Big Spring Run, Cumberland County, 1/19/2014

Alnitak

Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2014
Messages
314
Yesterday my nephew and I headed out to fish since he didn't have school. With warmer air temps, optimism was high and we decided to go to Big Spring Run in Cumberland County. The stream was *packed* with people fly fishing. Between Nealy Road and and the old hatchery there were at least 20 other people.

Air temps were about 43F when we arrived at 11am, didn't get a water temp, but it was nice and warm like one would expect from a high flow-rate spring-fed stream like that. We saw a few flies hatching--mayflies of some kind--but weren't able to catch any to see what they were. We fished for a few hours, mostly with some scuds and cress bugs I had tied the day before. I had two bites, one a smaller fish I missed and one a big guy that took my fly and line in one chomp--the 5x tippet was a bit too thin for him. My nephew had one fish about 18" on the hook but it jumped and tossed it off--he was frustrated.

Lots of huge rainbows were seen hanging in the slower water between patches of weeds. You could see them occasionally snacking on scuds and cress bugs as they drifted by them. I managed to get a few to look at my scud but they would turn away right at the last moment. Smart old fish. I decided to try something different to tempt them, figuring that something unique might work, so I put on a hot pink San Juan I tied and that was the fly that got chomped and lost, so the idea worked, but after another 30 minutes of trying the only open section of stream we had available, I changed back to a scud.

Near 3pm the winds really started to pick up, making casting difficult, so we headed out but swore we'd be back. My nephew is very talented and very determined, and he left swearing he'd be back there until he lands a big one. It was great to see such huge colorful fish in that crystal-clear water. I've attached a photo of one guy that was in the 24" range based on what we could compare him to. Just hanging in the water.

On the way back to Lancaster we made a brief detour to Clarks Creek, but only managed to get in about 30 minutes of fishing--road work left us sitting in traffic for 15 minutes or more and reduced time on the stream. Clark's was of course much colder and the air temps there was 38F. I managed to have a few fish taste my Prince but none that held it long enough for me to set the hook.

Jeff
 

Attachments

  • 500-02392.jpg
    500-02392.jpg
    113 KB · Views: 11
I fished it yesterday and got the big skunk. Saw a few other folks, not a lot. I was hoping the bite was going to be on bit it surely wasn't. Maybe I was doing something wrong, I don't know. It seemed like the bite was off. O well it was only my2x there. Saw lots of big fish.

Can someone tell me if you use split shot to get the small midge patterns down, or just let them sink? I maybe should have tried a black bugger, but I didn't.
 
It's a stream that sees a lot of pressure. And the tactics employed to catch the big fish there are a bit unique in a sense. You have to learn where they live, how they feed, and their characteristics. Stick with it as you will eventually be rewarded with some nice fish. But until you unlock those techniques, don't get frustrated. With BS running a fairly consistent temperature, "the bite" is more predictable than that of a freestone stream where temperatures affect feeding to a larger extent.

And that's definitely a big "tanker" bow. You'll see some big brookies, but only big by wild brook trout standards.
 
I was there on Friday. I won't go on the weekends anymore because of the "20" people. I got the skunk too. Tried cress, scuds, a few midges, but most of the day I pounded the crap out of sculpins. Got a few chases but no takes.
 
It must just be tough lately for whatever reason. I talked to one dude there who fishes there a few times a week and caught 1 on Monday. He did give me a few tips to try next time. I 'll be going back soon.
 
Folks,
Please keep in mind that brook trout are currently spawning in BS, mainly in the upper reaches of the FFO section. Please watch your wading, avoid redds, and be aware that brooks on gravel are busy. Take measures you deem appropriate in the presence of spawning trout. Also, watch your step in the Phase II restoration section as small plants have been placed in the filled areas.
 
I did see a few redds. Didn't see any brookies on them, though. That stream, I hate wading it haha! So mucky.

There was someone fishing the lower restoration work. Looks like it was a successful job! We fished mostly the upper end of the restoration. Didn't make it the whole way up to the ditch.
 
I was at big Spring as well a couple days ago and saw only a few redds, but, they did have paired Brookies on them.... That made my day
 
Back
Top