know it is a made up fly, but it sure does work. I feel bad fishing behind the other people and catching all the fish they tried for.
 
I am plan on heading out around 4 today and taking my son over to Rustic Park area to do some fishing. I am going to have my 5wgt in tow, I am not sure if he is going to want to use his fly rod or throw lures though. I have been checking my Gazetteer and browsing the web to find a new spot to try today, I was up in the air between Hay, French at Warwick park & Trout Run Res.

A picture might help identify that fly for you,better then a description.
 
Can't get the picture of it on here... Seemed to be lots of fish, just very picky. The ones I got were below the pavilion. Let me know how it goes if you do go.
 
We ended up staying in the top handful of pools, my son wasn't in the mood to do any walking to try anywhere else. Especially after he saw a few small trout pulled out by someone using a black woolly bugger ( the guy then gave him one ). We did get some hits,but, only ended up with a single 2&1/2 inch shiner for the day.
 
That's what happened to me... This guy apparently had a 35-40 fish day on that fly. You can catch them when the water is really muddy with white streamers. I used to catch a lot of chubs with corn there...
 
Back
Top