Elk Creek, Erie Co, 12/2-3/10

MapleSteely

New member
Joined
Aug 15, 2007
Messages
9
Fished Elk Creek a couple times after the rain, and had good success while fishing different sections of the creek.

Crowds over the past week were tolerable (almost non-existant in some cases!) - and the few folks I did meet were great sportsman. Met guys from several areas that had far more travel time than myself, so I felt 'lucky', and enjoyed chatting with them while on the stream.

Fish took a variety of flies - copper johns were the hot ticket one day, while egg-sucking leech (wine colored), eggs, and prince nymphs all turned a few few as well. Thursday (Dec 2) proved to be the 'numbers' day, while Friday, Dec 3 rewarded me with a very nice male that cartwheeled out of the water (probably about 38 degrees) that truly was quite a rush! Hooked into that big one literally after landing a smaller 18" 'skipper' just two or three cast before - the contrast in their battles really woke me up. And, for a refreshing change, the big one didn't get away - at least long enough for a picture as he was released, along with all the others.

Never got above freezing, and roads were a little slick on Friday AM, but streams held up well and lets hope the weatherman misses on the long range forecast for Erie County.....forecast is calling for even colder temps with perhaps more significant snow events, so not sure if I'll have many more steelhead days left.

On a side note - the last day I fished was by "Millers Landing" - ie the old "Whiteman's Bridge" area. Looks like a forester is harvesting quite a few of the (big) trees adjacent to the access area (private property). Dodged several large tree limbs that went floating downstream while forester was cutting away......

(all pics taken with self-timer, so kinda tough to get things set up the way it was planned)

Nice Male taken on November 29


Not many guys out - took several out of this hole, but this was the only one that cooperated for a pic


Found a "honey hole" around 2 PM -



Action died after 3 PM - but the better part of an hour it was almost non-stop action - egg sucking leech was the "fly of the hour!"
a
dec2lastoneatcliffs.jpg


Dusk and snow hit about the same time - but one last fish before tracking back to the car.....


Elk Creek on Dec 3 - saw maybe 5 guys all day



This male took an oregon cheese egg pattern, and the first time he 'rolled' (before his acrobatic jump) I swear it had shoulders on it!




Close up
 
Looks like you had one hell of a run, nice to see that.
Beautiful fish too!
 
Damn! Nice fish maple
 
Wow - some nice fish and pretty good pics for the timer. That last one is about as impressive as they get.
 
Real nice--and there I was over fishing the Mile Creeks on Thursday....Nice fish Maple.
 
That last one may be the coolest looking steel I ever saw from up there. Looks like a male brown with rainbow markings.
Nice day.
 
So, did you figure out where all the fish have gone? 😎

Very nice soup-maker, that last one. Glad you had a productive outing.
 
shame most guys quit when the big runs come in and fishing gets good , once the "T" shirts dissapear the fish appear !
 
Thanks for the info. I am going there from Wed to Fri next week.
I hope I have as much success as you did.
 
Thanks for the comments - it's refreshing to post on a message board without all the bashing. I don't post often, but after reading some of the poor reports, thought I'd offer another viewpoint.

I've been fishing PA streams and the lake for steelies (back then there were coho and some chinook) since 1976, and every year poses a new set of challenges. From more crowds, more posted property, new or different techniques, stream structural changes (the most dramatic in my opinion was after the hurricane aftermath from 2003) - it's always been a good and memorable experience nonetheless. The quality of my trips have not disappointed me in the least. My long-time best fishing friends have moved out of the area, so the trips are solo now - aside from the dog - and he never complains about the fishing.

Good luck to all - the weather is starting to get a bit nasty up there presently, but hopefully we'll get a mid-December thaw. It's still too early to write off 2010! (c'mon, just one more hookup ! ! )
 
Nice work and it's obvious you know how to work those waterways. That last fish is an absolute brute and in my opinion, worthy of a magazine cover.

I saw on the Today show this morning that Erie is expecting to have 3'+ of snow on the ground by the end of the day tomorrow. Looks like it could be a rough December there and downwind of all the Great Lakes.

Thanks for sharing your trip report!
 
I'm not sure which is more impressive...your fishing ability or the talent with the camera. Your photos are outstanding! That last fish, and those photos are treasures for sure. Congratulations on a successful outing. Was that last fish in the photos pulled out of the stretch in the 6th photo? I believe I recognize the area as it's one of my favorite places on Elk.
 
I keep looking at this post and man Maple this is awesome. What a great trip. Makes me want to go to Erie and actually catch some fish.

Thanks!
 
Great report and photo's!! I'm right there with dkile as I find myself coming back and admiring your pic's. I am off the week after X-Mas and hope to get a shot at some steel providing the tribs are'nt froze over. Great report.

Jeff
 
Back
Top