Brodhead Creek, Monroe County, 05/17/2010

greenlander

Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
807
Fished the Brodhead for the first time today. Despite the underwhelming impression of the surrounding area driving in via 22/33, once we found ourselves on the creek near Anamolink, we were impressed with how picturesque the creek was. Fished from a few hundred yards below top of the channelized stretch up to the large still pool below the train bridge.

Time: 2pm - 7:30pm
Flow: ~ 80 CFS
Water Temp: No thermometer, I'd guess high 50s

Early afternoon had sporadic bug activity with a nice handful of large March Browns flying around and we were able to land 4 fish on March Brown dries.

Bug activity slowed for a couple hours but by 5:30pm or so was really heating up. Not a ton of bugs on the water, but plenty in the air (and still a good number on the water). We saw two colors of Caddis, March Browns, some very large Black Stoneflies, a bright yellow-bodied fly with two sets of wings that my companion said was a golden Stonefly (though I disagreed), midges, Sulfurs, and a white fly that was immitated well by a light Cahill.

Seriously, everything was in the air.

Despite this, no rising fish. Anywhere. Neither of us so much as hooked a fish for the last 3 hours on the stream.

Between the two of us, six fish came to hand in the 5.5 hours we were on the stream. All fish were taken on the surface, which is a first in my fishing experience. About a dozen different nymphs were drifted and swung through, with no takers.

Not that landing only a few fish is foreign territory to me, but based on observations on the stream fish population seemed low. Anyone know if this is the case?

Couple of pics attached.
 

Attachments

  • brodhead1.jpg
    brodhead1.jpg
    241.4 KB · Views: 13
  • brodhead2.jpg
    brodhead2.jpg
    206.4 KB · Views: 14
Nice report. This is an example of what we're seeking here on PAFF with regards to fishing reports: specific information (and you remembered to include the county in the title line). Pics aren't necessary but they add to the report and often folks click on the thread to see the pics.

I'm not a regular in that part of the state so will have to defer to a Poconos guy/gal for comment on what's typical there.
 
I have to agree with GM; the Brodhead always seem to have lots of fish; though they aren't always on a tear. Don't even want to get into the stocking over wild fish issue. I've always caught the vast majority of my fish using wets and nymphs there. (and you can't be bashful with the weight) The riffles and fast runs have been the most generous to me.
 
Back
Top