Conestoga River Lancaster County 5/28&5/30/15

salvelinusfontinalis

Active member
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
7,267
I was fortunate enough to fish my home river twice this past week. Both days I had from sun up to about 3pm, which unfortunately, means I missed prime time on the river.

The smallmouth are on the edges of the river by the afternoon. I took notice, through wet wading, that the edges of the river are cooler in the morning than they feel by 11am. I did not catch a ton of smallmouth in the past two days but what I got were good sized and strong fighters. All took an articulated black bleeding minnow pattern I tie.

The past few days large Cahills start hatching the second the sun starts beating down on the water. Not in "cloud like numbers" or anything but enough that the carp are taking notice, but no leaping smallmouth after them. I will note that they must hatch for many miles of river because you can see the emerger carcasses floating down stream just about anywhere you fish if you look for a minute or 2.

Watching carp rise the first day prompted me to bring dries on the second day. One the first day I went 3/5 on carp. All on my black bleeding minnow pattern. Since it's tied with a crap ton of black marabou, they likely thought it was a leach. Today I went 8/10 on carp. Split between Dean Myers bead chain crayfish pattern and Cahills. Managed to take 2 carp on top. All of the carp were monsterous in size, not that there weren't small ones but I targeted the biggest fish. I will note that the conestoga is a wonderful carp fishery that would rival any in the state.

A few things I witnessed of interest.

Saw a guy keep over his limit of bass. Saw him fishing later too upstream of the first location. Such a shame.

Saw a duck get eaten by what appeared to be a musky.

People are amazed to see a fly fisherman on the river and WILL talk to you at LENGTH about it.

Had a large musky chase a large smallie away from my fly and then caught nothing. Hard to swallow but cool to watch.

I'm addicted to WW fly-fishing. Hard to think about sulphurs and trout.
 
Thanks for the update. Been thinking with this hot weather it's time to hit the Conestoga for some smallmouth. I didn't think you could keep bass at this time of year?
 
Awesome report. I'd love to see a musky take out a young goose or 100 sometime. Down here on the Shenandoah there were a couple bass leaping for cahills last night, though the bass strangely shut down around 7:30 while the hatch continued. Caught everything on clousers.
 
Nice report, Sal. Warmwater fishing is a blast. I think I enjoy it as much as trout fishing too. I went 4/6 this morning on carp, but not on the 'Stoga. I found a mulberry tree that was already dropping red berries with a pod of carp set up around it and working the top. I caught my first carp on top this AM on one of my deer hair mulberry flies. Definitely made my morning. The report of the musky activity is really cool as well.
 
Great report Sal. Thanks. To see a ducking get eaten by a Muskie is just plain spectacular! Sorry you didn't catch that other pesky Muskie. Nice hook up ratio on the carp by the way.
 
Don't give up on that muskie - good chance you can return and stick him.

Neat report. It's getting to be WW time!
 
Fishidiot wrote:
Don't give up on that muskie - good chance you can return and stick him.

Neat report. It's getting to be WW time!

Anyone know a good Mallard pattern? Hehe.

I got out with the big 6wt for the first time this year today. Usual SC PA warmwater mix of species. Highlights were one Smallie approaching 12" and a 9" Rock Bass...probably the biggest one I've ever caught. Steady action for a couple hours on the water though. Smallies were near the bank off current breaks...still Spring time mode. I got very little action (other than Fallfish) from the more mid-Summer Smallie haunts in mid-current bouldery areas. No toothy encounters.
 
I was on codorus tonight and I believe i and an another angler saw an Esox take a mallard. It was quite shocking. Like a 55 gallon drum falling in the water. This was within city limits...
 
Those are carp eating the baby ducks.
 
I fished the Conestoga at Perlman Park on Wednesday the 20th from 6:30 to 8:00 and got 2 little Smallmouths and 3 Rock bass, and then got a solid fish that jumped three times. I knew it wasn't a bass, but didn't know what it was, it ran right upstream to me and jumped a fourth time. I finally landed and released a heavy 18 inch rainbow. What a shock!

I also fished the same section yesterday from 9:00 to 1:00 and did nothing.
 
The guy kept over his limit of bass? That's not all that was wrong; bass are not open to harvest at the moment in inland waters.

Regarding Pearlman Park, bass habitat is poor, at least for legal size fish. I once investigated it as a possible fingerling sampling site and was not impressed with the habitat in general...wide and shallow, at least where I looked at it.
 
Swattie87 wrote:
Anyone know a good Mallard pattern? Hehe.

Yup!

Merganser%20Better.jpg




http://rusuperfly.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=2&products_id=20
 
That's pretty cool and I suppose they would work. I would think the little legs swimming is a trigger though.

I never even thought about out of season bass. Really I was there to target carp anyways, but I should read the regs now that Iam targeting so many more species. I never worry about harvest regs since I never keep fish anyways.
 
And as far as bass goes, if you're not on protected stretches of the Susky or Juniata during the "closed season" (or feeder tribs for a short distance), you're good.
 
Back
Top